Movies from the late seventies usually have this specific, gritty texture that makes you feel like you need a shower after watching them. Good Luck Miss Wyckoff 1979 is exactly that kind of film. It’s a polarizing, awkward, and deeply difficult piece of cinema that most people have either forgotten or actively tried to erase from their memory.
Honestly, it's a tough watch.
Based on the 1970 novel by William Inge, the film tackles themes that would probably get a director blacklisted today. It’s set in a small, suffocating Kansas town in the 1950s. Evelyn Wyckoff, played with a sort of fragile desperation by Anne Heywood, is a high school Latin teacher who is slowly losing her mind to loneliness.
Then things get complicated.
She enters into a sexual relationship—one that is fraught with power imbalances and racial tensions—with a Black janitor named Rafe Collins. The fallout is brutal.
The Controversy Surrounding Good Luck Miss Wyckoff 1979
Most people who stumble across this movie today are usually looking for 1970s cult cinema or are fans of William Inge’s plays like Picnic or Splendor in the Grass. But this isn't a sweeping romance. It’s a tragedy about social ostracization. When Good Luck Miss Wyckoff 1979 was released, it didn't exactly set the box office on fire. It was too "indecent" for some and too uncomfortable for others.
The film was directed by Marvin J. Chomsky. If that name sounds familiar, it's because he directed the Roots miniseries. He wasn't a stranger to heavy topics. Yet, even with his pedigree, the movie felt like it was pushing against a wall that wasn't ready to move.
The central conflict isn't just about the affair. It’s about the crushing weight of small-town morality. Evelyn is a woman who has followed every rule her entire life. She’s "proper." She’s "respected." But the moment she deviates from the script written for her by the community, they don't just judge her; they annihilate her social standing.
Why the Casting Matters
Anne Heywood was a bold choice for Evelyn. She had previously starred in The Fox (1967), another film that dealt with "taboo" sexual themes at the time. She had this ability to look composed on the surface while looking like she was screaming on the inside.
Opposite her was Robert Vaughn as Dr. Neal and Carolyn Jones as Beth. You might remember Carolyn Jones as Morticia Addams, but here she plays a very different, much more grounded character. The acting isn't the problem with the film. The performances are actually quite nuanced. The problem—or the challenge—is the script’s handling of Rafe, played by John Lafayette.
In the book, the relationship is depicted with a lot more psychological violence. The film tries to soften some of those edges, which arguably makes it more confusing. Is it a story about liberation? Or is it a story about exploitation? The movie never quite decides.
A Product of Its Time or Just Plain Wrong?
If you watch Good Luck Miss Wyckoff 1979 today, you’re going to notice the "Gaze." It’s a film made by white creators during a period of transition in Hollywood. The 1970s were over, and the 80s were looming. Cinema was caught between the experimental "New Hollywood" era and the upcoming blockbusters.
The movie feels dated, sure. The pacing is slow. Some of the dialogue feels like it was ripped from a stage play and never quite adjusted for the camera.
But there’s a raw honesty in how it depicts the 1950s. It doesn't look like Grease or Happy Days. It looks gray. It looks dusty. It looks like a place where dreams go to die in a school hallway.
The "Good Luck" in the title is, of course, biting irony. By the time the credits roll, Evelyn has lost her job, her home, and her dignity. The town "graciously" lets her leave, hence the sarcastic well-wishing.
Critical Reception and Legacy
Critics weren't kind. Many felt it was "sleazy." Others thought it was just boring. In reality, it sits in that weird middle ground of "prestige exploitation." It wants to be a serious social commentary, but it relies on shock value to get there.
There’s a specific scene involving a physical exam that still gets cited in film studies classes as one of the most awkward and "un-cinematic" moments of that era. It’s clinical, cold, and reinforces the idea that Evelyn is being "checked" for her sins by the male establishment.
How to Find and Watch It Now
Finding a high-quality version of Good Luck Miss Wyckoff 1979 isn't easy. It hasn't received the Criterion treatment. You won't find it on Netflix. Most people find it on obscure streaming sites or via old DVD releases from companies like Scorpion Releasing.
If you do decide to track it down, go into it knowing it’s a time capsule. It’s a look at how 1979 viewed 1954. It’s a layers-deep exploration of repression.
💡 You might also like: Pretty Little Liars Season 5: Why It’s Kinda The Best (And Worst) Mess We Ever Loved
Key Takeaways for Film Buffs
- The Inge Connection: William Inge was a master of midwestern repression. This was his last novel, and it’s his darkest.
- Performance Over Plot: Watch it for Anne Heywood. She carries the movie on her back, even when the script fails her.
- The Ending: It’s one of the most depressing "walking away into the sunset" endings in cinema.
If you are interested in the evolution of how race and sex were handled on screen, this is a vital, if uncomfortable, piece of the puzzle. It shows the limitations of the "liberal" filmmaking of the late 70s.
To truly understand the context, you should also look into William Inge's other works. Compare how Picnic handles the "outsider" compared to how this film treats Rafe. The difference tells you everything you need to know about how American culture shifted between the 1950s and the 1970s.
Seek out the Scorpion Releasing DVD if you want the best possible transfer. Most "free" versions online are bootlegs of old VHS tapes and are almost unwatchable due to the dark lighting. Read the original 1970 novel first to see what was "sanitized" for the screen; it provides a much clearer picture of Evelyn’s internal breakdown. Finally, watch it alongside other 1979 releases like Norma Rae or Kramer vs. Kramer to see just how far outside the mainstream this movie actually sat. It was an outlier then, and it remains one now.