Honestly, the What to Expect When You're Expecting movie is a weird piece of cinema history. It’s based on a non-fiction pregnancy manual. Think about that for a second. It's like someone decided to make a rom-com out of the owner’s manual for a 2012 Honda Civic. It shouldn't have worked. Yet, here we are, over a decade since its release, and it’s still the thing people put on when they’re staring at a positive pregnancy test and spiraling into a mild panic.
It’s messy. It’s loud. It has a cast list that looks like someone threw darts at a Hollywood "Who's Who" board. You’ve got Jennifer Lopez, Cameron Diaz, Anna Kendrick, and Elizabeth Banks all trying to navigate the biological reality of growing a human. It’s a lot to take in.
The movie doesn’t try to be The Godfather of parenting films. It’s more like a chaotic brunch where everyone is oversharing.
The Brutal Honesty of the "Pregnancy Glow" Myth
We’ve all seen the magazines. The celebrities looking radiant with a perfectly round bump and zero swelling. The What to Expect When You're Expecting movie takes a sledgehammer to that image, mostly through Elizabeth Banks’ character, Wendy.
Wendy is an "author-expert" on breastfeeding and pregnancy who has spent her whole life romanticizing the process. When she actually gets pregnant? She’s a disaster. She’s sweaty, she’s leaking, and she’s angry. Her speech at a baby expo—where she basically admits that pregnancy sucks and the "glow" is just a layer of oil and broken dreams—is probably the most relatable moment in the whole film.
📖 Related: The Nirvana In Utero CD Cover: Why This Anatomical Angel Still Haunts Us
It’s a stark contrast to Brooklyn Decker’s character, Skyler. Skyler is the stepmother-in-law who stays thin, carries twins effortlessly, and literally sneezes and the babies pop out. We all know a Skyler. We all want to be a Skyler. But most of us are Wendy.
Why the ensemble structure actually matters
By juggling five different couples, the movie covers ground that a single-narrative story couldn't touch. You have the high-achievers (Diaz and Morrison), the older couple (Quaid and Decker), the young "oops" pregnancy (Kendrick and Crawford), the adoption journey (Lopez and Rodrigo Santoro), and the "average" couple (Banks and Ben Falcone).
This isn't just about different personality types. It’s about the fact that "expecting" isn't a monolithic experience. For some, it’s a biological triumph. For others, it’s a legal and emotional marathon of international adoption. For the youngest couple, it’s a tragic lesson in how quickly things can be taken away.
The Dude's Group: A Portrayal of Modern Fatherhood
One of the more memorable parts of the What to Expect When You're Expecting movie is the "Dudes’ Group." Led by Chris Rock, this is a pack of dads who walk through the park with their strollers like they’re in a low-stakes version of The Avengers.
Their rule? No judgment.
They talk about the things men aren't "supposed" to admit. The loss of freedom. The constant exhaustion. The fact that their kids are sometimes tiny terrorists. It’s played for laughs, but it touches on a very real shift in 21st-century parenting where fathers are expected to be hands-on but often feel like they’re flying blind.
✨ Don't miss: Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch: What Most People Get Wrong
The humor is dated in spots—some of the "men are incompetent" tropes haven't aged perfectly—but the camaraderie feels authentic. It highlights that the "expecting" part isn't just for the person carrying the baby. The partners are in a different kind of waiting room, one where they’re terrified of the responsibility but eager to find a community that understands the struggle.
The Reality of Loss in a Comedy
Most people forget that this movie gets dark.
The storyline featuring Anna Kendrick and Chace Crawford is surprisingly heavy. They’re two rival food truck owners who have a one-night stand, get pregnant, and then lose the baby. In a movie that features a scene where a guy gets his nipple bitten by a kid at a park, a miscarriage feels like a tonal whiplash.
But it’s necessary.
If the What to Expect When You're Expecting movie was just 110 minutes of morning sickness jokes, it would be forgettable. By including the reality of miscarriage, the film acknowledges that for many, the period of "expecting" ends in grief rather than a nursery. It’s handled with a surprising amount of grace for a film that also features a scene where Joe Manganiello does a shirtless workout in slow motion.
Behind the Scenes: From Book to Screen
The book itself, written by Heidi Murkoff, has been a bestseller since 1984. It’s often called the "Pregnancy Bible." Converting a Q&A-style reference book into a narrative script was the job of Shauna Cross and Heather Hach.
They had to create characters that represented the different chapters of the book.
- "Are we ready?" (The adoption arc)
- "Your Body During Pregnancy" (The Wendy arc)
- "Special Concerns" (The high-risk or athletic arc)
Director Kirk Jones had to weave these together. It’s a tough gig. You’re essentially making five short films and hoping the audience doesn't get whiplash jumping between them. The critics weren't always kind. It currently sits at a pretty low rating on Rotten Tomatoes. But audiences? They liked it way more. It’s a "comfort watch."
The Cast and the 2012 Time Capsule
Looking back, the cast is insane.
- Jennifer Lopez as Holly (the photographer struggling with the cost of adoption)
- Cameron Diaz as Jules (the fitness guru who can’t stop working)
- Matthew Morrison as Evan (the Glee-era heartthrob)
- Rebel Wilson as Janice (the quirky assistant)
It’s a snapshot of who was "big" in 2012. Seeing Rebel Wilson in one of her early Hollywood roles is a trip. The fashion, the technology (hello, Blackberrys), and the specific brand of humor all scream early 2010s. Yet, the core anxieties—money, health, relationship strain—are evergreen.
👉 See also: Black Flag TV Show: Why Everyone Is Still Waiting for the Ultimate Pirate Epic
Does it hold up?
If you're looking for a cinematic masterpiece, keep walking. This isn't it. But if you're looking for something that validates the fact that you feel like a bloated whale and your partner is driving you crazy, the What to Expect When You're Expecting movie is actually pretty great.
It gets the "small" things right. The way a pregnancy can strain a marriage. The weird competition between fathers and sons (the Quaid/Falcone dynamic). The fear of not being a "natural" at parenting.
The movie reminds us that nobody really knows what they're doing. Everyone is just faking it until the kid shows up, and even then, you're still basically guessing.
What You Should Do Next
If you’re actually expecting and you’re watching this movie for "research," take a breath. It’s a caricature.
- Watch it with your partner. It’s a great conversation starter for the "scary" topics you’ve been avoiding.
- Don't compare your bump to Skyler. She’s a fictional character played by a supermodel. It’s not real life.
- Listen to the Dudes' Group advice. Not the part about letting kids eat floor snacks, but the part about finding your own "pack" of parents. Isolation is the enemy of new parents.
- Read the actual book. The movie is for the heart; the book is for the actual medical questions you have at 3:00 AM.
The What to Expect When You're Expecting movie might be a bit of a chaotic mess, but then again, so is parenthood. Sometimes the most "human" thing a movie can do is admit that life doesn't always follow the script, even when you've got the manual right in front of you.
Next Steps for Your Journey
To get the most out of your "expecting" phase, consider these three moves:
- Build your village early. Whether it’s a formal "Dudes’ Group" or just a group chat with friends who have kids, start those connections now.
- Separate fiction from reality. Use the movie for a laugh and the book for facts. Don’t let Hollywood’s version of a "perfect delivery" set your expectations.
- Document the "Wendy" moments. Take the photos when you’re messy and tired. You’ll laugh at them a lot more than the posed ones five years from now.