Football is unfair. Ask any Bills fan who watched the 2024 AFC Divisional Round, or the 2021 "13 Seconds" meltdown, and they won’t talk about Patrick Mahomes’ brilliance first. They’ll talk about the flags. Or the lack of them. The history of bad calls in Chiefs Bills game matchups has become its own sub-genre of NFL lore, a frustrating mix of subjective officiating and high-stakes drama that seems to break Buffalo's heart every single time they meet in January.
It's not just salt.
When you have two titans like Josh Allen and Mahomes, the margin for error is razor-thin. One missed holding call or a questionable "peace sign" taunting penalty doesn't just change a set of downs; it alters the trajectory of a decade. We saw it again recently. The tension in Highmark Stadium wasn't just about the wind or the missed field goals. It was about the feeling that the zebras had a hand in the script.
The Offside That Changed Everything (And Why It Wasn't a Bad Call)
You can't talk about officiating in this rivalry without starting with Kadarius Toney. Remember the 2023 regular-season clash? Late in the game, Kelce pulls off a lateral for the ages. Toney streaks into the end zone. The stadium is dead. Then, the flag.
Toney was lined up offside.
Fans screamed that it was a "bad call" because officials usually give a warning. Mahomes was livid on the sidelines, yelling at the refs that they "ruined" a legendary moment. But looking back, was it actually a bad call? Honestly, no. Rules are rules. But the inconsistency is what drives people crazy. If you don't call it for three quarters, why call it on the game-winning play? This specific moment set the stage for the narrative that the officiating crew is always the "third team" on the field during these matchups.
📖 Related: Shedeur Sanders Draft Room: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Fumble Out of the End Zone: A Rule Everyone Hates
During the 2024 Divisional Playoff, Mecole Hardman fumbled the ball through the end zone. Touchback. Bills ball.
Wait.
While that specific call actually favored the Bills, it highlighted the sheer chaos of how these games are officiated. Later in that same contest, there were multiple instances where Bills fans felt Josh Allen was hit late without a whistle. Or the missed pass interference on a crucial third down. When we talk about bad calls in Chiefs Bills game history, it’s usually the "no-calls" that hurt the most.
Referees seem to "let them play" in the postseason. That sounds great in theory until a defender has a handful of jersey while the ball is in the air.
The Subjectivity of Roughing the Passer
Kansas City gets the benefit of the doubt. That’s the consensus in Western New York. Whether it’s true or just a byproduct of Mahomes being the face of the league is up for debate, but the numbers in certain high-pressure moments are jarring.
👉 See also: Seattle Seahawks Offense Rank: Why the Top-Three Scoring Unit Still Changed Everything
Take a look at the landing zone hits. In multiple games, Josh Allen—because he's built like a linebacker—doesn't get the same "protected" whistles that smaller or more "traditional" pocket passers receive. There was a hit in the 2022 matchup where Allen was clearly struck in the helmet. No flag. Three plays later, a defender brushes Mahomes' jersey after the ball is gone. 15 yards.
It’s that lack of symmetry that fuels the "rigged" conspiracies on social media. It isn't that the refs are actively trying to help the Chiefs; it's that the superstars often command a certain level of unconscious bias from the officiating crew.
Why These Mistakes Happen in High-Stakes Moments
- The Pace of Play: Both Buffalo and KC run high-tempo offenses. Officials often struggle to get into position, leading to "guessing" on holding calls.
- The Mahomes Factor: When a quarterback scrambles for 10 seconds, offensive linemen are almost forced to hold. Refs can't see everything, so they often miss the initial grab but catch the late shove.
- Crowd Noise: In Orchard Park, the noise is deafening. Communication between officials breaks down, leading to those awkward "conference" huddles that take five minutes and result in a "no foul on the play" announcement.
Looking at the Pass Interference Non-Calls
Pass interference is the most subjective call in sports. In the 2024 playoff game, there was a specific route by Stefon Diggs where the defender clearly didn't play the ball and made contact early. The back judge had a clear view. No flag.
If that flag is thrown, the Bills are in field goal range. They likely win. They likely move on to the AFC Championship.
Instead, the drive stalls.
✨ Don't miss: Seahawks Standing in the NFL: Why Seattle is Stuck in the Playoff Purgatory Middle
Then you look at the other side. Travis Kelce is a master of the "push-off." He does it subtly, just enough to create space. Bills defenders have been flagged for far less contact while trying to jam him at the line. This isn't just about "bad" officiating; it's about the "veteran savvy" of the Chiefs knowing exactly how much they can get away with before a flag comes out.
The Problem With "Letting Them Play"
NFL officiating crews for the playoffs are "all-star" crews. They aren't the same units that work together all season. This is a massive mistake by the league. You take the best individual refs and throw them together, but they haven't built the chemistry needed to manage a game this fast.
This leads to the bad calls in Chiefs Bills game history because the communication isn't seamless. One ref thinks his partner has the deep ball; the other thinks his partner has the line of scrimmage. The result? A clear penalty happens in the "dead zone" where nobody is looking.
How to Handle Officiating Frustration as a Fan
If you're betting on these games or just emotionally invested, you have to account for the "ref factor." It's as much a part of the game as the weather.
- Check the Officiating Crew: Before kickoff, look up who the head ref is. Some refs, like Shawn Smith, tend to call fewer penalties in big games. Others are "flag-happy."
- Focus on the Replay Rules: Understand that many "judgement calls" like holding or pass interference are not reviewable in the way fans want them to be.
- The Three-Point Rule: Coaches often say you have to be at least three points better than your opponent to overcome bad officiating. The Bills have often been exactly equal to the Chiefs, which leaves the door open for a single bad whistle to decide the season.
Actionable Steps for the Future
The NFL needs to move toward "SkyCam" officiating or a dedicated "Eye in the Sky" that can buzz down and correct an obvious missed call in real-time without a lengthy review process. Until then, the rivalry between Buffalo and Kansas City will always be tainted by the feeling that the better team didn't always win—sometimes, it was just the team that didn't get caught.
To minimize the impact of officiating on your own viewing experience, track the penalty trends early in the first quarter. If the refs are calling it tight, expect the Chiefs' defense to struggle. If they are letting them play, the Bills' physical secondary has the advantage. Understanding these nuances won't change the scoreboard, but it’ll certainly make the "bad calls" feel less like a conspiracy and more like a predictable part of the modern NFL landscape.