If you want to know if a company is actually good at making money—not just busy, but efficient—you look at Return on Equity. It's the "efficiency" metric. Honestly, most people just glance at net income and call it a day, but that’s a rookie mistake. You can have a billion dollars in profit, but if it took a trillion dollars of shareholder cash to get there, you're basically failing.
The formula to calculate return on equity is your literal BS detector. It tells you how much bang you’re getting for your buck. If you’re an investor, this is the number that separates the Compounders from the Value Traps.
The Raw Math: Breaking Down the Formula to Calculate Return on Equity
Let’s keep it simple. The standard formula to calculate return on equity is:
$$ROE = \frac{\text{Net Income}}{\text{Shareholders' Equity}}$$
Net income is what’s left after the government, the employees, and the landlords take their cut. You find this at the very bottom of the Income Statement. Shareholders' equity? That’s on the Balance Sheet. It's the assets minus the liabilities. Think of it as the "book value" of the company.
It sounds easy. Too easy.
The problem is that "Net Income" can be a bit of a lie. Companies love to use "one-time charges" or "restructuring costs" to make their earnings look better or worse depending on the season. If a company sold off a massive warehouse this year, their Net Income might skyrocket, making their ROE look world-class. But is it sustainable? No. It’s a one-off. You’ve got to strip that stuff out if you want the truth.
✨ Don't miss: Pacific Plus International Inc: Why This Food Importer is a Secret Weapon for Restaurants
I usually look for a "Normalized ROE." This means you use steady-state earnings. If the company is growing, use the average equity over the year rather than just the number at the end of December. Why? Because the company didn't have that end-of-year equity to work with in January. Averaging it out gives you a much more honest picture of performance.
Why 15% is the Magic Number (Usually)
Most veteran investors, like Warren Buffett or the folks over at Charlie Munger’s old haunts, look for a consistent ROE of 15% or higher. Anything below 10% is kinda meh. It means the company is barely outperforming a basic index fund or a high-yield bond. If a business can’t generate at least 10% on your money, why are they even in business? They should just close up shop and put the cash in a savings account.
But don't get obsessed with high numbers.
A 40% ROE looks incredible on a screen, but it’s often a red flag. Seriously. How? Debt.
If a company borrows a massive amount of money to buy back its own stock, the "Equity" part of our formula shrinks. When the denominator gets tiny, the ROE explodes. This isn't because the company got better at selling widgets; it's because they took on massive financial risk. If the economy hits a speed bump, that high-ROE company might go bankrupt because they’re suffocating under interest payments.
The DuPont Analysis: Peeling the Onion
If you really want to understand the formula to calculate return on equity, you have to talk about the DuPont Model. It breaks ROE into three distinct levers. This is where the pros live.
🔗 Read more: AOL CEO Tim Armstrong: What Most People Get Wrong About the Comeback King
- Profit Margin: How much profit do they keep from every dollar of sales? (Efficiency)
- Asset Turnover: How fast are they moving product? (Speed)
- Financial Leverage: How much borrowed money are they using? (Risk)
Think about a grocery store like Kroger. Their profit margins are razor-thin, maybe 1% or 2%. Tiny. But they turn their inventory over every few days. People have to eat. That high speed (Asset Turnover) makes their ROE decent despite the low margins.
Now compare that to a luxury brand like Ferrari or Hermès. They don’t sell many units, but the margin on a single handbag or car is astronomical. They don't need speed because they have "markup." Both can have the same ROE, but they get there in totally different ways. Knowing how a company gets its ROE tells you if the business model is actually durable.
The Share Buyback Trap
We have to talk about share buybacks because they’ve completely warped the formula to calculate return on equity in the last decade. Look at a company like Apple or Domino's Pizza. For a while, Domino's actually had negative equity because they returned so much cash to shareholders.
When equity is negative, the ROE calculation becomes meaningless. You can't divide by a negative number and get a "return." In these cases, ROE is a broken metric. You have to switch to Return on Invested Capital (ROIC). ROIC counts debt as part of the capital base, so companies can't "cheat" the math by just borrowing money to buy back shares.
Sector Matters: Don't Compare Apples to Oranges
Comparing the ROE of a software company to a utility company is a waste of time. Software companies (like Microsoft or Adobe) have almost no physical assets. No factories. No massive fleets of trucks. Their "Equity" is small, so their ROE is naturally huge.
Utilities? They have to build power plants and lay thousands of miles of cable. Their equity base is massive. A "good" ROE for a utility might be 11%, while a "good" ROE for a software firm might be 30%.
💡 You might also like: Wall Street Lays an Egg: The Truth About the Most Famous Headline in History
If you see a tech company with a 10% ROE, they are likely failing. If you see a utility with a 30% ROE, they are probably about to be investigated by a regulatory commission for overcharging customers. Context is everything.
Practical Steps for Your Portfolio
Stop looking at ROE as a static number. It’s a trend.
If you see a company whose ROE has climbed from 12% to 18% over five years, that’s a signal. It means they are gaining pricing power or becoming more efficient. If it’s dropping, the "moat" around the business is likely being filled in by competitors.
Here is what you should do next:
- Check the 5-year average: Go to a site like Morningstar or Yahoo Finance. Don't look at this year's ROE. Look at the average over the last five years to filter out the noise.
- Compare against the "Cost of Equity": This is a bit nerdy, but if a company's ROE is lower than its cost of capital (usually around 8-9% for big firms), they are actually destroying value. Every dollar they reinvest is worth less than a dollar.
- Watch the Debt-to-Equity ratio: If ROE is rising but Debt-to-Equity is also skyrocketing, run away. That’s "fake" growth fueled by the credit card, not the business's core strength.
- Verify with FCF: Check if Free Cash Flow supports the Net Income. If ROE is high but the company has no cash in the bank, the accounting department is likely getting creative with the books.
ROE is a starting point, not a finish line. Use it to find companies that are efficient, but always dig into the DuPont breakdown to make sure that efficiency isn't just a mountain of debt in disguise.