Small talk is a slow death. You’re sitting there, staring at your phone or across a sticky bar table, and the conversation is basically on life support. "How was your day?" "Good." "What did you do?" "Work." It’s brutal. Honestly, the barrier between a connection that actually goes somewhere and a "read" receipt that lingers for three days is usually the quality of the inquiry. If you’re looking for good questions to ask a guy you like, you have to stop playing it safe.
Most people are terrified of being "too much." They stick to the script. But the script is boring. According to research by Harvard psychological scientists, people who ask more questions—specifically follow-up questions—are perceived as significantly more likable. It’s called "responsiveness." When you ask something that actually requires him to dig into his brain, you aren't just gathering data; you're creating a dopamine spike in his prefrontal cortex. People love talking about themselves. It’s a biological fact.
The Psychology of Breaking the Ice Without Being Weird
You’ve probably seen those lists of "36 Questions to Fall in Love" based on the work of psychologist Arthur Aron. They work because they force vulnerability at a graduated pace. You can't just walk up to a guy and ask him what his biggest regret is before you even know if he likes cilantro. That’s a fast track to a restraining order.
Instead, start with "the situational pivot."
If you’re at a party, don’t ask how he knows the host. Ask what the most "out of character" thing he’s done this week is. It’s slightly jarring in a fun way. It signals that you aren’t interested in the standard social dance. It invites him to tell a story rather than recite a resume. Men, generally speaking, communicate through shared activities or narrative-based sharing. Give him a chance to be the protagonist of a story, and he’ll lean in.
Getting Past the Surface
Most guys have a "default" mode. They talk about their job, their gym routine, or whatever sport is currently in season. To break that, you need to ask about the why behind the what.
Suppose he mentions he’s an engineer. Instead of saying "Oh, cool, do you like it?", try asking what the most "MacGyver" thing he’s ever had to do was. It’s specific. It’s playful. It validates his competence while letting him show off a bit of his personality.
✨ Don't miss: Boynton Beach Boat Parade: What You Actually Need to Know Before You Go
Good Questions to Ask a Guy You Like When Things Get Real
At some point, you have to move from "fun banter" to "do we actually keep each other sane?" This is where the good questions to ask a guy you like shift from lighthearted to revealing.
I remember talking to a relationship coach, Dr. Alexandra Solomon, who talks about "relational self-awareness." It’s the idea that you need to know how someone processes their own life before you can fit into it. You don't get that by asking "Where do you see yourself in five years?" That sounds like a corporate performance review.
Try these instead:
- "What’s a hill you’re absolutely willing to die on?" (This reveals values without being heavy-handed).
- "If you had a totally free Saturday with no responsibilities and an unlimited budget, what does the first hour look like?"
- "What’s the most overrated virtue in your opinion?"
The "overrated virtue" question is a goldmine. If he says "honesty," run. If he says "hustle culture," you’ve found someone who values balance. It’s a shortcut to his philosophy on life without needing a philosophy degree to navigate the conversation.
The Power of "Would You Rather" for Adults
Don't underestimate the juvenile. Serious conversations are exhausting. Sometimes, the most good questions to ask a guy you like are the ones that make him laugh or think about something absurd.
"Would you rather always have to sing instead of speaking or always have to dance instead of walking?"
🔗 Read more: Bootcut Pants for Men: Why the 70s Silhouette is Making a Massive Comeback
It’s stupid. It’s also a great way to see if he can be silly. A guy who takes himself too seriously is going to be a nightmare when you’re trying to navigate a flat tire or a ruined dinner date three months from now. If he engages with the absurdity, he’s showing he’s adaptable.
Why Most People Mess Up the Q&A Phase
The biggest mistake? Treating it like an interrogation.
If you fire off five questions in a row without sharing anything about yourself, he’s going to feel like he’s being audited by the IRS. The "Statement-Question-Statement" loop is your best friend here.
Share a tiny bit of your own perspective first. "I’ve been obsessed with travel documentaries lately because I’m dying to go to Japan. If you could teleport anywhere for just twenty-four hours, where would you land?"
See what happened there? You gave him a hook (Japan, documentaries), then you handed him the mic. It feels like a conversation, not a deposition.
Watching for the "Yellow Flags"
Pay attention not just to the answer, but how he handles the question. Does he turn it back on you? Does he seem annoyed by the depth?
💡 You might also like: Bondage and Being Tied Up: A Realistic Look at Safety, Psychology, and Why People Do It
A guy who gives one-word answers to thoughtful prompts is giving you a gift: he’s showing you he’s not ready for the level of engagement you’re offering. Don’t try to "fix" the conversation by asking more. If he’s not biting, he’s not the one. Move on.
Digital vs. In-Person Dynamics
Texting changes the stakes. On a screen, you have time to be clever, but you lose the tone. Good questions to ask a guy you like over text should be visual or opinion-based.
Ask for a recommendation. "I need a new show that isn't soul-crushing. What’s your go-to?"
It’s low pressure. It gives him a chance to be the expert. Men love being the expert. It’s a trope because it’s true. Use it to your advantage.
Putting It Into Practice
The goal isn't to memorize a list. It’s to develop a mindset of curiosity. When you’re genuinely curious about how another human being perceives the world, the questions come naturally.
Next Steps for Your Next Interaction:
- Pick three "tiers" of questions. Have one "light" (hobbies/absurdity), one "medium" (opinions/preferences), and one "deep" (values/history) ready in your back pocket.
- Wait for the lull. Don’t interrupt a good flow to ask a scripted question. Use these when the "So, what’s up?" starts to creep in.
- Observe the 70/30 rule. Let him do 70% of the talking initially. It makes him feel heard and gives you more "ammo" for follow-up questions later.
- Ditch the "interview" questions. Stop asking about his siblings or his major unless it naturally comes up. Ask about his experience of those things instead. "What was it like being the youngest of four?" is a thousand times better than "Do you have siblings?"
Effective questioning is about opening doors. Some doors lead to amazing views, and some lead to empty rooms. The sooner you start opening them, the sooner you'll know which house you're standing in.