It was late 2017. If you were a fan of AMC’s zombie juggernaut back then, you probably remember exactly where you were when the credits rolled on the mid-season finale. Honestly, the shock wasn't just about the plot. It was the realization that the show was fundamentally breaking its own rules. The Walking Dead Season 8 Episode 8, titled "How It's Done," wasn't just another hour of television; it was the moment the series took a sledgehammer to its own foundation.
Carl Grimes was the future. Period.
That was the unspoken contract between the writers and the audience for nearly a decade. Seeing that bite mark on his midsection felt like a betrayal to many, and even years later, the ripples of that decision are still felt in the fandom. People still argue about whether it was a bold creative choice or the beginning of the end for the show’s peak popularity.
What Actually Happened in The Walking Dead Season 8 Episode 8?
The episode kicks off with a massive shift in momentum. Rick and his allies thought they had the Saviors pinned at the Sanctuary. They were wrong. Negan’s group escaped, and they didn't just come back—they came back with a vengeance. The episode is structured like a series of hammer blows hitting Alexandria, the Hilltop, and the Kingdom simultaneously.
📖 Related: Why Spring Is Here Lyrics Still Break Your Heart (And Why That Matters)
Negan shows up at the gates of Alexandria. He’s whistling. He’s smug. He’s doing that leaning thing Jeffrey Dean Morgan became famous for. While Rick is away, Carl steps up. This is probably Chandler Riggs’ best performance in the entire series. He offers his own life to Negan to spare the others. It feels like a moment of ultimate growth, a young man becoming a leader.
But then the grenades start flying.
Alexandria is literally set on fire. The visual of the houses burning—the same houses we watched them build and defend—was gut-wrenching. Meanwhile, Simon stops Maggie’s convoy on the road and executes Neil in the back of the car. It’s cold. It’s calculated. Over at the Kingdom, Gavin and the Saviors take over, and Ezekiel manages a heroic distraction to let his people escape, resulting in his own capture.
The chaos is relentless. You barely have time to breathe before the scene shifts again.
The Twist That Broke the Internet
The ending is what everyone remembers. Rick finally makes it back to a burning Alexandria. He fights Negan in a brutal, messy brawl inside a house before escaping into the sewers. When he finds Michonne and the rest of the survivors hiding in the tunnels, he sees Carl.
Carl is pale. He’s sweating. And then he reveals the bite on his torso.
✨ Don't miss: Rosalie and Isles Cast: What Most People Get Wrong
It didn't happen during the battle. It happened episodes earlier while he was helping Siddiq. That’s the kicker. The most important character for the show's long-term future was killed by a random walker while doing a side quest. It wasn't a heroic death in battle against Negan; it was a quiet, tragic accident.
The Controversy: Why Fans Are Still Mad
If you talk to any "die-hard" fan, they'll likely point to The Walking Dead Season 8 Episode 8 as the moment they almost checked out. In the comics by Robert Kirkman, Carl doesn't die. He survives until the very end. He grows up, has a family, and becomes the person who carries on Rick’s legacy.
By killing Carl, the showrunners (led by Scott Gimple at the time) effectively threw the source material out the window. This wasn't just a deviation; it was a total rewrite of the story’s DNA.
- The Loss of Hope: Carl represented the "why" of the show. Rick was doing everything for his son. Without Carl, Rick’s motivation became a lot muddier.
- The Actor’s Departure: It came out later that Chandler Riggs reportedly didn't want to leave. He had just bought a house near the filming location. This added a layer of real-world bitterness to the fan reaction.
- Pacing Issues: Some critics argued that the "All Out War" arc was dragging, and Carl’s death was used as a "shock factor" tool to boost ratings.
Honestly, it’s hard to look back at this episode without feeling the weight of what could have been. If Carl had lived, the later seasons involving the Whisperers and the Commonwealth would have had a completely different emotional anchor.
The Technical Side of "How It's Done"
Directed by Michael E. Satrazemis, the episode is a masterclass in tension, even if the writing was divisive. The lighting is oppressive. Everything is bathed in the orange glow of fire or the pitch black of the sewers.
The pacing is frantic. Unlike some episodes of Season 8 that felt like they were spinning their wheels, episode 8 moves at breakneck speed. The jump-cuts between the three different communities create a sense of a world falling apart all at once.
One thing people often overlook is the music. Bear McCreary’s score in this episode is haunting. It moves away from the typical "action" synth and into something much more somber and inevitable as we approach the final reveal.
Impact on the Rest of the Series
You can't talk about The Walking Dead Season 8 Episode 8 without looking at the fallout. This episode necessitated the "mercy over wrath" ending of the war. Rick’s decision to save Negan in the season finale was directly tied to Carl’s dying wish.
Without Carl’s death, Rick probably would have just slit Negan’s throat and been done with it. Carl became the moral compass from beyond the grave. It forced a level of character development for Rick that was arguably necessary, but it came at a massive cost.
It also paved the way for Judith Grimes to take over Carl’s comic book arcs. While Cailey Fleming did an incredible job as older Judith, there’s always that lingering feeling that we missed out on seeing Carl and Rick lead together.
👉 See also: David Bailey: Why the World’s Most Famous Photographer Still Matters
Why It Still Matters in 2026
Even now, as the TWD Universe has expanded into spin-offs like The Ones Who Live and Daryl Dixon, this episode remains a touchstone. It’s the definitive "Before and After" marker for the franchise.
When Rick and Michonne finally reunited in recent years, the shadow of Carl was everywhere. The show is still trying to answer the questions posed in Season 8: Can you really build a world after so much loss? Is peace actually possible, or is it just a dream Carl had before he died?
Summary of Key Moments
- Negan’s Return: The Saviors escape the Sanctuary and launch a three-pronged attack.
- The Burning of Alexandria: The community is effectively destroyed by fire and grenades.
- Ezekiel’s Sacrifice: He saves his people but is captured by Gavin.
- The Reveal: Carl reveals a walker bite on his side, marking his death sentence.
- The Shift: The war changes from a quest for revenge to a struggle for a peaceful future.
How to Revisit This Era of TWD
If you’re planning a rewatch or diving into this for the first time, don't just watch the episode in a vacuum. To really get the "full experience" of the impact, you need to pay attention to the episodes leading up to it.
- Watch Episode 6 ("The King, the Widow, and Rick"): This is where Carl actually gets bitten. It’s subtle. You might miss it if you aren't looking for it.
- Focus on the Letters: In the second half of Season 8, pay close attention to the letters Carl wrote. They provide the context for why the show had to change its tone.
- Check out the "Behind the Scenes": Look for interviews with Chandler Riggs and Andrew Lincoln from late 2017. Their genuine emotional reactions to the script tell a story on their own.
Whether you love it or hate it, "How It's Done" is an essential piece of television history. It proved that in the world of the walking dead, no one—not even the "untouchable" characters—is truly safe. It was a brutal reminder that the world doesn't care about your plans for the future.