It was August 15, 2021. You probably remember the footage. People were literally clinging to the sides of C-17 transport planes at Kabul’s airport because the fear of what was coming was greater than the fear of falling from the sky. It felt like the world shifted on its axis in a single afternoon. For twenty years, the U.S.-led coalition had poured trillions of dollars into a nation-building project that basically evaporated in a matter of weeks.
But what happened in Afghanistan isn't just about that chaotic exit. It’s about a total systemic collapse that caught the smartest people in the room off guard.
If you ask a veteran, a refugee, or a diplomat what went wrong, you’ll get three different stories. Some blame the Doha Agreement. Others point to the deep-seated corruption within the former Afghan Republic’s government. Honestly, it was a "perfect storm" of bad timing, intelligence failures, and a Taliban insurgency that was much more patient than the West.
The Collapse Nobody Predicted (But Everyone Should Have)
The speed of the Taliban’s takeover was the real shocker. By May 2021, they held maybe a few dozen districts. By August, they had the capital. How? It wasn't always through bloody battles. In many cases, the Afghan National Defense and Security Forces (ANDSF) simply stopped fighting.
Imagine you’re a soldier in a remote outpost. You haven't been paid in months. Your ammunition is low. Your superiors in Kabul are more interested in lining their pockets than sending you supplies. Then, the Taliban sends you a WhatsApp message: "Surrender, and we’ll give you safe passage and $500 to go home." What would you do? This happened at scale. It was a psychological victory long before it was a military one.
The "ghost soldier" phenomenon was a massive part of the rot. Basically, commanders would list thousands of non-existent soldiers on their rosters to pocket the salaries funded by U.S. taxpayers. When the Taliban pushed, the numbers on paper didn't match the boots on the ground. It was a hollow shell.
🔗 Read more: January 6th Explained: Why This Date Still Defines American Politics
The Doha Agreement’s Role
We have to talk about the 2020 Doha Agreement signed under the Trump administration. It’s widely cited by experts like Laurel Miller of the International Crisis Group as the beginning of the end. Why? Because it excluded the actual Afghan government from the negotiations. It signaled to everyone—the Taliban, the Afghan army, and regional neighbors—that the U.S. was leaving no matter what. It broke the morale of the local forces. They knew the air support they relied on was about to vanish.
What Happened in Afghanistan Since the Taliban Took Over?
Life changed overnight, especially for women. I’m not just talking about the burqa. It’s deeper. The Taliban initially promised a "moderate" version of their 1990s rule, but that didn't last. According to UN Human Rights reports, Afghanistan is currently the only country in the world where girls are banned from attending school beyond the sixth grade. It’s a literal erasure of half the population from public life.
The economy also fell off a cliff. When the Taliban rolled into Kabul, the U.S. froze roughly $7 billion in Afghan central bank assets. International aid, which previously accounted for about 75% of the government's budget, stopped.
Suddenly, a country already struggling with drought and poverty found itself with no cash. You’ve got doctors and teachers working for free because there’s no currency to pay them. It’s a humanitarian disaster that’s still unfolding in real-time. Families have been forced to sell furniture—and in some horrific, documented cases, their own children—just to buy flour.
The Security Paradox
Here is something weird that most people don't talk about: the security situation is technically "better" for some people.
💡 You might also like: Is there a bank holiday today? Why your local branch might be closed on January 12
If you are a farmer in a rural province that was a frontline for 20 years, the war is over. There are no more nighttime raids. No more IEDs on the roads. No more drone strikes. For the first time in a generation, people can travel between cities without getting caught in a crossfire.
But this "peace" is incredibly fragile. The Islamic State Khorasan Province (ISIS-K) is still there. They hate the Taliban as much as they hate the West. They’ve been carrying out brutal bombings at mosques and schools, mostly targeting the Hazara minority. So, while the "big war" ended, a shadow war between extremist groups is very much alive.
Human Rights and the "Morality Police"
The Ministry for the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice is back. They’ve replaced the Ministry of Women’s Affairs. They patrol the streets to enforce dress codes and ensure men grow beards and women have male chaperones (mahram) for long trips. It’s a return to a version of Sharia law that is strictly interpreted and harshly enforced.
The Brain Drain and the Global Fallout
When the government fell, the country lost its best and brightest. Doctors, engineers, pilots, and journalists fled. This "brain drain" means the Taliban is now trying to run a complex modern state with people who spent the last two decades living in caves or mountains. They know how to fight, but they don't necessarily know how to manage a national electrical grid or a central bank.
Regionally, countries like Pakistan, China, and Russia are playing a delicate game. Nobody wants a total collapse that leads to a massive refugee crisis or a playground for terrorists. But nobody really wants to officially recognize the Taliban government either. It’s a diplomatic limbo.
📖 Related: Is Pope Leo Homophobic? What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Insights and Reality Checks
If you’re looking to understand the current state of affairs or want to help, you need to look past the headlines. Here is the ground reality:
- Aid is complicated but necessary: Many people want to boycott the Taliban, but doing so starves the Afghan people. Supporting NGOs like the World Food Programme (WFP) or Doctors Without Borders (MSF) is the most direct way to get help to the vulnerable without funding the regime.
- The Refugee Crisis isn't over: Thousands of Afghans who worked with Western forces are still stuck in "third countries" or hiding in Afghanistan. Advocacy for the Afghan Adjustment Act in the U.S. is a major focus for veteran and human rights groups.
- Information is a weapon: The Taliban has cracked down on local journalism. Following sources like Amu TV or Rukhshana Media—which are run by Afghan journalists (often in exile)—gives you the most accurate picture of what is actually happening inside the country.
- Watch the borders: The relationship between the Taliban and Pakistan has soured significantly over border disputes and the TTP (Pakistani Taliban). This is a flashpoint that could reignite regional instability.
The story of what happened in Afghanistan is still being written. It wasn't just a 2021 event; it's a daily struggle for 40 million people trying to survive under a regime that the rest of the world has largely decided to ignore. Understanding the nuance—the corruption, the failed diplomacy, and the current humanitarian stakes—is the only way to avoid making the same mistakes again.
To stay informed, track the quarterly reports from SIGAR (Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction). They provide the most blunt, unvarnished assessments of how billions were spent and where the accountability failed. Watching the UN Security Council briefings on the "Situation in Afghanistan" is also the best way to see how the international community is attempting to negotiate for women's rights in exchange for economic relief.
---