The History of Running Shoes and Why Your Feet Probably Hurt

The History of Running Shoes and Why Your Feet Probably Hurt

You’re probably wearing them right now. Or they’re sitting by your front door, a mess of synthetic mesh, nitrogen-infused foam, and carbon fiber plates that cost more than a week's worth of groceries. We take the modern sneaker for granted, but the history of running shoes isn't some straight line of "better and better" tech. Honestly, it’s a chaotic story of kitchen appliances, accidental discoveries, and a few decades where we basically ignored how the human foot actually works.

Running is the most natural thing we do. Yet, for thousands of years, we did it in nothing. Or at best, a thin slice of leather strapped to our soles with some twine. It’s wild to think that the cushioned, high-stack "super shoes" we see at the Boston Marathon today are a total departure from how humans moved for about 99% of our existence.

When Plimsolls Were the Gold Standard

Before the late 1800s, there wasn't really a "running shoe." If you were fast, you were probably running in dress shoes or leather boots. Imagine trying to clock a sub-five-minute mile in oxfords. It sounds like a recipe for a stress fracture, but that was the reality.

Then came the "Plimsoll."

These were basically the Great-Great-Grandfather of the Converse All-Star. They featured a canvas upper and a crude rubber sole. The term "sneaker" actually comes from this era because the rubber soles were so quiet that you could "sneak up" on people. British brands like J.W. Foster and Sons—which you now know as Reebok—started adding metal spikes to these rubber soles in the 1890s. They were heavy. They smelled. They offered zero arch support. But for the first time, runners had traction.

The Waffle Iron That Changed Everything

If you want to understand the history of running shoes, you have to talk about Bill Bowerman. He wasn't just a coach at the University of Oregon; he was a tinkerer who was obsessed with weight. He believed that if you could strip an ounce off a shoe, you’d save a runner from lifting hundreds of pounds over the course of a marathon.

One morning in 1971, Bowerman was looking at his wife’s waffle iron.

He wondered if the pattern could provide grip without the weight of metal spikes. He literally poured liquid urethane into the iron. He ruined the waffle iron, obviously, but he created the "Waffle Sole." This was the birth of the Nike Cortez and, eventually, the Nike Waffle Racer. It shifted the industry away from heavy, hard rubbers toward lightweight, grippy materials.

It also started the "cushioning arms race."

✨ Don't miss: Nebraska Cornhuskers Women's Basketball: What Really Happened This Season

The Great 1970s Boom and the Rise of "Science"

The 1970s were weird for running. Suddenly, everyone was doing it. It wasn't just for Olympic athletes anymore; it was for suburban dads in short-shorts. This created a massive market. Brands like Asics (then Onitsuka Tiger), New Balance, and Brooks scrambled to figure out how to stop these new "joggers" from getting injured.

Enter the EVA foam.

Ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) is basically that squishy, air-filled plastic you find in almost every midsole today. Brooks was the first to use it in 1975 with the Villanova model. Before EVA, midsoles were made of heavy crepe rubber or firm foam that packed down after twenty miles. EVA changed the game. It was light. It felt like walking on clouds.

But it also introduced a problem: overpronation.

Because the shoes were so soft, people’s feet started rolling inward. To "fix" this, the industry invented "Stability" and "Motion Control" shoes. They added hard plastic medial posts to stop the foot from moving. For thirty years, this was the gospel. If you had flat feet, you bought a brick-heavy stability shoe. If you had high arches, you bought "Neutral" shoes.

The thing is, modern studies—like those conducted by sports scientist Benno Nigg—suggest this whole categorization might have been total guesswork. There isn't much evidence that matching a shoe to your arch height actually prevents injury. We just thought it did because it sounded scientific.

The Minimalist Rebellion

By 2009, the history of running shoes took a sharp U-turn.

Christopher McDougall published Born to Run. He told the story of the Tarahumara Indians in Mexico who ran hundreds of miles in thin sandals called huaraches. He argued that modern, cushioned shoes were actually making our feet weak and causing the very injuries they claimed to prevent.

🔗 Read more: Nebraska Basketball Women's Schedule: What Actually Matters This Season

Suddenly, everyone wanted to run "barefoot."

Vibram FiveFingers—those weird toe-shoes that look like gorilla feet—became a billion-dollar sensation. Every major brand panicked. They started stripping away the foam. Nike came out with the "Free" line. New Balance made the "Minimus." The industry decided that the less shoe you had, the better runner you were.

It was a disaster for a lot of people.

People who had spent 20 years in 12mm-drop cushioned shoes suddenly tried to run 10 miles in thin slippers. Achilles tendons snapped. Metatarsals cracked. The "barefoot" craze died almost as fast as it started, but it left behind one important lesson: foot strength matters. You can't just slap a piece of foam on a problem and expect it to go away.

The Era of the Super Shoe

We are currently living in the "Maximalist" era. It started with a brand called Hoka One One (pronounced O-nay O-nay). They looked ridiculous. They had midsoles that looked like moon boots. People laughed at them until they realized that the extra foam actually saved their legs from the pounding of the pavement.

Then came 2017 and Nike’s "Breaking2" project.

Eliud Kipchoge tried to run a marathon in under two hours wearing a prototype called the Vaporfly 4%. It featured a new kind of foam called PEBA (polyether block amide) and a curved carbon fiber plate. PEBA is incredible. Unlike old EVA, which just absorbs energy, PEBA returns about 85-90% of it. It’s like having a literal spring under your foot.

Now, every brand has a "Super Shoe."

💡 You might also like: Missouri vs Alabama Football: What Really Happened at Faurot Field

  • Adidas has the Adizero Adios Pro.
  • Saucony has the Endorphin Elite.
  • Asics has the Metaspeed.

These shoes are so effective that World Athletics had to create new rules to limit the stack height to 40mm. Anything more is considered "mechanical doping." We’ve reached a point where the shoe is doing a significant portion of the work, reducing the metabolic cost of running by up to 4%. That’s the difference between a podium finish and being an also-ran.

Is the Future Sustainable or Just Plastic?

One thing the history of running shoes usually ignores is the waste. Most sneakers are a nightmare of glued-together plastics that take 1,000 years to decompose. We're finally seeing a shift. Brands like Allbirds or the On "Cyclon" subscription service are trying to make shoes that are either biodegradable or fully recyclable.

The "Cyclon" model is actually pretty smart. You don't own the shoe. You wear it out, send it back, they grind it up into pellets, and they make a new pair of shoes out of the old ones. It’s a closed loop. Given how much gear the average runner goes through—usually a new pair every 300 to 500 miles—this kind of tech is probably more important than the next carbon plate.

What This Means for Your Next Run

If you’re looking at this timeline and wondering what you should actually buy, here’s the reality. The "best" shoe in history doesn't exist. There is only the best shoe for your biomechanics right now.

Forget the marketing hype about "energy return" for a second. Most of us aren't sprinting for Olympic gold. We're trying to clear our heads on a Tuesday morning. The most important metric, according to the "Comfort Filter" theory proposed by Dr. Nigg, is simply how the shoe feels when you put it on. Your body is actually pretty good at telling you if a shoe is working with your natural gait or fighting against it.

Actionable Steps for Your Next Pair

Stop buying shoes based on color or what your fastest friend wears. Try these instead:

  1. Shop late in the afternoon. Your feet swell throughout the day. A shoe that fits at 9:00 AM will be a torture device by mile five of a sunny afternoon run.
  2. Ignore the "Size" on the box. I wear a 10 in some brands and an 11.5 in others. There is no standard. Focus on having a thumb’s width of space between your toes and the end of the shoe.
  3. Rotate your shoes. This is the big one. Research shows that runners who rotate between two or more different models have a lower risk of injury. It forces your muscles and tendons to adapt to slightly different stresses rather than doing the exact same repetitive motion every single day.
  4. Look at the wear pattern. Take your old shoes to a dedicated running store. A good staff member can look at where the rubber is worn down and tell you if you're landing on your heel, midfoot, or if you're "toeing off" aggressively. This is way more valuable than a generic "arch test."

The history of running shoes is really just a history of us trying to find a shortcut to the perfect stride. We've tried spikes, waffles, air bubbles, gel, and carbon fiber. But at the end of the day, the shoe is just a tool. The real work is still done by you.