You’ve probably heard the loud, confident claims before. Maybe you were at a bar in Montreal, or a small diner in Windsor, Nova Scotia. Someone bangs their fist on the table and swears their hometown is the one true "Birthplace of Hockey."
They’re all kinda right. And they’re all kinda wrong.
Honestly, pinpointing exactly where did ice hockey begin is like trying to find the specific cloud that started a rainstorm. It didn't just "poof" into existence one Tuesday morning because some guy had an epiphany. It was a messy, decades-long evolution involving Scottish immigrants, British soldiers, Mi’kmaq craftsmen, and a bunch of rowdy college kids who just wanted to hit something with a stick.
The Montreal Myth (and Reality)
If you’re looking for the "official" start date, March 3, 1875, is the big one. This is when the first organized indoor game went down at the Victoria Skating Rink in Montreal.
James Creighton is the name you’ll see in the history books. He was a young man from Halifax who moved to Montreal and basically said, "Hey, let's take this game we play outdoors and put it inside where it's not minus-forty degrees."
They used a flat wooden disk instead of a ball. Why? Because a ball would bounce into the spectators and probably break someone's nose. They had nine players per side. They had rules. They even had a post-game brawl with some local skaters who were mad that the hockey players were hogging the ice.
🔗 Read more: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
Classic hockey.
But here is the thing: Creighton didn’t "invent" the game that night. He just organized it. People had been playing versions of "shinny" or "ice hurley" on frozen ponds for a hundred years before that puck—well, wooden block—ever dropped in Montreal.
The "Cradle of Hockey" Contenders
While Montreal claims the first organized game, other places claim the soul of the sport.
Windsor, Nova Scotia
Windsor calls itself the "Birthplace of Hockey." Their evidence? A mention in an 1844 novel by Thomas Chandler Haliburton about boys at King’s College School playing "hurly on the ice." It's a strong claim, and the town leans into it hard with a "Cradle of Hockey" museum.
Kingston, Ontario
Then there’s Kingston. They claimed for years that British soldiers played the first game there in 1843. This claim was so influential it actually helped Kingston land the original Hockey Hall of Fame, though the "evidence" turned out to be a bit shaky and mostly based on fuzzy memories.
💡 You might also like: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
The Northwest Territories
Even the Arctic wants a piece of the action. Sir John Franklin, the famous explorer, wrote in his diary in 1825 about his men playing "hockey on the ice" at Fort Franklin (now Délįne). If that’s the metric, the north wins the timeline battle by a landslide.
The Missing Indigenous Link
We can't talk about where did ice hockey begin without talking about the Mi’kmaq people of Nova Scotia. Long before European settlers were "organizing" games, the Mi’kmaq were playing alchamadijik.
They used sticks carved from the root of the yellow birch. These weren't just random sticks; they were beautifully crafted tools. In fact, for decades in the late 1800s and early 1900s, "Mic-Mac" hockey sticks were the gold standard. If you were a serious player back then, you didn't want a mass-produced piece of lumber. You wanted a Mi’kmaq stick.
The European game of "hurling" or "shinty" collided with Indigenous traditions and the North American game of lacrosse. This "collision" is what actually created ice hockey. It's a hybrid. A mutt of a sport.
Why the Rules Changed Everything
The game used to be chaos. Imagine 30 people on the ice, no zones, and you couldn't even pass the puck forward.
📖 Related: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
- The Puck: Switching from a ball to a flat disk changed the physics. It stayed on the ice, which allowed for actual strategy.
- The Number of Players: It went from "whoever shows up" to nine, then seven, then finally the six-per-side we see today.
- The Goalie: In the early days, if a goalie fell down to make a save, it was a penalty. They were expected to stand tall like "gentlemen." Thank goodness that rule died out.
How to Win Your Next Hockey History Argument
If you want to sound like a real expert next time this comes up, don't just pick one city. Nuance is your friend.
Basically, you’ve got to separate the activity from the sport.
The activity of hitting a thing with a stick on ice? That’s ancient and happened everywhere from Scotland to the ponds of Nova Scotia. The sport of ice hockey—with a codified rulebook, a defined rink, and a recorded score? That’s a product of 1870s Montreal.
Actionable Insights for the History Buff
- Visit Long Pond: If you're ever in Windsor, NS, go to Long Pond. Even if the "first game" debate is never settled, standing on that ice feels like standing on hallowed ground.
- Read the SIHR Reports: The Society for International Hockey Research is the "Supreme Court" of hockey history. If they say a claim is "unsubstantiated," believe them.
- Support Indigenous Makers: Look into the history of the Mi’kmaq stick-making tradition. It's a huge part of the game's DNA that often gets overshadowed by the NHL's corporate history.
At the end of the day, hockey didn't start in a vacuum. It was a slow-motion car crash of different cultures, climates, and cravings for something to do during a brutal Canadian winter. It belongs to everyone who ever laced up a pair of skates and felt that first chill on their face.
Next Steps for You
- Research the 1875 Montreal game to see the original "nines" who played.
- Trace the evolution of the Stanley Cup from a small silver bowl to the massive trophy it is now.
- Explore the early rules of the AHA (Amateur Hockey Association) to see how different the game looked in the 1880s.