It happened on a random Saturday in October 2017. Syfy dropped a low-budget supernatural flick that honestly didn't look like much on the surface. You know the trope. A group of teenagers decides to spend Halloween in an abandoned house that—shocker—is actually haunted by a malevolent force. But here is the thing about the House of the Witch cast: they actually leaned into the campy, terrifying premise with more heart than you'd expect from a TV movie.
People still hunt for this cast list. Why? Because a few of these actors have popped up in much bigger projects since they were running away from a practical-effects hag in a creepy basement. It’s one of those "wait, was that him?" kind of movies.
🔗 Read more: Rurouni Kenshin Where to Watch: Navigating the Messy Rights of the Hit Samurai Epic
The Lead Players: Who Anchored the Chaos?
The heavy lifting falls on Emily Bader, who plays Lana. If you've kept up with your supernatural teen dramas, you probably recognize her from the Charmed reboot or more recently as the lead in My Lady Jane. Back in 2017, she was the quintessential final girl. She’s got this grounded energy that makes the ridiculousness of a "witch curse" feel a bit more visceral.
Then you have Darren Mann. He plays Shane. Darren is arguably the biggest breakout from this specific group. If you’ve watched 1923 (the Yellowstone prequel), he’s Jack Dutton. He was also Luke Chalfant in Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. Seeing him in House of the Witch is sort of like looking at a time capsule. He was already doing the "charming but troubled" thing well before he was riding horses on a Montana ranch.
Michelle Randolph plays Raquel. She’s another one who stayed in the Taylor Sheridan universe, appearing alongside Darren in 1923 as Elizabeth Strafford. It’s kind of wild that two of the main teens in this Syfy horror ended up being the romantic core of a massive prestige Western years later.
The Rest of the Friend Group
You can't have a slasher-style setup without a diverse mix of personalities to fill out the body count. Coy Stewart plays Dax. Coy was already a bit of a veteran by then, having done a ton of work on Nickelodeon's Bella and the Bulldogs and the TBS sitcom Are We There Yet?. He brings a necessary levity to the movie.
The cast is rounded out by:
- Arden Belle as Taylor.
- Jesse Pepe as Skyler.
Pepe is an interesting one. He’s not just an actor; he’s heavily into music and has a very specific, edgy vibe that fit the "bad boy with a sensitive side" archetype perfectly.
Why the House of the Witch Cast Worked Better Than Expected
Usually, these made-for-TV horror movies suffer from what I call "cardboard acting." You don't care when they die. You might even cheer for the witch. But the chemistry here felt real.
The movie was directed by Alex Merkin. He clearly knew he wasn't making Hereditary. He was making a popcorn flick. Because the actors took the stakes seriously, the audience could actually enjoy the jump scares. When Lana and Shane are trapped, you aren't just looking at the lighting; you're looking at two actors who would eventually go on to lead much bigger productions.
The "Witch" Behind the Mask
We have to talk about the antagonist. The witch itself isn't just CGI. It's a combination of physical performance and makeup. While the credits often focus on the teens, the creature work is what stays with you. It’s that jerky, unnatural movement that defined 2010s horror.
✨ Don't miss: Alice in Wonderland with Johnny Depp: Why the 2010 Movie Still Divides Fans Today
Where Can You See Them Now?
If you're looking at the House of the Witch cast and thinking they look familiar, here is the quick cheat sheet for your "hey, it's that guy" moments:
- Darren Mann: Check out 1923 on Paramount+ or Animal Kingdom. He’s gone full leading man.
- Emily Bader: She’s the titular lead in My Lady Jane on Amazon Prime. It’s a huge jump from Syfy horror to a high-budget period fantasy.
- Michelle Randolph: Also in 1923. She’s transitioned into very high-profile dramatic roles.
- Coy Stewart: He’s been active in various shorts and series, continuing a very steady career that started when he was just a kid.
Is It Worth a Rewatch for the Cast Alone?
Honestly? Yeah.
It’s fun to see "before they were famous" performances. You can see the raw talent in Emily Bader even when she’s screaming at a ghost. The movie doesn't overstay its welcome. It’s a lean 90 minutes.
The plot is basic. The house is creepy. The ending is... well, it’s a horror movie ending. It leaves the door just a tiny bit ajar in case they ever wanted a sequel, which never happened. But the legacy of the film lives on through these actors' resumes.
💡 You might also like: Kelly Clarkson AMAs 2025: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
How to Track Their Careers Effectively
If you're a fan of this specific era of horror, the best way to keep up with the House of the Witch cast is to follow their production companies rather than just their social media. Many of them have moved into indie producing.
Check out the IMDb "Pro" links if you have access, or just keep an eye on Taylor Sheridan's casting calls, as he seems to have a real affinity for the people who survived this fictional haunted house.
To dig deeper into this specific niche of horror, start by looking into the filmography of Alex Merkin. He has a knack for picking young talent right before they blow up. Also, look into the casting director for this project; they clearly had an eye for future stars. You might find other low-budget gems with surprisingly high-caliber ensembles.
Next Steps for Horror Fans
- Verify the Streaming Status: As of 2026, House of the Witch frequently rotates through platforms like AMC+, Shudder, and the Roku Channel.
- Compare Performances: Watch Darren Mann in this and then jump straight to 1923. The range is actually impressive.
- Explore the Sub-Genre: If you liked the vibe, look for other Syfy originals from the 2017-2018 window. There was a specific "look" to these films that utilized similar Vancouver-based or Southern US-based crews and talent pools.