You’ve probably been there. You're standing in the lobby, someone sends a trade request, and they throw in a Seer or maybe a Chroma Heat. Your heart skips. Is it a win? A loss? If you're relying on your gut, you're basically gambling with your inventory. This is why everyone talks about the murder mystery 2 value list like it's the holy grail of Roblox trading. But here's the kicker: no single list is perfect. Values shift faster than a murderer's knife throw.
Trading in MM2 isn't just about clicking "Accept." It’s a psychological game. It’s about knowing which items are "stable" and which ones are "hyped." If you don't understand the nuance behind the numbers, you're going to get sharked. Honestly, it happens to the best of us. You think you're getting a massive overpay because the value list says so, but then you realize that item has zero demand. Nobody wants it. Now you're stuck with a "high value" paperweight.
The Reality of the Murder Mystery 2 Value List
Most players swear by two main sources: MM2V (MM2 Values) and Supreme Values. They’re the titans. If you walk into a crowded server, you’ll see people arguing in the chat about which one is "correct." The truth? Neither is 100% right all the time. They are community-driven databases that track thousands of trades to give us an average.
Think of it like the stock market.
A godly knife might be worth 50 on paper today. Tomorrow? Nikilis drops a new update, a new crate appears, and suddenly that knife is worth 40. Or maybe a famous YouTuber starts wearing a specific vintage item, and the demand skyrockets. This is why a static murder mystery 2 value list is just a starting point. It's a snapshot in time. You have to look at the "Demand" and "Rarity" stats usually tucked away next to the number.
Why Demand Trumps Value
Let’s talk about the "Seer" problem. The Seer is the baseline. It’s the dollar bill of MM2. But just because something is worth "10 Seers" doesn't mean you can easily trade it for ten actual Seers.
Demand is the secret sauce.
Take the Corrupt knife. For the longest time, its value was astronomical because it's a limited item from the early days of the game. But its value fluctuates wildly based on how many "hoarders" are holding onto them. If the big traders decide to sell at once, the value dips. If they hold, it stays high. A murder mystery 2 value list might tell you a specific Chroma is worth more, but if nobody wants Chromas this month, you’re better off holding a high-demand Godly like Heartblade or Batwing.
People love aesthetics. If a knife looks cool, people will overpay. If it looks like a blocky mess from 2016, you’re going to have a hard time moving it, even if the "rarity" says it’s rare.
Common Scams and Trade Traps
If you’re looking up a murder mystery 2 value list, you’re probably trying to avoid getting ripped off. Scammers love the "Value List Lie." They’ll tell you, "Hey, this list is outdated, use this one," and send you a link to a fake site they built. That site will show their worthless item is worth 500. Don't fall for it. Only trust the established community sites.
Then there's the "ghosting" or "item switching" trick. You're looking at the trade window, focusing on the values you just looked up. You're doing the math in your head. 45 + 20 + 15... okay, I'm winning by 5. Right as you're about to click, they swap the Godly for a common that looks similar. Always, always double-check the trade window right before the final green button.
- Check the icons. Some commons are colored to look like Godlies.
- Verify the name. Hover over the item.
- Don't rush. Scammers use "hurry up" tactics to make you mess up the math.
The Rise and Fall of Chromas
Chromas used to be the pinnacle. If you had a Chroma Luger, you were a king. Then, the great "duping" waves happened. Duping (duplicating) ruins the economy. When thousands of copies of a rare item are suddenly glitched into the game, the murder mystery 2 value list has to be rewritten overnight.
Currently, Chromas have stabilized a bit, but they aren't the untouchable assets they once were. Many traders now prefer "Collectibles"—items from old Halloween or Christmas events that can't be obtained anymore. These tend to hold their value better because the supply is fixed. There’s no more coming.
How to Calculate a "Win" in a Trade
A "win" isn't just when your side of the box has a higher number. That’s a rookie mistake. A real win is when you trade "Low Demand" items for "High Demand" items, even if the total value is slightly lower.
Why? Because you can flip High Demand items instantly.
If you have a knife worth 100 that nobody wants, and someone offers you an 85-value knife that everyone is hunting for, take it. You can turn that 85 into a 110 by the end of the day. This is called "flipping." Professional traders rarely look at the total value sum; they look at "liquid assets." In the world of the murder mystery 2 value list, liquidity is everything.
Managing Your Inventory Growth
Don't be afraid to break down your big items. If you have one massive Godly, you're limited to one trade. If you trade that for four smaller Godlies, you now have four "seeds" to grow.
- Look for "Underpays" on items with rising demand.
- Avoid "Ancient" items unless you plan to keep them; they are notoriously hard to trade.
- Keep an eye on the "Stable," "Rising," and "Decreasing" tags on value lists.
- If an item is "Overpaid For," it means people are regularly giving more than the listed value. This is your target.
Understanding the "VNT" and "Tiering" System
Most lists categorize items into Tiers. Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 3, etc. This is usually based on the original obtaining method or the crafting cost. Vintages (VNT) are a weird middle ground. They come from the original Murder Mystery 1. While they have historical value, their demand in MM2 is often surprisingly low. New players don't care about a "Classic" gun; they want the glowing neon scythe.
✨ Don't miss: Home Sweet Home Rebirth 2025: Why This Horror Sequel Might Actually Be Terrifying
If you're using a murder mystery 2 value list, pay close attention to the "Set" bonuses too. Some items are worth significantly more if you have both the knife and the matching gun (like the Amerilaser and Old Glory set). Breaking a set often drops the individual values of the pieces.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Trade
Stop blindly following the first number you see. To truly master the economy, you need a strategy that goes beyond just reading a screen.
First, cross-reference. Open both Supreme and MM2V. If one says an item is 60 and the other says 40, the real value is likely somewhere in the middle—or it’s currently in a state of flux. This gap is where you can find "arbitrage" opportunities.
Second, join trade hangouts. Don't just stay in standard lobbies. Go to the dedicated trading servers. Watch the chat. See what people are actually asking for. If 10 people are screaming "TRADING SUGAR," and nobody is biting, you know the "value" listed online is currently too high for the actual market.
Third, focus on "Adds." If a trade is almost fair but you're hesitating, ask for an "add"—a small legendary or a few rares. Over time, these small adds can be crafted into Seers, which can then be traded for Godlies. It’s slow, but it’s the safest way to build a massive inventory from nothing.
Finally, set a "Hard Stop" for yourself. Never trade away your last Godly for a "high value" collectible you aren't sure about. Always keep a liquid item in your inventory so you can keep playing the market. The moment you're stuck with an un-tradable item, your progress hits a wall. Use the murder mystery 2 value list as your map, but use your common sense as your compass. The market doesn't care what a website says if nobody in the server wants to click "Accept."