Why the Pull Up Gym Machine Is Actually Better Than the Bar

Why the Pull Up Gym Machine Is Actually Better Than the Bar

You want a wide, V-taper back. Everyone does. But if you walk into any commercial gym, you’ll see a line of people avoiding the standard pull-up bar like it's covered in industrial grease. Instead, they’re flocking to the pull up gym machine. Specifically, the assisted version.

Purists will tell you it’s "cheating." They're wrong.

Let’s be real: doing a bodyweight pull-up is hard. It requires a specific strength-to-weight ratio that many beginners—and even seasoned lifters—just don’t have on day one. If you can only do two shaky, half-reps of a traditional pull-up, you aren't actually building muscle. You’re just struggling. That is where the assisted pull up gym machine changes the game, allowing you to actually hit the 8 to 12 rep range that triggers hypertrophy.

The Counter-Intuitive Truth About Assisted Reps

Most people use the machine wrong because they treat the weights as a score. It’s the opposite of a bench press. On a bench, more weight means you’re stronger. On the pull up gym machine, adding more weight makes the exercise easier. It’s a counterbalance system. If you weigh 200 pounds and set the machine to 50 pounds, you are effectively lifting 150 pounds.

It’s basic math. But the ego gets in the way.

I’ve seen guys dump the entire weight stack on the pin just so they can move fast. Stop that. The real magic happens when you use just enough assistance to keep your form perfect. You want your chest up. You want your shoulders retracted. If you’re rounding your back like a frightened cat, the machine isn't the problem—your ego is.

Research from the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research suggests that vertical pulling movements, whether assisted or not, are the gold standard for activating the latissimus dorsi. But here’s the kicker: the machine allows for a longer "time under tension." When you aren't terrified of falling off the bar, you can actually feel the muscle squeeze. That mind-muscle connection is the difference between a thick back and just "moving weight."

Why Your Grip Probably Sucks (And How to Fix It)

Most pull up gym machines come with a variety of handles. You’ve got the wide grip, the neutral grip (palms facing each other), and the chin-up grip (palms facing you).

  1. Wide grip hits the outer lats. It’s what gives you that "wingspan" look. However, it’s also the toughest on your rotator cuffs. If you feel a pinch in your shoulder, narrow it down.
  2. Neutral grip is the safest. Honestly, if you have any history of shoulder impingement, stay here. It puts the least amount of stress on the joint while still hammering the lats and the brachialis.
  3. The chin-up grip recruits the biceps heavily. It’s great for arm growth, but sometimes your biceps will give out before your back does.

Variation is key. Don't just do the same grip every Monday. Switch it up. Use the wide grip for two weeks, then move to neutral. Your nervous system likes the change.

The Kneeling vs. Standing Debate

There are two main types of machines you'll find at places like Planet Fitness or Gold's Gym. One has a platform you stand on; the other has a pad you kneel on.

👉 See also: Treat Under Eye Bags: Why Your Expensive Cream Isn't Working

The kneeling version is generally superior for core stability. When you kneel, it's harder to use your legs to "kick" or generate momentum. It forces your torso to stay upright. The standing version is fine, but people tend to bounce. Bouncing is the enemy of growth. If you find yourself using the momentum of the weight stack to fly upward, you’ve lost the plot.

The "Plateau Buster" Method

So, you’ve been using the pull up gym machine for three months and you’re stuck. You’re using 40 pounds of assistance and you can’t seem to drop to 30.

Try negatives.

Set the machine to a very light weight—something you can’t actually pull up. Use the steps to get your chin above the bar. Then, slowly—I’m talking a five-second count—lower yourself down. This eccentric loading is a well-documented way to build raw strength. According to experts like Dr. Mike Israetel of Renaissance Periodization, the eccentric phase is where a massive amount of muscle damage (the good kind) happens.

Also, look at your "top-end" strength. Are you pulling all the way up? Your chin should clear the handles. If you're stopping short, you're missing out on the contraction of the lower traps and rhomboids.

💡 You might also like: Moving away from sun exposure: Why your skin and eyes might actually need the shade

It's Not Just for Beginners

Pro bodybuilders use the pull up gym machine all the time. Why? Because they weigh 260 pounds. Doing 15 bodyweight pull-ups at that size is a massive drain on the central nervous system. By using the machine, they can isolate the lats without burning out their entire body before they even get to rows or deadlifts.

It’s a tool. Not a crutch.

Think of it like training wheels on a bike. Eventually, you want to ride without them, but they’re what teach you how to balance in the first place. Or, think of it like a spotter. The machine is just a spotter that never gets tired and doesn't yell "It's all you, bro" while actually lifting 40% of the weight.

Common Mistakes to Avoid (The "Don't Do This" List)

  • Looking down. Look at the ceiling. Where the eyes go, the body follows. Looking down rounds your shoulders forward, which shifts the load from your back to your chest and front delts.
  • The "Death Grip." Don't squeeze the handles like you're trying to choke them. Use a thumbless grip (suicide grip) if you can. It helps take the forearms out of the movement so your back does the heavy lifting.
  • Partial reps. If you aren't going all the way down to a full stretch, you're wasting time. The stretch at the bottom is arguably the most important part of the rep for muscle growth.

Moving Toward the Bar

If your goal is to eventually do unassisted pull-ups, use a "descending assistance" protocol. Start your workout with the hardest version. Maybe that’s bodyweight, even if you can only do one. Then, move to the machine to finish your sets.

Don't wait until you're exhausted to try the hard stuff.

The pull up gym machine is a bridge. For some, it’s a bridge to the bar. For others, it’s a bridge to a bigger, stronger back without the joint pain of traditional calisthenics. Both are valid.

✨ Don't miss: Why Being Rich in Vitamin A Actually Matters for Your Long-Term Health

Actionable Steps for Your Next Back Day

Next time you see that big, hulking machine in the corner, don't walk past it.

  • Step 1: Choose a weight that allows you to do exactly 10 reps with a 2-second pause at the top.
  • Step 2: Focus on driving your elbows toward your hips, not pulling your hands toward the bar. Think of your hands as mere hooks.
  • Step 3: Perform 3 sets. Every week, try to reduce the assistance by one plate (usually 5 or 10 pounds).
  • Step 4: Record your progress. Strength in the vertical plane is one of the best indicators of overall upper body health.

Start by treating the machine with the same respect you give the squat rack. Dial in the form, embrace the burn in your lats, and ignore anyone who says assisted reps don't count. Your reflection in the mirror six months from now will be all the proof you need.

Get on the platform. Pull. Grow.