Ever walked into an office and felt like you were just a line item on a spreadsheet? Most people have. It sucks. Managers often treat their teams like machines that just need more oil to run faster, but that’s exactly where they lose the game. Kevin Leman and William Pentak wrote The Way of the Shepherd back in 2004 to fix that. They didn't write a dry textbook on management theory or some data-heavy white paper. Instead, they told a story. It’s a fable about a young man and a mentor, and honestly, it’s probably one of the most practical leadership books you'll ever read because it gets back to the basics of human connection.
People are messy. They have bad days, they get distracted, and they need to feel like they actually matter to the person signing their checks. That’s the core of the book. It’s about the "Seven Secrets" of management, but really, it’s just about being a decent human being who knows how to guide others toward a goal without burning them out.
What Most People Get Wrong About The Way of the Shepherd
The biggest misconception? That it’s a "soft" book. People see the word "shepherd" and think it’s all about being nice and fluffy. It isn't. If you’ve ever seen a real shepherd work, you know it’s exhausting, gritty, and requires a lot of discipline. A shepherd doesn’t just sit in the grass playing a flute; they’re constantly scanning for predators, checking for diseases, and making sure the flock is moving in the right direction. In a business context, this means you can’t lead from a corner office while staring at a dashboard. You’ve got to get your boots dirty.
Leadership isn't a rank. It's a responsibility. Leman and Pentak argue that if you don't know your people—like, really know them—you aren't leading them. You're just supervising a process.
Knowing the Condition of Your Flock
The first principle in The Way of the Shepherd is about knowing the condition of your flock. This sounds simple. It’s not. In a modern corporate environment, "knowing the flock" means understanding more than just a person’s KPIs. It means knowing that Sarah’s mom is sick or that Dave is struggling with a specific type of software.
You have to follow the status of your people as well as the status of the work. If you only care about the output, the input (the people) will eventually fail. I’ve seen managers try to "optimize" teams by cutting out the small talk. Big mistake. That "small talk" is where the trust is built. Without it, you’re flying blind. You won't know a top performer is planning to quit until they’ve already signed an offer letter with your competitor.
✨ Don't miss: Pacific Plus International Inc: Why This Food Importer is a Secret Weapon for Restaurants
The Art of Selecting Your Sheep
The book makes a point that might ruffle some feathers: not everyone belongs in your flock. In the story, the mentor explains that you have to choose sheep that have the right "SHAPE." This is a clever little acronym for Strengths, Heart, Attitude, Personality, and Experiences.
- Strengths: Can they actually do the job?
- Heart: Do they care about the mission?
- Attitude: Are they going to poison the well?
- Personality: Do they fit the dynamic?
- Experiences: What have they learned elsewhere?
If you hire someone who has the skills but a terrible attitude, you're bringing a "wolf" into the fold. It doesn't matter how talented they are; they’ll tear the team apart. Good shepherding starts with good gatekeeping.
Why Your People Need a Sense of Belonging
We all want to belong to something. It’s primal. The Way of the Shepherd emphasizes that the leader’s job is to create an environment where people feel "in." This is where the concept of the "mark" comes in. In the old days, shepherds would mark their sheep so everyone knew who they belonged to. In business, that mark is your culture. It’s your identity.
When people feel like they belong, they work harder. They stay longer. They solve problems instead of ignoring them. If your team feels like a bunch of independent contractors who just happen to share a Slack channel, you don’t have a flock. You have a crowd. Crowds scatter the second things get difficult. Flocks huddle together.
The Staff and the Rod: Not Just for Show
A lot of managers struggle with the "Rod and Staff" concept from the book. They either want to be everyone's best friend (the Staff) or they want to be a tyrant (the Rod). You need both.
🔗 Read more: AOL CEO Tim Armstrong: What Most People Get Wrong About the Comeback King
The Staff is for guidance. It’s the gentle nudge. It’s the coaching session where you help an employee see a better way to handle a client. The Rod, however, is for protection and correction. Sometimes you have to use the rod to fend off "predators"—like toxic office politics or external threats to the team’s integrity. And sometimes, you use it to pull a "sheep" back from the edge of a cliff if they’re about to make a catastrophic mistake.
If you use the rod too much, your people will be terrified of you. If you never use it, they won't respect you. Finding that balance is basically the "final boss" of management.
Creating a Safe Environment
Sheep are nervous animals. So are employees who think they might get fired at any moment for making a mistake. The book talks about the "Heart of the Shepherd," which is essentially about building trust. If your team is constantly looking over their shoulders, they aren't looking ahead at the goals.
Safe doesn’t mean "easy." You can have a high-pressure, high-stakes environment that is still "safe." It’s safe because the expectations are clear, the leader has the team's back, and mistakes are treated as learning opportunities rather than crimes. Dr. Leman, a psychologist by trade, understands the human need for security. When people feel secure, their brains actually function better. They’re more creative. They take calculated risks.
Communication: The Shepherd's Voice
In the book, the sheep know the shepherd’s voice. They trust it. In your company, how do you communicate? Is it through cold, vague emails? Or is it a consistent, honest voice that people can rely on?
💡 You might also like: Wall Street Lays an Egg: The Truth About the Most Famous Headline in History
Trust isn't built in a single meeting. It’s built over a thousand small interactions. It’s about being "there" for the flock. The authors suggest that a leader must be visible. You can't lead from behind a closed door. You need to be "out in the pasture" with them. This doesn't mean micromanaging; it means being accessible. If your team feels like they have to schedule a meeting three weeks in advance just to ask you a question, you’ve lost the "voice" of the shepherd.
Is This Style of Leadership Still Relevant?
We’re living in a world of remote work, AI, and constant digital noise. Does a book about sheep and shepherds from 20 years ago still matter?
Absolutely. In fact, it might matter more now.
Technology has made us more efficient but more isolated. A manager who uses the principles in The Way of the Shepherd stands out because they treat people like humans in an increasingly automated world. Empathy is becoming a competitive advantage. If you treat your employees like a "flock" that you genuinely care about, they will run through brick walls for you. If you treat them like "resources," they’ll leave for an extra $5,000 a year somewhere else.
The principles are timeless because human nature doesn't change. We still want to be known, we still want to be led by someone we trust, and we still want to know that our work has meaning.
Actionable Steps for Modern Shepherding
Leadership isn't something you "achieve"; it's something you practice. If you want to implement these ideas without sounding like you're reading from a script, start small.
- Get Out of the Office (Virtually or Physically): Spend at least 20% of your day just "wandering." Check in with people. Don't ask about deadlines every time. Ask how they are. Listen to the subtext.
- Audit Your "Mark": Ask your team what they think the company culture is. If their answers are wildly different from yours, you have a branding problem within your own flock.
- Clarify the Boundaries: Use your "Rod" to set clear non-negotiables. People actually feel safer when they know where the boundaries are. Uncertainty is the enemy of productivity.
- Personalize Your Approach: Stop using one-size-fits-all management. Some "sheep" need more direction; others need more space. Learn the individual rhythms of your team members.
- Protect the Perimeter: Identify the "wolves" in your organization. This could be a toxic client, a redundant process that wastes time, or a "brilliant jerk" who is making everyone else miserable. Deal with them decisively.
The goal isn't to be a perfect leader. It’s to be a present one. Success in management isn't just about hitting your numbers; it's about making sure that when you get to the destination, your team is still with you, healthy, and ready for the next hill. That’s the real way of the shepherd.