If you’re a Steelers fan, you’ve basically spent the last four years in a constant state of "who’s under center today?" It's exhausting. Honestly, the post-Ben Roethlisberger era hasn't been the smooth transition we all hoped for.
Right now, in January 2026, the starting QB for Pittsburgh Steelers is a question mark wrapped in a mystery, tucked inside a 42-year-old’s decision-making process.
The Aaron Rodgers Experiment
Aaron Rodgers is the guy. For now.
He came to Pittsburgh on a one-year "experiment" for the 2025 season. He’s 42. He’s still got the arm, mostly, and that weird Benjamin Button vibe where he claims he feels younger than ever. But here’s the reality: he’s a free agent as soon as this postseason run ends. He’s been efficient, sure, and he’s kept the Steelers in the hunt for the AFC North, but he’s also 42 with a mended wrist.
The vibe around the facility is that Rodgers might not be back. He hasn't slammed the door, but he’s talking about "options." In Rodgers-speak, that usually means he’s looking at the exit.
💡 You might also like: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
Who Else is in the Room?
If Rodgers walks, the depth chart is... well, it’s a bit thin.
- Mason Rudolph: The ultimate survivor. He’s back on a two-year deal he signed in 2025. He’s the "safe" choice. He knows the playbook, the city, and exactly how the Primanti Bros. sandwich tastes after a win. He stepped in when Rodgers hurt his wrist against Cincinnati and didn’t blink.
- Will Howard: The rookie out of Ohio State. He was a sixth-round pick, so the expectations aren't sky-high yet. But he’s got size. He’s the project that hasn’t really been tested in a real-game scenario.
- Skylar Thompson: He’s there. He’s depth. He’s probably not the future.
The Russell Wilson and Justin Fields Hangover
Remember 2024? That feels like a decade ago.
Russell Wilson is currently in New York, trying to convince the Giants he can still play after a pretty rough 2025 stint. He recently switched agents to David Mulugheta, which is basically the NFL version of a "new year, new me" Instagram post.
And Justin Fields? He’s with the Jets. He started 2024 strong for Pittsburgh (4-2 record!), but Mike Tomlin went back to Wilson, and the rest is history. Fields didn’t quite light it up in New York, and there are already whispers about him potentially coming back to the Steelers as a low-cost veteran option for 2026. It's funny how things circle back.
📖 Related: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
The 2026 Draft Dilemma
Pittsburgh is hosting the NFL Draft this year. It would be poetic to draft a franchise guy in your own backyard, right?
The problem is the 2026 QB class is kind of a mess.
- Fernando Mendoza: The Indiana standout. He’s almost certainly going #1 to the Raiders.
- Dante Moore: He’s staying at Oregon for another year. Ouch.
- Ty Simpson: Maybe? He’s the Alabama guy with a lot of hype but not a ton of starts.
The Steelers likely won't pick high enough to get a "sure thing." They’re too good to be bad, which is the classic Pittsburgh curse.
Wildcards: The Veteran Market
General Manager Omar Khan is known for being aggressive. If Rodgers retires or moves on, keep an eye on these names:
👉 See also: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
- Kirk Cousins: He’s in a weird spot with Atlanta. A restructured contract means he could be a free agent by March. He’d be another "cheap veteran" move, which seems to be the Steelers’ current brand.
- Kyler Murray: Rumors are swirling that Arizona might be ready to move on. He’s expensive, but he’s dynamic.
- Malik Willis: He’s been backing up Jordan Love in Green Bay and looked incredible in his limited 2025 action. He’s that "Lamar Lite" type that could modernize the Steelers' offense.
What Happens Next?
The Steelers are at a crossroads. They’ve spent two years plugging holes with legends like Wilson and Rodgers. It works for a season, but it doesn't build a decade.
If you're looking for the starting QB for Pittsburgh Steelers for the 2026 season opener, the smart money is on a veteran bridge like Mason Rudolph or a high-upside trade for someone like Malik Willis.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Watch the Rodgers Pressers: If he starts talking about "family" and "legacy" more than "next week," he's gone.
- Track the Head Coach Hire: With Mike Tomlin gone, the new coach will want "his guy." If they hire an offensive-minded coach, expect a big trade or a high draft pick.
- Monitor the March 13 Deadline: That’s when Kirk Cousins' status becomes clear. If he hits the market, the Steelers will be one of the first calls.
The search for the next Big Ben continues, but for now, it's just about surviving the playoffs with Rodgers.