United States Flag Burning: What Most People Get Wrong About the Law

It’s one of those things that makes people’s blood boil instantly. You see a video on social media of someone flicking a lighter at the Stars and Stripes, and the comments section turns into a war zone within seconds. Most folks think it’s a shut-and-case crime. They assume that because it’s the national symbol, there must be a law on the books that lands you in a jail cell for desecrating it.

Actually, it’s the opposite.

United States flag burning is technically legal. Well, "legal" is a boring way to put it—it's a constitutionally protected form of free speech. That doesn't mean it isn't controversial. It is. It’s arguably the most divisive expression of protest in American history. But if you're looking for the guys in suits to come hand out handcuffs just for the act of burning the flag, you’re going to be waiting a long time.

The story of how we got here isn't just about fire and fabric. It’s about a guy named Gregory Lee Johnson, a 1984 protest in Dallas, and a Supreme Court decision that forced the country to decide what "freedom" really looks like when it’s ugly.

The Night in Dallas That Changed Everything

In 1984, the Republican National Convention was happening in Dallas. Ronald Reagan was being renominated. Outside, things were getting rowdy. Gregory Lee Johnson, a member of the Revolutionary Communist Youth Brigade, ended up with an American flag that had been snatched from a flagpole.

He doused it in kerosene. He lit a match.

While the flag burned, protesters chanted, "America, the red, white, and blue, we spit on you." It was messy. It was loud. And at the time, Texas had a law against "desecration of a venerated object." Johnson was arrested, fined $2,000, and sentenced to a year in the local lockup.

He appealed. He argued his actions were "symbolic speech."

The case, Texas v. Johnson, eventually landed in front of the U.S. Supreme Court in 1989. You’d think the conservative justices would have slammed the door on him, right? Wrong. In a 5-4 decision that crossed ideological lines, the Court ruled that burning the flag was a protected form of "expressive conduct" under the First Amendment.

Justice William Brennan wrote the majority opinion. He basically said that if there is a bedrock principle underlying the First Amendment, it’s that the government may not prohibit the expression of an idea simply because society finds the idea itself offensive or disagreeable.

That’s a heavy pill to swallow for a lot of people.

👉 See also: Have the astronauts been rescued yet? What is actually happening with the Starliner crew

Wait, Isn’t There a Flag Code?

You’ve probably heard of the U.S. Flag Code. It’s a real thing—Title 4 of the United States Code. It’s full of rules about how to display the flag, when to hoist it, and how to fold it.

Section 8(k) of that code actually says the flag should be destroyed in a dignified way, preferably by burning, when it is no longer a fitting emblem for display.

Here’s the catch: The Flag Code is "suggestive." It isn’t enforceable.

There are no "Flag Police." If you leave your flag out in the rain or fly it upside down (which is technically only for "dire distress"), nobody is going to show up at your door with a warrant. The federal government can’t punish civilians for breaking these rules because of that pesky First Amendment.

It's kind of ironic. The "proper" way to dispose of a flag is to burn it, but the "protest" way to handle a flag is also to burn it. The difference is all in the intent and the ceremony. One is a funeral; the other is a scream.

The Flag Protection Act of 1989

Congress didn't take the Texas v. Johnson ruling lying down. There was an immediate uproar. Politicians on both sides of the aisle were tripping over themselves to show how much they loved the flag. They quickly passed the Flag Protection Act of 1989.

It was a direct middle finger to the Supreme Court.

The law made it a crime to knowingly mutilate, deface, physically defile, burn, or maintain on the floor or ground any flag of the United States. Almost immediately, people started burning flags specifically to challenge the new law.

One of those people was Shawn Eichman. Her case, United States v. Eichman, went to the Supreme Court just one year later in 1990. The Court didn't flinch. They struck down the federal law, too. They doubled down on the idea that you can't protect the symbol of freedom by destroying the freedom the symbol represents.

The Loophole: When Can You Actually Get Arrested?

Just because United States flag burning is protected speech doesn't mean you have a "get out of jail free" card for everything you do while holding a lighter. Context is everything in the eyes of the law.

If you steal a flag from your neighbor’s porch and burn it? That’s theft and destruction of property.

If you start a massive bonfire in the middle of a dry forest or on a crowded city sidewalk without a permit? That’s arson or a violation of local fire ordinances.

If you use the burning flag to incite an immediate riot or put people in physical danger? That’s "fighting words" or "inciting violence," which are categories of speech the First Amendment does not protect.

So, while the act of burning the flag as a statement is legal, the method you use to do it can still get you busted. It's a fine line. Police often use "disorderly conduct" or "breach of peace" charges to sweep up protesters, even if the flag burning itself is technically okay.

Why Do People Still Try to Ban It?

Since 1990, there have been dozens of attempts to pass a Constitutional Amendment to ban flag desecration. An amendment is the only way to bypass the Supreme Court's ruling.

It’s come remarkably close.

In 2006, a proposed amendment failed by just one single vote in the Senate. One. Most veterans' groups, like the American Legion, have been huge proponents of these bans. For them, the flag isn't just fabric; it’s a shroud for fallen comrades. It represents the lives lost to keep the country going. Seeing it scorched feels like a personal attack on their sacrifice.

On the other side, groups like the ACLU argue that the strength of America is that we allow people to hate the flag. They argue that in a truly free country, you don't need to force people to respect symbols. If you have to pass a law to make people respect the flag, the respect isn't real anyway.

Common Misconceptions About Flag Desecration

1. "It's treason." Nope. Treason is very narrowly defined in the Constitution (Article III, Section 3). It requires levying war against the U.S. or giving "Aid and Comfort" to enemies. Burning a flag doesn't qualify.
2. "You'll lose your citizenship." Total myth. The Supreme Court ruled in Afroyim v. Rusk (1967) that the government can't just strip away your citizenship for your actions or speech.
3. "It's illegal in other countries." This one is actually true. In many countries, like France, Germany, or India, desecrating the national flag can land you in prison. The United States is actually an outlier in how much protection it gives to flag burners.

The Cultural Impact

We've seen flag burning surge during specific moments in history. The Vietnam War was the big one. Then again during the Iraq War. More recently, we saw it during the 2020 racial justice protests.

Every time it happens, the same cycle repeats.

The images go viral. People get angry. Politicians give speeches. The Supreme Court precedents are cited. And usually, nothing changes legally. It remains a powerful, visceral tool for those who feel the government has failed them.

Interestingly, some of the most "patriotic" people often accidentally "desecrate" the flag according to the Flag Code. Have you ever seen an American flag napkin at a BBQ? Or flag-patterned swimsuits? Or a flag used as a cape? According to the official U.S. Flag Code, all of that is technically a no-no.

"The flag should never be used as wearing apparel, bedding, or drapery."

We’ve become a culture that "uses" the flag for everything, which some argue has cheapened the symbol more than any protester ever could.

How to Handle a Flag Situation (Actionable Steps)

If you find yourself in a situation where you need to dispose of a flag, or you’re witnessing a protest, here’s how to navigate it without losing your cool or breaking a law.

For Proper Disposal:
Don't just throw an old, tattered flag in the trash. It feels wrong to most people and is generally looked down upon. Instead, find a local VFW (Veterans of Foreign Wars) post, an American Legion hall, or even a Boy Scout troop. Most of these organizations have drop boxes where they will take your old flags and retire them in a formal, respectful ceremony. They usually do a mass burning where the flags are handled with care and silence.

If You Are Protesting:
If you plan on using a flag in a demonstration, know your local fire codes. You need to be in a space where open flames are allowed. If you're on public property, you likely need a permit for any kind of fire. Be aware that while the speech is protected, the fire is regulated.

If You See a Flag Being Burned:
It’s easy to want to intervene. But legally, if that person owns the flag they are burning, they have a right to do it. Engaging physically can lead to assault charges against you. The most effective "counter-protest" in the eyes of the law is more speech—holding your own flag higher or vocalizing your disagreement.

The Nuance of the Law

The reality of United States flag burning is that it sits at the very edge of what a democracy can tolerate. It’s the ultimate test of the First Amendment. It’s easy to protect speech we like. It’s incredibly hard to protect speech that makes us want to scream.

Whether you view it as a disgusting act of "un-Americanism" or the ultimate expression of the right to dissent, the legal standing is clear. As long as the Texas v. Johnson and United States v. Eichman rulings stand, the flag will continue to be a symbol that can be used—and destroyed—to make a point.

The beauty, or the frustration, of the American system is that the flag protects the very person who wants to burn it.

Next Steps for Research:

• Check Local Ordinances: Look up your specific city's fire codes regarding "open burning" to see how they handle protests involving fire.
• Read the Full Rulings: Search for the "Majority Opinion of Texas v. Johnson" to see the full logic used by the Supreme Court—it’s a fascinating read on the philosophy of liberty.
• Locate a Retirement Center: If you have an old flag, use the American Legion's website to find a "Flag Drop Box" near your zip code for proper retirement.