When you walk into a Barnes & Noble today, you probably smell that specific mix of vanilla-scented candles, Starbucks espresso, and fresh ink. It feels permanent. Like it's always been there. But if you're asking when did barnes and noble open, the answer is actually a lot messier than a single date on a ribbon-cutting ceremony.
Honestly, it depends on what you mean by "open."
Are we talking about the first guy with the name selling books? Or the first actual store in New York? Or maybe the "modern" version of the giant green-awning superstores we all know? Depending on who you ask, you'll get 1873, 1917, or 1971.
Let's break it down.
The 1873 Myth (And the Illinois Connection)
If you look at the company’s official corporate history, they love to claim 1873 as their birth year. It makes them feel old and established. But in 1873, there was no "Barnes & Noble." There was just a guy named Charles Montgomery Barnes.
Charles was a former minister who decided to start a second-hand book business out of his home in Wheaton, Illinois. He wasn't selling the latest thrillers or celebrity memoirs. He was a "jobber" for school books. Basically, he bought used textbooks and sold them to local students who couldn't afford new ones.
It was a small-time operation. Eventually, he moved into Chicago, and his son, William, joined the family business. This is where the story splits. That Chicago company actually evolved into what we now know as Follett Corporation. So, while the "Barnes" name started in 1873, the actual brand we recognize wouldn't exist for another forty-something years.
✨ Don't miss: Steve Gall in Granite Bay: What Most People Get Wrong About His Real Estate Career
The Real Birth: 1917 in Manhattan
The year 1917 is the one that really counts. This is when did barnes and noble open as a partnership.
William Barnes (the son from Illinois) moved to New York City. He wasn't looking to start from scratch. He partnered up with Gilbert Clifford Noble, who was already working at a bookstore called Arthur Hinds & Company. Noble had been there since 1886, starting as a clerk and working his way up.
They shook hands, merged their interests, and opened their first store together at 31 West 15th Street in Manhattan.
That was the official debut of the Barnes & Noble name.
It wasn't a "superstore." It was a specialized shop. They focused on academic books, textbooks, and technical manuals. If you were a New York intellectual or a college student in the 1920s, that’s where you went. They weren't trying to sell you a leather-bound journal or a LEGO set back then.
The Depression and the Fifth Avenue Move
Things got real in 1932.
Think about that timing. The Great Depression was absolutely crushing the American economy. Most businesses were folding. Instead of shrinking, Barnes & Noble decided to go big. They moved their flagship store to 18th Street and Fifth Avenue.
This location became a New York institution. It stayed open for over 80 years before finally closing in 2014.
During the 1940s, they were actually pioneers in weird ways. They were one of the first stores to pipe in Muzak—that "elevator music"—to keep people shopping longer. They even invented a "book-a-teria" system during the war years. It was basically a cafeteria-style line where you picked your textbooks and paid at the end. Efficient? Yes. Cozy? Not really.
1971: The Leonard Riggio Takeover
The Barnes & Noble you actually shop at today—the one with the couches and the "buy one get one 50% off" deals—really started in 1971.
By the late 60s, the company was sort of dying. It had been sold to a conglomerate called Amtel that didn't know what to do with it. The business had shriveled down to just the one flagship store and a wholesale operation.
Enter Leonard Riggio.
Riggio was a college dropout who had started a successful competing bookstore called the Student Book Exchange (SBX) across the street. He borrowed $1.2 million to buy the Barnes & Noble name and that single Fifth Avenue shop.
Riggio is the guy who changed everything. He didn't just want to sell books; he wanted to sell the experience of being a reader. He was the first to start discounting New York Times bestsellers by 40%. Other booksellers hated him for it. They thought he was cheapening the "sanctity" of literature.
Riggio didn't care. He wanted everyone to feel welcome, not just professors and elites.
Why the 90s Changed the Game
In the early 90s, the company went on a tear. They started opening "superstores." These were 25,000-square-foot behemoths with cafes and comfy chairs.
👉 See also: Joseph Lawrence Sr: The Truth Behind the Man Who Changed Medicine (and Hollywood)
- 1987: They bought B. Dalton Bookseller, which gave them 797 stores in malls across the country.
- 1993: The company went public on the New York Stock Exchange.
- 1997: They finally launched their website to fight back against a tiny startup called Amazon.
People often forget that before Amazon was the villain, Barnes & Noble was the "big bad" of the book world. They were the ones putting the small "mom and pop" shops out of business. It’s funny how perspective shifts over thirty years.
Where Are They Now?
After a rough decade of nearly going bankrupt thanks to the rise of e-readers and Amazon's dominance, Barnes & Noble is actually having a weirdly successful comeback.
In 2019, a hedge fund called Elliott Advisors bought the company and put James Daunt in charge. Daunt had already saved Waterstones in the UK. His strategy? Stop acting like a boring corporate chain and start acting like an independent bookstore again.
He told local managers they could pick their own books and design their own displays. No more "planograms" sent from a corporate office in New York.
It’s working.
New stores are opening for the first time in years. They're smaller, punchier, and focused on "BookTok" trends and local interests.
🔗 Read more: Getting Rid of the Penny: What Most People Get Wrong About Trump’s Order
Actionable Insights for Book Lovers and Business Nerds
If you're looking to understand the timeline of when did barnes and noble open, keep these milestones in your pocket:
- Check your local store's history: Many newer B&N locations are actually former Borders or Waldenbooks sites that were rebranded after those companies folded.
- Look for the "First Edition" signage: Some flagship-style stores still have legacy markers or displays that reference the 1917 founding.
- Support local curation: If you notice your local B&N has a weirdly specific section (like a massive "Local Authors" shelf or a strange obsession with Gothic Horror), that's because of the 2019 policy shift. Engage with the staff; they actually have more control over the inventory now than they did ten years ago.
- Verify the "Est. 1873" claim: When you see that date on a tote bag, remember it's a bit of a marketing stretch. The brand name you're holding didn't exist until 1917, and the store experience you're enjoying was born in 1971.