Joe Goldberg thought he could just disappear. He really did. After the bloody mess of his life in New York, the stalker-turned-killer packed his bags and headed to the one place he supposedly hated most: Los Angeles. This move set the stage for a sophomore outing that arguably remains the peak of the series. While the first season was a claustrophobic thriller about a man trapping a woman, the You cast season 2 flipped the script by introducing characters who were just as messy, if not messier, than Joe himself.
It’s easy to forget how much of a gamble this was at the time. Netflix had just fully taken over the show from Lifetime, and the pressure was on to see if the formula could survive outside the dark, dusty corners of a New York bookstore. By moving Joe to the bright, kale-smoothie-soaked sunshine of LA, the show found a new way to mock modern culture while deepening Joe’s internal delusion.
The LA Glow-Up: New Faces and Old Habits
The casting director, Felicia Fasano, had a massive task. How do you replace Beck? How do you replace the visceral, grounded reality of the first season? You don't. You pivot. Instead of another "girl next door" victim, the You cast season 2 gave us Love Quinn, played with a terrifyingly sweet intensity by Victoria Pedretti.
Pedretti was fresh off her breakout role in The Haunting of Hill House, and she brought a specific kind of "broken rich girl" energy that Penn Badgley’s Joe didn't know how to handle. Unlike Beck, Love wasn't an aspiring artist struggling to pay rent. She was Los Angeles royalty. She had a twin brother, Forty, played by James Scully, who became the unexpected emotional anchor of the season. Forty was chaotic. He was a drug-addicted, aspiring screenwriter who sucked all the oxygen out of every room he entered.
- Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley): Still creepy. Still narrating. But now, he’s pretending to be "Will Bettelheim."
- Love Quinn (Victoria Pedretti): The chef with a secret. She’s not just a love interest; she’s a mirror.
- Forty Quinn (James Scully): The "problem child" of the family. His codependency with Love is the actual engine of the plot.
- Delilah Alves (Carmela Zumbado): The street-smart apartment manager. She provided the grounded perspective the show desperately needed amidst the Hollywood fluff.
- Ellie Alves (Jenna Ortega): Long before she was Wednesday Addams, Ortega was the precocious teen neighbor who Joe actually tried to protect.
- Candace Stone (Ambyr Childers): The ghost of Joe's past. She’s the only one who knows the truth, and she’s out for blood.
Honestly, the chemistry between Badgley and Pedretti is what kept the show from becoming a parody of itself. If Love had just been another victim, we would have been bored by episode four. Instead, the writers leaned into the idea that Joe might have finally met his match.
📖 Related: Why The Adventures of Wild Bill Hickok TV Series Still Hits Different Today
Why the Love Quinn Twist Still Works
People still talk about that finale. You know the one.
When Joe finally realizes that Love isn't the "pure" soul he hallucinated her to be, his reaction is hilarious and hypocritical. He’s disgusted. He’s horrified that she killed Delilah and Candace to "protect" their love. The You cast season 2 thrived on this irony. Joe wants a woman he can save, but Love Quinn didn't need saving. She needed a partner in crime.
The inclusion of Candace was a brilliant move, too. Ambyr Childers played her with a frantic, desperate energy that highlighted just how much Joe had gaslit his previous victims. She was the "Final Girl" who refused to go away quietly. However, the show subverted the trope. Usually, the survivor gets her revenge. In the dark world of You, the survivor gets her throat slit in a storage unit. It’s bleak. It’s cynical. It’s exactly why the show became a global phenomenon.
The Supporting Players Who Stole the Show
We have to talk about Forty. James Scully’s performance is often overlooked in the broader conversation about the show, but he was essential. Forty was the barrier between Joe and Love. To get to the girl, Joe had to become the brother’s best friend, editor, and babysitter. This led to some of the funniest—and weirdest—sequences in the series, including a drug-fueled writing retreat that ended with Joe locked in a room trying to finish a screenplay.
Then there’s Delilah and Ellie.
Carmela Zumbado and Jenna Ortega brought a much-needed sense of stakes. While the Quinns were shielded by their massive wealth, Delilah and Ellie were vulnerable. They represented the real-world consequences of Joe’s presence. When Delilah died, it wasn't just another body count; it felt like a genuine loss of a character who had a future. It was the moment Joe—and the audience—realized that LA wasn't going to be a fresh start. It was just a different kind of graveyard.
👉 See also: Spider-Man TV Show Live Action History: Why It Keeps Disappearing and Coming Back
Ranking the Performances: Who Actually Carried the Season?
It’s Penn Badgley’s show, obviously. His "Joe voice" is iconic at this point. But Victoria Pedretti stole his thunder. There is a specific look she gives in the final episodes—a mix of maternal instinct and pure predatory hunger—that changed the DNA of the series.
- Victoria Pedretti: She had to play "perfect dream girl" for eight episodes before pivoting to "maniacal protector." The transition was seamless.
- Penn Badgley: His physical comedy in the second season is top-tier. Watching Joe try to act "normal" while grinding a body in a Henderson’s kitchen is peak dark humor.
- Jenna Ortega: Even at a young age, her screen presence was undeniable. She played Ellie with a cynicism that made her feel older than Joe in many ways.
- James Scully: He made a potentially annoying character deeply sympathetic. You actually felt bad when he died, despite his constant tantrums.
The Problem with Joe’s Redemption Arc
A lot of fans fell into the trap of rooting for Joe this season. The writers knew what they were doing. By putting Joe up against even "worse" people—like the predatory comedian Henderson (Chris D'Elia)—they made Joe look like a vigilante.
But he’s not.
The You cast season 2 serves as a warning about the "Nice Guy" trope. Joe thinks he’s protecting Ellie, but he’s the one who put her in danger by killing her only guardian. He thinks he loves Love, but he only loves the idea of her. The moment she becomes a real, flawed, and violent person, he wants out. He’s trapped in a prison of his own making, which is perfectly symbolized by the suburban house he ends up in at the end of the season.
👉 See also: Bar Rescue The Lister: What Really Happened to San Francisco’s Iconic Dive
Comparing Season 1 and Season 2
New York was cold, literal, and literary. Los Angeles was bright, metaphorical, and vapid.
In Season 1, the cast was small. It felt like a stage play. Season 2 expanded the world. We got the "Anavrin" grocery store (Nirvana spelled backward, because of course), the wellness gurus, and the deep-seated corruption of the film industry. The You cast season 2 reflected this expansion. Every character felt like they were performing for an audience, which made Joe’s internal monologue even more biting. He was the only one "being real," or so he thought.
What to Take Away from the Second Season
If you’re rewatching or diving in for the first time, pay attention to the background details. The show is a masterclass in using its setting to comment on the characters. Joe hates LA because it’s a city built on artifice, yet he is the most artificial person there.
The real genius of the You cast season 2 wasn't just the kills or the twists. It was the way it forced the audience to confront why we like Joe Goldberg. We like him because he’s funny and he likes books. We like him because he "cares" about kids like Ellie. But by the time the credits roll on the finale, the show reminds us that he’s a monster who attracts other monsters.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Content Creators:
- Analyze Character Archetypes: If you're writing your own thriller, look at how Love Quinn subverts the "Damsel in Distress" trope. She’s the "Shadow Self" of the protagonist.
- Setting as Character: Notice how the move from NYC to LA changed the tone of the show. Use location to dictate the "vibe" of your narrative.
- The Power of Voiceover: Badgley’s narration isn't just exposition; it’s a character in itself. It’s unreliable. When writing, consider how an unreliable narrator can create tension between what the audience sees and what they hear.
- Follow the Career Trajectories: Look at where the You cast season 2 is now. Jenna Ortega is a superstar. Victoria Pedretti is a genre icon. Following the casting choices of successful shows is a great way to spot rising talent early.
The show eventually moved on to London and the suburbs, but the LA era remains the most vibrant and shocking chapter of Joe's journey. It’s where the series stopped being a simple stalker story and became a complex, satirical look at how we justify our own darkness.