Honestly, looking back at Pretty Little Liars season 5, it feels like a fever dream. One minute we’re reeling from the fact that Alison DiLaurentis is actually alive, and the next, we’re watching a house explode while a mysterious figure in a black hoodie moves into a new lair. It was a lot.
Most fans remember this season for the big stuff—Mona’s "death," the Christmas episode, and that insane dollhouse finale. But if you really sit down and rewatch it, you realize season 5 was the moment the show shifted from a teen mystery into something much darker and, frankly, a bit unhinged.
The Return of the Queen Bee
When Alison came back to Rosewood, everything changed. For four seasons, she was this mythical figure, a ghost in a yellow top. Then suddenly, she’s just… there. Sitting in the Brew, walking the halls of Rosewood High, and lying through her teeth.
The Liars—Aria, Hanna, Spencer, and Emily—weren’t exactly welcoming her back with open arms, and can you blame them? They’d spent years being tortured because of her secrets. In Pretty Little Liars season 5, the dynamic shifted from "Find Ali" to "Can we even trust Ali?"
Basically, the answer was usually no.
Ali’s big lie about being kidnapped for two years was the catalyst for most of the season's drama. It forced the girls to back up a story they knew was fake, and it eventually led to the breakdown of their friendship. Watching Spencer and the others slowly realize that Alison hadn't changed at all was heartbreaking but also felt very real. You’ve probably had that one friend who just can't stop stirring the pot. That was Ali.
👉 See also: Finding a One Piece Full Set That Actually Fits Your Shelf and Your Budget
Why the 100th Episode Mattered
Episode 5, "Miss Me x 100," was a massive milestone. It wasn't just about the number; it was about the stakes. We finally got the name of the girl in the grave: Bethany Young.
This name would haunt the rest of the series.
The 100th episode also gave us the return of Caleb (with that questionable "Ravenswood" hair) and a very brief moment of peace before A literally blew up Toby’s house. It was the show's way of saying, "Yeah, Ali's back, but the game is just getting started."
The "Death" of Mona Vanderwaal
If you didn't gasp when the news broke that Mona was dead, were you even watching?
The summer finale, "Taking This One to the Grave," was peak PLL. Mona had finally teamed up with the Liars to prove Alison was A. She was winning. She had the evidence. And then, in true slasher-movie fashion, A broke into her house.
✨ Don't miss: Evil Kermit: Why We Still Can’t Stop Listening to our Inner Saboteur
The image of Mona’s "dead" body in the trunk of a car is one of the most iconic (and traumatic) visuals from Pretty Little Liars season 5. At the time, we all thought she was gone for good. The grief the characters felt—especially Hanna and Mona’s mom, Leona—gave the show an emotional weight it sometimes lacked.
Of course, because this is Rosewood, "dead" is a relative term.
The Dollhouse and the "Charles" Reveal
Let's talk about the finale: "Welcome to the Dollhouse."
It’s easily the best episode of the season, if not the entire series. After Alison is found guilty of Mona’s murder (which she didn't commit), the Liars are arrested as accessories. But they never make it to prison.
A hijacks the van and takes them to a literal life-sized dollhouse.
🔗 Read more: Emily Piggford Movies and TV Shows: Why You Recognize That Face
What went down in the bunker:
- The girls woke up in rooms that were exact replicas of their own bedrooms.
- Mona was alive! But she was being forced to pretend she was Alison, complete with the blonde wig and the yellow top.
- They were forced to "play" out a prom from years ago.
- Spencer discovered the name Charles.
That reveal—that A’s name was Charles DiLaurentis—blew the fandom apart. We didn't know who he was yet (hello, Charlotte), but the psychological horror of the dollhouse was a level of intensity the show hadn't reached before. It felt less like a teen soap and more like a Saw movie for the ABC Family crowd.
Why Season 5 Still Matters Today
People love to complain about the plot holes in PLL. Trust me, I get it. Why was Toby a cop after like two weeks of training? Why did the parents never notice their kids were missing for weeks?
But Pretty Little Liars season 5 worked because it explored the trauma of being a victim. It wasn't just about the "Who is A?" mystery anymore. It was about how these girls were fundamentally broken by the games being played with their lives.
It also tackled the idea of redemption. We saw Hanna trying to find her own identity outside of "Alison’s twin," and Emily struggling with her feelings for a girl who was objectively kind of a monster.
If you’re planning a rewatch, pay close attention to the clues in Mona’s mirror and the background of the Radley scenes. The writers were dropping hints about Charles and the DiLaurentis family tree way earlier than most people realize.
Next Steps for Your Rewatch:
- Focus on the "A" endings in the second half of the season; the clues for the Dollhouse are hidden in plain sight.
- Re-examine the scenes between Mrs. DiLaurentis and Bethany Young in the flashbacks—they explain so much about why Charles was so angry.
- Watch Hanna's transformation; her "dark Hanna" phase is a direct reaction to Ali's return and is some of Ashley Benson's best work.