You’re standing in the bathroom, toothbrush in hand, staring at that familiar tube of Silly Strawberry or Simply White. You bought it because it’s "natural." You trust it for your kids. Then you see the headline: the FDA found bacteria and "black mold-like substances" in the factory. It’s enough to make anyone want to gargle with bleach.
But here’s the weird part. If you go to the store right now, the toothpaste is probably still on the shelf. There was a massive wave of panic about a tom's toothpaste recall, yet the actual story is way more complicated than a simple "product is bad, take it back" situation.
Honestly, the whole thing feels like a breakdown in communication between a massive corporation and a federal watchdog. Back in late 2024, the FDA dropped a warning letter that read like a horror script for anyone who cares about hygiene. They talked about Pseudomonas aeruginosa in the water. They mentioned Ralstonia insidiosa. They even brought up a weird little bug called Paracoccus yeei found in a batch of Wicked Cool! toothpaste.
So why isn't there a giant bin at the front of Target for returns? Because as of today, Tom’s of Maine hasn't actually issued a formal, nationwide recall for all their products. They’ve basically bet their reputation on the idea that while their water and facility had issues, the final toothpaste in your drawer is just fine.
The FDA Warning That Started the Tom's Toothpaste Recall Panic
Let’s look at what actually went down in Sanford, Maine. The FDA sent inspectors to the Tom’s plant in May 2024. What they found wasn't great.
According to the official warning letter dated November 5, 2024, the water system—which is the main ingredient in your toothpaste—was contaminated. We’re not talking about a little dust. We’re talking about "too numerous to count" levels of bacteria.
The most concerning find was Pseudomonas aeruginosa. This isn't a "stomach ache" kind of germ. It’s an opportunistic pathogen. If it gets into your blood or lungs, especially if you’re immunocompromised, it can be nasty. The FDA pointed out that this bacteria was found in the water used to make Simply White Clean Mint Paste and in the water used to rinse the equipment.
Then there was the mold. Or "black mold-like substance," to use the FDA's specific, cautious phrasing. It was found behind water storage tanks and at the base of hose reels. Specifically, it was within a foot of the pails used to handle the ingredients.
Why the company says you're fine
Tom’s of Maine (and their parent company, Colgate-Palmolive) didn't just sit there. They pushed back. Their stance is basically: "Yeah, the facility had some housekeeping issues, but we test every single batch before it leaves the building."
They claim that their finished goods testing didn't show the bacteria, even if the source water did. They’ve since hired water specialists and dumped a bunch of capital into upgrading the Sanford plant. But the FDA wasn't impressed with their initial response. The agency called the company's internal investigation "inadequate."
Basically, the FDA’s logic is: if your water is dirty and your walls have mold, how can you be sure the toothpaste is clean?
The 400 Ignored Complaints
This is the part that bugs me the most. During the inspection, the FDA found that Tom's hadn't investigated about 400 consumer complaints.
People were calling in saying their toothpaste smelled weird, looked off, or tasted wrong. Tom’s allegedly didn't look into them because they didn't think there was a "trend."
When you’re a "natural" brand, trust is everything. If 400 people tell you the Silly Strawberry tastes like a wet basement, you probably shouldn't just file those under "miscellaneous." This lack of investigation is a big reason why the tom's toothpaste recall conversation became so heated. It suggested a culture of "don't ask, don't tell" regarding quality control.
The specific products mentioned
While there isn't a blanket recall, the FDA specifically called out these three in their report:
- Simply White Clean Mint Paste: Linked to the contaminated water samples.
- Wicked Cool! Anticavity Toothpaste: A specific batch (3025UST11B) actually tested positive for Paracoccus yeei.
- Silly Strawberry Anticavity: Mentioned because of "powdery residue" found near the equipment used to make it.
If you have these in your bathroom, you're probably wondering if you should toss them. Most experts, like those interviewed by the New York Times and various health watchdogs, suggest playing it safe. If the FDA is worried enough to issue a formal Warning Letter—which is basically the last step before they shut a factory down—it might be worth the $6 to just buy a new tube of something else.
What You Should Actually Do Now
Look, you probably haven't died from brushing your teeth. But the "natural" label doesn't mean "immune to bacteria." In fact, because natural products often avoid harsh synthetic preservatives, they can actually be more susceptible to things like mold if the factory isn't spotless.
🔗 Read more: Woman's weight loss secrets: the unspoken truth about why your body fights back
Here is how you handle this without spiraling into a germaphobe meltdown:
Check your batch numbers. If you have the Wicked Cool! variety, look for batch 3025UST11B. If that’s what’s on your counter, stop using it.
Watch for changes. If your toothpaste suddenly changes color, gets a grainy texture, or starts smelling like a pond, throw it away. Don't wait for a formal tom's toothpaste recall notice to hit the evening news. Your nose is a better scientist than a corporate press release.
Consider the user. If you are healthy, the risk from these specific bacteria is relatively low. However, if you are buying this for a toddler who swallows half the tube, or if you have a weakened immune system, the risk profile changes. Be extra cautious with the kids' versions.
Keep an eye on the factory. The Sanford, Maine plant is still under the microscope. Tom's has 15 days from the letter to prove they fixed it, and the FDA will likely re-inspect.
Honestly, the biggest takeaway here isn't that Tom's is "evil." It's that even the "good" brands can get lazy with their plumbing. Until the FDA gives the Sanford plant a clean bill of health, you might want to switch to a different brand or at least a different Tom's product that is manufactured at a different site (though most of their core toothpaste lines come from that one Maine facility).
If you want to be proactive, you can actually report any weird toothpaste experiences directly to the FDA’s MedWatch program. Since Tom's apparently struggled to keep up with their own 400 complaints, the government is the better place to send your data.
To stay safe, keep your toothpaste in a cool, dry place. Humidity in the bathroom can actually make factory-born mold issues worse once the tube is open. Switch to a new tube if you've been sick, and maybe give the "natural" section a skeptical side-eye for a few months while Tom's finishes their "capital investments" in their water pipes.