Honestly, if you ask a casual fan about the Chiefs vs Eagles 2023 Super Bowl, they’ll probably mention three things: Rihanna’s pregnancy reveal, Patrick Mahomes’ heroic limp, and that controversial holding call at the end. It’s the standard script. But looking back at Super Bowl LVII, the narrative has kinda flattened into a story about a single yellow flag. That’s a shame.
It was a shootout. 38–35.
People forget how much Philadelphia actually dominated large chunks of that game. Jalen Hurts didn’t just play well; he played a game that, in almost any other year, would have made him an undisputed legend. He put up 20 points by himself, tying a record. He ran for three touchdowns. He threw for over 300 yards. And yet, the history books show a loss.
The Field Conditions Nobody Wants to Talk About (But Should)
Let's talk about the grass. Or the "Sodfather" drama. George Toma, the legendary groundskeeper who had worked every single Super Bowl since the first one in 1967, retired after this game. And it was a mess.
The NFL spent two years and roughly $800,000 developing a specific type of grass called Tahoma 31. It was supposed to be the gold standard. Instead, it was a literal ice rink. You’ve probably seen the clips—players from both teams were changing their cleats like they were in a pit stop.
👉 See also: Why the Next Match Los Angeles Lakers Fans Watch Might Define the LeBron Era
- Eagles’ Haason Reddick called it the "worst" surface he'd ever played on.
- The "Cleat Issue": The NFL later tried to blame the players for not wearing the right studs, but that felt like a massive deflect.
- Tactical Impact: This wasn't just a nuisance. It neutralized the Eagles' historic pass rush. Philly had 70 sacks in the regular season—the third-most in NFL history. In the Super Bowl? Zero.
When you can’t get traction, you can't explode off the edge. Patrick Mahomes, playing on a high ankle sprain that looked like it would end his night in the second quarter, suddenly had all the time in the world.
That "Holding" Call: Let's Be Real
We have to address the elephant in the room. 1:54 left on the clock. Third-and-8 at the Eagles' 15-yard line. Mahomes throws an incomplete pass. The stadium holds its breath, thinking the Eagles are about to get the ball back for a potential game-winning drive.
Then the flag comes out. James Bradberry on JuJu Smith-Schuster.
"It was a holding," Bradberry said after the game. He actually admitted it. He hoped they’d let it slide, but he copped to it. That’s the part people usually leave out when they argue the game was "rigged" or "stolen." Whether it should have been called in that moment is a different debate, but the contact was real. It allowed the Chiefs to bleed the clock down to 11 seconds, setting up Harrison Butker for the chip-shot field goal.
The Genius of "Corn Dog"
While everyone was screaming at their TVs about the refs, Andy Reid and Eric Bieniemy were busy out-scheming the Eagles' defense with a play affectionately known as "Corn Dog."
Twice.
They used the exact same motion-to-flat concept for two different touchdowns. First to Kadarius Toney, then to Skyy Moore. Basically, the receiver starts in motion, the Eagles' defender follows, the receiver suddenly stops and pivots back out to the sideline. Because the Eagles were playing man coverage and the field was so slippery, the defenders stood no chance. They were left in the dust. It was beautiful, simple, and absolutely lethal.
Why This Game Still Matters
The Chiefs vs Eagles 2023 Super Bowl wasn't just another win for Kansas City; it was the moment the "dynasty" talk became unavoidable. Mahomes became the first player this century to win the NFL MVP and the Super Bowl in the same season. That’s a massive legacy check.
For the Eagles, it remains one of the greatest "what if" games in Philly history. If the grass is dry, does the pass rush get home? If Jalen Hurts doesn't lose that fumble in the second quarter (which Nick Bolton returned for a touchdown), do the Eagles win by two scores?
Actionable Takeaways for the Super Bowl Obsessed:
If you’re looking back at the tape or arguing with friends about this game, keep these nuances in mind:
- Check the Trench Data: Don't just look at the score. Look at how the lack of sacks changed the Chiefs' play-calling. Kansas City went into a quick-game rhythm that the Eagles never adjusted to.
- The "Sodfather" Factor: If you’re ever betting on a big game, look at where it’s played. Indoor stadiums with retractable grass (like State Farm Stadium) often have moisture issues that affect speed-based defenses.
- The Value of the "Slide": Jerick McKinnon’s decision to slide at the 2-yard line instead of scoring a touchdown is a masterclass in situational football. It’s a move every youth coach should show their players. It guaranteed the win more than a touchdown ever could.
Next time you watch a replay of Super Bowl LVII, look past the yellow flag. Look at the feet. Look at the play-calling. It was a tactical war that just happened to end on a whimper instead of a bang.
To really understand how the Chiefs have stayed on top, you should look into how they rebuilt their offensive line specifically to handle teams like the 2022 Eagles after their previous Super Bowl loss to the Bucs.