You’ve heard it a thousand times. Your grandma said it when you were picking out colleges. Your financial advisor says it every time you look at your 401(k) statement. Even your tech-savvy friend says it about their crypto wallet. Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. It’s the ultimate safety net of a sentence. It’s the linguistic equivalent of a warm blanket. But here’s the thing: sometimes, following that advice is exactly how you end up with a bunch of empty baskets and no breakfast.
Risk is a funny thing. We’re taught to fear it, to spread it out until it’s so thin you can’t even feel the impact of a win. But if you look at how real wealth is actually built—or how the most successful projects in history came to be—you’ll find that people often did the exact opposite. They found a really good basket, checked it for holes, and then shoved every single egg they had inside it.
The Origin Story of a Cliché
Where did this even come from? It’s not just a folk saying. The sentiment shows up as early as the 1600s. Miguel de Cervantes wrote in Don Quixote that it is "the part of a wise man to keep himself today for tomorrow, and not venture all his eggs in one basket."
It makes sense on a surface level. If you’re a 17th-century farmer and you trip while carrying everything, you’re starving. But we aren't farmers carrying literal eggs anymore. We’re dealing with asset allocation, career pivots, and intellectual property. In the world of Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT), which Harry Markowitz pioneered in the 1950s, this concept became "diversification." Markowitz actually won a Nobel Prize for basically proving that you can reduce risk without necessarily hitting your returns by spreading out your investments.
He wasn't wrong. For the average person just trying to retire at 65 without losing their shirt, diversification is a godsend. It protects you from your own ignorance. If you don't know which tech company is going to blow up next year, buying an index fund is the smart move. You’re buying the whole coop.
When Diversification Becomes "Di-worse-ification"
Peter Lynch, the legendary manager of the Fidelity Magellan Fund, coined a term that I absolutely love: di-worse-ification.
🔗 Read more: USD to Swedish SEK: Why the Krona is Still Struggling (and What Comes Next)
It happens when you’re so afraid of having too much of one thing that you start buying things you don't understand or that aren't actually good, just to "balance" things out. Honestly, it’s a trap. Imagine you own a fantastic business that’s growing at 20% a year. You have extra cash. Instead of putting it back into that winning business, you buy a failing dry cleaner down the street because "don't put all your eggs in one basket," right?
That’s a bad move. You’ve just lowered your overall quality to satisfy a proverb.
Concentration creates wealth; diversification preserves it. That’s the unspoken rule of the ultra-rich. Look at Warren Buffett. While he talks about the safety of index funds for the general public, his own portfolio at Berkshire Hathaway is often heavily weighted in just a handful of stocks like Apple or Coca-Cola. He’s famously said that "diversification is protection against ignorance. It makes little sense if you know what you are doing."
The Psychological Cost of Too Many Baskets
There’s a mental tax we pay when we spread ourselves too thin. This applies to careers just as much as money.
If you're trying to be a world-class pianist, a semi-pro coder, and a gourmet chef all at the same time, you’re probably going to be mediocre at all three. You’re hedging your bets against failure, but in doing so, you’re also hedging against elite success.
Focus is a finite resource.
When you decide to don't put all your eggs in one basket, you are essentially saying, "I'm not sure which of these is going to work." That's fine if you're exploring. But at some point, the most successful people find their "one thing" and go all in. Think about Elon Musk in 2008. He had $180 million from the sale of PayPal. He could have put it in T-bills and lived like a king. Instead, he split it between Tesla and SpaceX. When both companies were on the verge of bankruptcy, he didn't diversify further to save himself. He went "all in" on the baskets he believed in. He lived on borrowed rent money to keep the companies afloat.
It was risky. It was terrifying. It also changed the world.
How to Actually Manage Your Baskets
So, should you go out and bet your mortgage on a random penny stock? No. Obviously not. The trick isn't to ignore the advice entirely, but to understand when to apply it.
1. The Survival Stage
If you are just starting out, or if losing your "eggs" means you can't pay rent or feed your kids, you absolutely must diversify. This is the "Emergency Fund" phase of life. You need safety. You need multiple baskets because you can't afford the downside of a single mistake.
2. The Growth Stage
Once you have a baseline of security, sticking strictly to "don't put all your eggs in one basket" can actually hold you back. This is where you look for asymmetric bets. An asymmetric bet is something where the downside is limited (you only lose what you put in) but the upside is huge.
3. The Monitoring Phase
Andrew Carnegie, the steel tycoon, had a great counter-quote to the egg proverb. He said: "The way to get rich is to put all your eggs in one basket and then watch that basket."
Most people fail because they stop watching. They set it and forget it. If you’re going to concentrate your efforts or your money, you have to be obsessive. You have to know that basket better than anyone else in the world. You need to know if the wicker is fraying before the bottom falls out.
Real World Examples of Concentration Gone Right (and Wrong)
Let's talk about real stakes.
In the early 2000s, Apple was basically a computer company. When they decided to make the iPod, and later the iPhone, they weren't just "diversifying" their product line. They were pivoting the entire weight of the company into mobile devices. They put their best engineers on it. They bet the brand. If the iPhone had flopped, Apple might not exist today.
On the flip side, look at the 2008 financial crisis. Banks had "diversified" their risk by slicing up subprime mortgages and mixing them into complex securities called CDOs. They thought that by spreading the "bad eggs" across thousands of different baskets, they were safe. They weren't. The baskets were all sitting on the same shaky table. When the table broke, every basket fell.
This is the "Correlation" problem. Sometimes you think you’re diversified, but all your assets are actually tied to the same underlying factor. If you own five different tech stocks, you don't have five baskets. You have one big tech basket with five dividers.
Actionable Steps for the Modern Risk-Taker
If you’re feeling like your current strategy is a bit too "spread out" and you're not seeing the growth you want, here’s how to pivot without ruining your life.
Audit your "baskets" right now. Look at your bank account, your side hustles, and your career skills. Are you doing ten things at a 4/10 level? Pick the two that have the highest potential and move your "eggs" (time and money) there.
Define your "Uncle" point. If you’re going to put a lot of resources into one area, you need a pre-determined exit strategy. "I will keep all my eggs in this basket unless the value drops by X percent, or unless this specific metric isn't met by December." This prevents emotional decision-making when things get hairy.
Distinguish between "Low Risk" and "Low Volatility." A lot of people think putting all their money in a savings account is "safe" because the number doesn't go down. But with inflation, you’re guaranteed to lose purchasing power. That’s a 100% chance of a small loss. Sometimes, the "one basket" approach (like starting a business) has high volatility but a lower risk of long-term failure if you’re talented.
Build "Micro-Baskets" within a Macro-Strategy.
If you’re a freelance writer, don't just write about "everything." Pick a niche like "SaaS FinTech." Now you're concentrated in one industry (the basket), but you can have multiple clients within that industry (the eggs). You get the benefits of expertise and the safety of multiple income streams.
The phrase don't put all your eggs in one basket is a great rule for staying alive. It’s a mediocre rule for getting ahead.
The most successful people I know are the ones who spent years finding the right basket, spent months making sure the handle was sturdy, and then had the guts to put everything they owned inside it. It’s scary. It’s uncomfortable. It’s also usually the only way to win big.
Stop worrying about the number of baskets. Start worrying about the quality of the eggs.
Next Steps for You:
- Identify your "Core Competency" (the basket you know best).
- Calculate what percentage of your total resources (time/money) is currently invested there.
- If that number is less than 50%, ask yourself if you're actually diversifying or just hiding from the pressure of going all-in.
- Reallocate 10% of your "scattered" resources into your core basket this week and monitor the results.