February 4, 2018. Minneapolis is freezing, but the atmosphere inside U.S. Bank Stadium is electric. The New England Patriots are about to face the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LII. Fans are waiting for the defense to take the field. They expect to see #21.
He isn't there.
Malcolm Butler, the guy who saved Super Bowl XLIX with the most famous interception in NFL history, is standing on the sideline. He’s in uniform. He’s wearing his helmet. He’s even crying during the national anthem. But as the game starts, he stays glued to the bench.
Nick Foles starts shredding the Patriots' secondary. Eric Rowe is getting beat. Jordan Richards is struggling. Everyone is asking the same question: why was Malcolm Butler benched?
It’s been years, and the mystery still haunts New England. Bill Belichick, the master of "doing what's best for the team," made a call that many believe cost him a ring. But the reasons aren't just one thing. It was a mess of illness, bad timing, and a clash of egos.
The Perfect Storm: Sickness and Bad Practice
Honestly, the most grounded explanation involves a "perfect storm" of issues. It wasn't just a single event.
Butler arrived in Minneapolis a day later than the rest of the team. Why? He was legitimately sick. He had been hospitalized with severe flu-like symptoms. While his teammates were doing media availability and getting acclimated, Butler was recovering.
By the time he hit the practice field on Wednesday, he was behind.
🔗 Read more: Hulk Hogan Lifting Andre the Giant: What Really Happened at WrestleMania III
In the world of Belichick, if you don't practice well, you don't play. Sources like Albert Breer have noted that Butler’s performance in those few practice sessions was, frankly, awful. He wasn't sharp. He was "in the tank" mentally because he realized his role was being reduced.
The Matt Patricia Altercation
Then things got personal. According to Seth Wickersham’s book It's Better to Be Feared, Butler had a massive, heated exchange with then-defensive coordinator Matt Patricia during a practice. Patricia reportedly wasn't happy with Butler’s effort or his focus.
Butler didn't take the criticism quietly.
They went at it. Loudly. In front of the team. For a coach like Belichick, that kind of public defiance is a one-way ticket to the bench, regardless of how many Pro Bowls you've made.
Was it a Curfew Violation or a Concert?
If you ask the rumors on the street, it gets juicier. One persistent report—backed by NFL Network's Ian Rapoport shortly after the game—suggested a "minor team violation."
The word? Curfew.
The story goes that Butler attended a Rick Ross concert during Super Bowl week and didn't make it back to the hotel on time. While Belichick denied that the benching was disciplinary, saying it was a "football decision," the timing of the "minor violation" makes it hard to believe it didn't play a role.
💡 You might also like: Formula One Points Table Explained: Why the Math Matters More Than the Racing
- The Sickness: Hospitalized with the flu.
- The Late Arrival: Missed the first day of team activities.
- The Practice: Reportedly struggled to cover even scout team players.
- The Attitude: The blow-up with Matt Patricia.
When you add those up, you get a coach who decides he'd rather lose with a "prepared" backup than win with a "distracted" star.
Why the Decision Still Makes No Sense
Here is where it gets weird. Even if Butler had a bad week, the game was a defensive disaster. Nick Foles threw for 373 yards and 3 touchdowns. The Patriots couldn't stop a third-down conversion if their lives depended on it.
Yet, Butler stayed on the bench. He played exactly one snap on special teams.
Even Robert Kraft, the team owner, reportedly didn't know why Butler wasn't playing. In the Apple TV+ docuseries The Dynasty, Kraft revealed that he was told it was a "personal issue" between Belichick and Butler. That phrasing suggests it wasn't just about X’s and O’s.
It was a power move.
Belichick has a history of this. He benched Wes Welker for the start of a playoff game for making foot jokes about Rex Ryan. He sent Jonas Gray to the shadow realm after a 200-yard game because he was late to practice. But doing it in the Super Bowl? That was different.
The Teammate Reaction
The locker room was divided. Players like Eric Rowe were thrown into the fire without much warning. Years later, many of those players still won't talk about what happened in the locker room that night.
📖 Related: El Paso Locomotive FC Standings: Why the 2025 Surge Changes Everything for 2026
They saw their brother crying on the sideline. They saw the defense getting carved up. They knew Butler could help, and they knew the coach wouldn't let him.
What Most People Get Wrong
People think there's a "smoking gun." A secret scandal involving Steve Belichick’s wife or some massive drug bust.
Stop. There is no evidence for those wilder conspiracy theories.
The truth is likely much more boring but equally frustrating: Ego and Process. Belichick has a process. If you miss time (sickness), fail to perform in the limited time you have (practice), and then talk back to the staff (Patricia), the process says you sit. Belichick is the guy who would rather be wrong his way than right someone else’s way. He gambled that his system was better than one talented individual.
He lost the gamble.
Actionable Takeaways from the Butler Saga
If you’re a coach, a manager, or just a fan trying to make sense of this, there are real lessons here about leadership and communication.
- Flexibility over Rigidity: In high-stakes moments (like a Super Bowl or a major business launch), rigid adherence to "the process" can be fatal. If the plan isn't working, you have to be willing to break your own rules to win.
- Communication is King: The fact that the owner and the players were in the dark created a rift that arguably helped end the "Dynasty" era earlier than it should have.
- Manage the Ego: Butler's frustration was human. Belichick's response was cold. Somewhere in the middle, a conversation could have saved a championship.
Malcolm Butler eventually returned to the Patriots for a brief stint in 2022, proving that the bridge wasn't completely burned. But the "why" of 2018 remains a scar on the legacy of the greatest coach in NFL history. It’s a reminder that even the smartest guys in the room can be blinded by their own discipline.
Keep an eye on future memoirs from that 2017-2018 squad. As more players retire, the full, unvarnished locker room accounts usually start to leak. Until then, we’re left with the "perfect storm"—a mix of the flu, a concert, a shouting match, and a coach who wouldn't budge.