Fear is a funny thing. It’s usually quiet. But for Jack and Janet Smurl, fear was a 10-year-long scream that wouldn't end. You've probably heard bits and pieces of the story if you're into the paranormal, maybe through a grainy 90s TV movie or a late-night Wiki-crawl. But the haunted one family's nightmare wasn't a Hollywood script. It was a localized, decade-long siege in a duplex in West Pittston, Pennsylvania, that eventually drew in the heavy hitters of the ghost-hunting world, Ed and Lorraine Warren.
It started small.
Most hauntings do. A stain on a carpet that keeps coming back. A light that flickers when the wiring is brand new. A TV that turns itself on to a static-filled channel at 3:00 AM. For the Smurls, who moved into the Chase Street home in 1974, these were just "old house" quirks. At first. But by 1985, the activity had escalated into something much more physical and, frankly, terrifying. We aren't just talking about bumps in the night; we're talking about a family being shoved, slapped, and even sexually assaulted by an unseen force.
The Escalation of the Smurl Family Nightmare
Janet Smurl was often the primary target. She reported being pulled off her bed while she slept. That’s not just a "ghost story." That’s a physical trauma that leaves marks. The family claimed they smelled sulfur—the classic "rotten egg" scent often associated with demonic infestations in demonological literature.
Think about the psychological toll.
Imagine living in a home where you can't even trust the air you breathe. The Smurls weren't looking for fame. In fact, Jack Smurl was a soft-spoken guy, a veteran. He just wanted his kids to be safe. But the activity didn't stay inside the walls. It followed them. When they tried to pray, the noises got louder. When they brought in priests, the "entity" seemed to mock the rituals. This is a hallmark of what researchers call "infestation," the first stage of a demonic presence before it moves to oppression and, eventually, possession.
Enter the Warrens
By 1986, the Smurls were desperate. They reached out to Ed and Lorraine Warren. Now, the Warrens are polarizing figures. Some people think they were pioneers; others think they were opportunistic. Regardless of where you stand, their involvement turned this local disturbance into a national media circus. Lorraine, a medium, claimed she felt a "dark, ancient" presence in the home.
🔗 Read more: Burnsville Minnesota United States: Why This South Metro Hub Isn't Just Another Suburb
Ed Warren was blunter. He told the press that the house was occupied by a powerful demon.
The media went nuts.
Suddenly, the quiet street in West Pittston was lined with news vans. People were picnicking on the sidewalk, hoping to see a ghost. This added a whole new layer to the haunted one family's nightmare. They weren't just being tormented by a demon; they were being gawked at by the world. It’s hard to say which was worse for their mental health.
Why the Smurl Case Still Divides Experts
A lot of people ask: why didn't they just move?
It’s the most common question in any haunting case. But the Smurls didn't have a ton of money. They shared the duplex with Jack’s parents. Moving two households isn't easy, especially when you're convinced that the thing haunting you will just pack its bags and follow you to the next zip code anyway. And according to the Smurls, it did. Even when they went on vacation or stayed with friends, the "shadow man" was there.
Critics, like the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP), had a field day with this. Paul Kurtz and other skeptics argued that the Smurls were suffering from mass hysteria or perhaps "hallucinations induced by brain chemistry." They pointed out that there was never any hard, scientific evidence—no clear photos of the demon, no recordings that couldn't be explained away as house noises.
💡 You might also like: Bridal Hairstyles Long Hair: What Most People Get Wrong About Your Wedding Day Look
But the Smurls had witnesses.
Dozens of them. Neighbors claimed to hear the screams. Friends reported seeing furniture move. A reporter from the Lakeland Ledger even wrote about experiencing an "unnatural chill" in the house that seemed to defy the thermostat. It’s easy to dismiss one family, but when the whole block is looking at your house with wide eyes, things get complicated.
The Physicality of the Attacks
We have to talk about the darker side of this. Jack Smurl reported being sexually assaulted by a succubus-like entity. This is one of the most controversial aspects of the case. In the realm of demonology, these are called "visitations," but to a modern psychologist, these reports often sound like sleep paralysis.
During sleep paralysis, the brain is awake but the body is paralyzed. It's common to see a "shadow person" sitting on your chest. You feel a sense of dread. You might even feel a physical touch. Was Jack Smurl experiencing a rare, recurring form of sleep paralysis triggered by the stress of his environment? Or was something truly malevolent reaching out from the shadows? Honestly, the truth probably lies somewhere in the messy middle.
The Media Circus and the Aftermath
The nightmare peaked with a televised exorcism. It didn't work. Or at least, it didn't work immediately. The family eventually moved in 1987, and the new owners of the Chase Street house claimed... nothing. Absolutely nothing.
This is the "smoking gun" for skeptics. If the house was truly haunted, why did the ghosts stop as soon as the Smurls left?
📖 Related: Boynton Beach Boat Parade: What You Actually Need to Know Before You Go
Paranormal investigators argue that the entity wasn't tied to the location, but to the people. This is the difference between a haunting and a poltergeist or demonic attachment. If the energy is feeding off the family's stress, faith, or specific dynamics, it leaves when they do. The Smurls claimed they were still bothered by the entity for years after moving, though the intensity eventually faded into a dull roar.
What We Can Learn from West Pittston
The Smurl case is a masterclass in how a private tragedy becomes a public spectacle. It highlights the tension between faith and science. For the Smurls, their Catholic faith was their only weapon, yet it also seemed to provoke the entity. For the skeptics, the lack of "ghost in a jar" proof meant it was all a hoax or a mental breakdown.
But look at the cost.
The family was left broken. Their privacy was gone. Their reputations were debated in every newspaper in the country. Whether you believe in demons or not, the haunted one family's nightmare was a very real psychological trauma.
Actionable Insights for the Paranormal Enthusiast
If you find yourself fascinated by cases like the Smurls, or if you're experiencing something you can't explain in your own home, there are practical ways to handle it without jumping straight to "demon."
- Rule out the mundane first. High EMF (Electromagnetic Field) levels from old wiring can cause feelings of being watched, nausea, and even hallucinations. Get an EMF meter or have an electrician check your breakers.
- Check for Carbon Monoxide. This is a big one. CO poisoning causes paranoia, auditory hallucinations, and a sense of impending doom. It is literally the "haunting" gas.
- Document everything. Keep a log. Is it happening at the same time? To the same person? Patterns help distinguish between environmental issues and something else.
- Prioritize mental health. Hauntings—real or perceived—are incredibly stressful. Stress causes the brain to misinterpret sensory data. Speaking to a counselor isn't "admitting you're crazy"; it's a tool to keep your head clear while you investigate.
- Research the history. Sometimes knowing the "why" helps demystify the "what." If the house has a history of high turnover, there might be a physical reason (like mold or structural noise) that drives people out.
The Smurl family nightmare remains one of the most documented and debated cases in American history. It sits right next to the Amityville Horror in terms of cultural impact. While we may never have a video of the "shadow man" that satisfies every scientist, the emotional wreckage left behind is proof enough that something happened on Chase Street.
Stay curious, but keep your feet on the ground. The basement might be dark, but usually, it's just a blown fuse. Usually.