Seeing a dark, tarry mess in the toilet is terrifying. It’s not just a "gross" moment; it's one of those visceral shocks that makes your heart skip. You probably think of blood as bright red. When it turns black, something has changed chemically. It’s scary because it’s unfamiliar.
Black blood in stool—medically known as melena—is basically digested blood. It has traveled through the gauntlet of your digestive enzymes and stomach acid. By the time it exits, it’s sticky, foul-smelling, and looks like used motor oil or wet coffee grounds. It’s usually a sign that something is bleeding higher up in your "plumbing," like your esophagus, stomach, or the first part of the small intestine.
Don't panic immediately, but don't ignore it either.
Is it actually blood or just last night's dinner?
Before we dive into the medical alarms, we have to talk about the "fakes." Honestly, a lot of things can turn your poop black that have absolutely nothing to do with internal bleeding.
If you’ve been taking Pepto-Bismol (bismuth subsalicylate) for an upset stomach, your stool will turn black. This happens because the bismuth reacts with the tiny amounts of sulfur in your saliva and digestive tract to create bismuth sulfide. It’s harmless. Iron supplements are another huge culprit. If you’re treating anemia, expect dark, greenish-black stools. Then there's food. Blueberries, blackberries, black licorice, and even a heavy serving of beets (though those usually lean red) can mimic the appearance of melena.
The "sniff test" is the differentiator. True melena has a specific, metallic, and incredibly pungent odor that is hard to forget. If it just looks dark but smells like... well, normal poop... it might just be the blueberries.
The common culprits behind the color change
If it is black blood in stool, the most frequent cause is a peptic ulcer. These are open sores on the lining of your stomach or the duodenum. They aren't just caused by "stress." Most are the result of an H. pylori bacterial infection or the long-term use of NSAIDs like ibuprofen (Advil/Motrin) or naproxen (Aleve).
Dr. Brennan Spiegel, a gastroenterologist at Cedars-Sinai, often notes that people underestimate how much damage daily aspirin or "harmless" painkillers can do to the stomach lining. These drugs inhibit the prostaglandins that protect your stomach from its own acid. Over time, the acid wins, a hole forms, and it bleeds.
Gastritis and Esophageal issues
Sometimes the lining of the stomach just gets incredibly inflamed. This is gastritis. It can be caused by heavy alcohol use, severe illness, or those same NSAIDs. If the inflammation is bad enough, the lining oozes blood.
Then there’s the esophagus. If you have severe acid reflux (GERD), the acid can wear away the esophageal lining (esophagitis). More seriously, people with chronic liver disease might develop esophageal varices. These are swollen veins that can leak or even burst. This is a medical emergency. If you have a history of liver issues and see black stool, you need an ER, not a Google search.
When the "silent" bleed becomes a problem
The tricky thing about black blood in stool is that it can be a slow leak. You might not feel "pain" in the traditional sense. Instead, you might feel exhausted. This is because you’re slowly losing red blood cells, leading to iron-deficiency anemia.
👉 See also: Why a picture of person with no teeth is changing how we see modern dentistry
You might notice:
- Shortness of breath when walking up stairs.
- Unusual pale skin or "ghostly" fingernails.
- A racing heart or palpitations.
- Dizziness when you stand up too fast.
This is the body trying to compensate for a lower volume of blood. In clinical settings, doctors look for a "orthostatic drop" in blood pressure—basically, your pressure plummets when you move from lying down to sitting up because there isn't enough fluid in the pipes.
The diagnostic journey: What happens at the doctor?
If you show up at a clinic complaining of melena, the first thing they’ll likely do is a digital rectal exam (DRE) and a fecal occult blood test. They need to confirm that the dark color is actually hemoglobin.
Once confirmed, the "gold standard" is an upper endoscopy (EGD).
A gastroenterologist will sedate you and slide a thin, flexible tube with a camera down your throat. It sounds miserable, but you’re usually out for the count and don't remember a thing. This allows them to see exactly where the blood is coming from. They can even fix the problem right then and there by cauterizing the wound, clipping a vessel, or injecting medicine to stop the leak.
📖 Related: Zepbound for Obstructive Sleep Apnea: What the SURMOUNT-OSA Trials Actually Proved
In some cases, if the EGD is clear but the bleeding persists, they might use a "pill cam"—a tiny camera you swallow that takes thousands of pictures as it travels through the twenty-plus feet of your small intestine.
What about the lower GI tract?
Usually, blood from the colon (lower GI) is bright red or maroon. This is called hematochezia. However, if your digestion is incredibly slow, blood from the right side of the colon can occasionally turn dark, though it rarely becomes the "true" sticky melena seen with stomach bleeds.
Conditions like Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis can cause bleeding anywhere in the tract. Also, we have to mention colon cancer. While it’s more common to see bright red blood or "hidden" blood with colon polyps or tumors, any change in stool color that persists for more than a few days warrants a colonoscopy, especially if you’re over 45.
Actionable steps you should take right now
If you are currently seeing black blood in stool, here is the protocol.
First, look at your medication cabinet. Have you taken Pepto-Bismol or iron in the last 24 hours? If yes, stop taking them and wait two days to see if the color reverts to normal. If you haven't taken those, look at your pain management. Are you popping ibuprofen daily for back pain or headaches? Stop immediately, as you may be aggravating an ulcer.
Check for "Red Flag" symptoms:
👉 See also: Signs of a Heart Attack: What Most People Get Wrong
- Are you feeling faint or lightheaded?
- Is your heart beating unusually fast while resting?
- Are you vomiting anything that looks like coffee grounds?
- Do you have severe abdominal pain?
If the answer to any of those is "yes," go to the Emergency Room. This isn't something to "wait and see" about. An active GI bleed can lead to shock very quickly.
If you feel fine otherwise but the stool is consistently black and tarry, call a gastroenterologist tomorrow morning. Ask specifically for a fecal occult test or an evaluation for melena. Keep a log of what you’ve eaten and any medications you use, including herbal supplements like Ginko Biloba or Garlic, which can actually thin the blood and increase bleeding risks.
Ultimately, your stool is a daily report card of your internal health. Black blood is a failing grade that requires an immediate tutor—in this case, a doctor with an endoscope. Addressing a small ulcer today is infinitely easier than dealing with a massive hemorrhage or advanced disease six months from now.