Everyone is staring at the same chart right now. You open your brokerage app, look at the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, and see a number that looks like a typo from a bull market fever dream. The SPY 1 year return has been hovering in that stratosphere of 25% to 30%, depending on the exact day you check the closing bell. It’s wild. If you put money in a year ago, you’re feeling like a genius. But here’s the thing—most people are looking at that percentage all wrong.
Markets don't just go up in a straight line because "the economy is good." Honestly, the economy has been a confusing mess of mixed signals for twelve months. We had recession fears that went nowhere, interest rate hikes that everyone thought would break the system, and a sudden explosion in artificial intelligence that basically carried the entire S&P 500 on its back. When you look at the SPY 1 year return, you aren't just looking at the "stock market." You're looking at a very specific, very heavy concentration of tech giants that decided to defy gravity.
What Actually Drove the SPY 1 Year Return This Time?
If you strip away the flashy headlines, the performance of the SPY over the last twelve months comes down to a handful of names. We call them the Magnificent Seven. You know them: Nvidia, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Meta, Alphabet, and Tesla. For a huge chunk of the year, if you took those seven stocks out of the S&P 500, the "return" for the other 493 companies was... well, it was okay. Not great. Just okay.
Nvidia alone has been a freight train. Because the S&P 500 is market-cap weighted, the bigger a company gets, the more it moves the needle for the entire index. When Nvidia jumps 10% in a week, the SPY 1 year return gets a massive shot of adrenaline, even if your local utility company or a mid-sized bank saw its stock price drop. It’s a top-heavy victory. This creates a bit of an illusion for the average investor who thinks "the whole market is booming." In reality, a few star players are doing the heavy lifting while the bench sits and watches.
💡 You might also like: Finding a Loading Dock in Stamford CT: What Most People Get Wrong
Inflation, Rates, and the "Pivot" Narrative
We can't talk about the last year without mentioning the Federal Reserve. Jerome Powell has been the most important person in your portfolio. For a while, the market was terrified. Every time a CPI (Consumer Price Index) report came out, everyone held their breath. If inflation was high, stocks tanked. If it cooled off, stocks rallied.
The reason the SPY 1 year return looks so good today is largely because the market started "pricing in" rate cuts. Investors stopped worrying about how high rates would go and started betting on when they would fall. It’s about anticipation. Stocks are a forward-looking mechanism. They don't care about what happened yesterday; they care about what they think will happen six months from now. That’s why we saw a massive rally even while the Fed was still technically holding rates at 20-year highs.
The Difference Between Total Return and Price Return
This is a nerdy point, but it matters for your wallet. When you see the SPY 1 year return quoted on news sites, they might just be showing you the price change. But SPY pays dividends. Usually around 1.3% or so.
- Price Return: Just the change in the share price.
- Total Return: The share price change PLUS the dividends reinvested.
If you aren't reinvesting those dividends, you’re leaving money on the table. Over a single year, 1.3% doesn't sound like a "get rich quick" scheme. But when the market is up 25%, that extra sliver makes the difference between a good year and a legendary one. Most professional analysts at firms like Goldman Sachs or BlackRock focus strictly on total return because that’s the real math of wealth building.
Measuring Against the "Average" Year
The historical average return for the S&P 500 is usually cited around 10% per year.
So, when you see a SPY 1 year return hitting 28%, you have to realize we are living through an outlier. This isn't normal. It's awesome, sure, but it isn't the baseline.
Regression to the mean is a real thing. It’s a concept that basically says things tend to move back toward the average over time. If we have a year that is nearly triple the historical average, it's statistically likely that the following years might be leaner. Or, we could just be in a new paradigm driven by productivity gains from AI. Nobody actually knows. Anyone who tells you they know exactly what the SPY will do in the next 12 months is probably trying to sell you a newsletter.
Why 2024-2025 Was a Weird Time for Indexing
Passive investing—just buying SPY and chilling—has been the "correct" move for a decade. But this past year tested people's nerves. Early on, the "equal-weighted" S&P 500 (ticker: RSP) was severely underperforming the standard SPY.
Why? Because the equal-weight version gives the same influence to a small clothing retailer as it does to Microsoft. If you held the equal-weight version, your SPY 1 year return equivalent looked pretty mediocre for months. It felt like the market was broken. Then, suddenly, the "broadening out" happened. Small caps started moving. Value stocks woke up.
This "broadening" is actually a healthy sign. It means the rally isn't just a tech bubble; it’s starting to seep into the rest of the economy. If you're looking at your portfolio today and wondering why you didn't beat the SPY, it's probably because you were diversified. Ironically, being "responsible" and owning a mix of assets often leads to underperforming the SPY when a few massive tech stocks are mooning.
The Psychology of Seeing a 30% Return
Greed is a funny thing. When the SPY 1 year return is 5%, everyone is bored. When it hits 25%, everyone starts looking for more risk. They start wondering if they should buy leveraged ETFs or dive into crypto.
Professional traders look at these high-return years as a time to rebalance. If your target was to have 60% of your money in stocks and 40% in bonds, a 30% run in SPY means your stocks might now make up 75% of your total pie. You're suddenly much more exposed to a crash than you were a year ago. Most people ignore this. They see the green numbers and want to double down.
Real-World Comparison: SPY vs. Other Assets
To put the SPY 1 year return in perspective, you have to look at what else you could have done with your cash.
- High-Yield Savings Accounts: These were finally paying 4% to 5%. Safe. Boring. But you missed out on an extra 20% gain.
- Gold: Gold had a decent run, hitting all-time highs, but it still struggled to keep pace with the sheer velocity of the S&P 500's tech-heavy growth.
- International Stocks (VEU/VXUS): Europe and emerging markets have been... fine? But they haven't had the Nvidia-fueled rocket boosters that the US market has.
Basically, the US large-cap market has been the "cleanest shirt in the dirty laundry" for global investors. Everyone wants to be where the growth is, and right now, the growth is in American silicon and software.
Don't Forget the Taxes
If you are looking at your SPY 1 year return and thinking about clicking that "sell" button to lock in profits, remember the tax man. If you’ve held the shares for less than 365 days, you’re paying short-term capital gains taxes. That can eat a massive chunk of your "30% gain."
Waiting just one extra day to cross the one-year threshold moves you into long-term capital gains territory, which is significantly lower (0%, 15%, or 20% depending on your income). It is one of the few times in life where doing absolutely nothing for 24 hours can save you thousands of dollars.
Actionable Steps for the "Post-Rally" Phase
If you’ve enjoyed the ride of the last year, don't just sit there. High returns are a gift, but they change the math of your financial plan.
- Check your "Magnificent Seven" exposure. Since SPY is market-cap weighted, you might be more "all-in" on tech than you realize. If you also own individual shares of Apple or Microsoft, you are double-dipping on that risk.
- Harvest some gains if you need the cash. If you have a big purchase coming up in the next year—a house, a car, a wedding—this is a great time to take some of that SPY 1 year return off the table. Don't gamble with money you need in the short term.
- Look at the "Laggards." Areas like healthcare and consumer staples haven't surged as hard as tech. If you're looking to put fresh money to work, it might be worth looking at the parts of the S&P 500 that haven't already gone vertical.
- Verify your cost basis. Make sure your brokerage is correctly tracking your buy-in price. This becomes vital when you eventually sell and have to report to the IRS.
- Stay humble. A 25% return doesn't mean you've "solved" the stock market. It means you were in the right place at the right time. Stick to your long-term contribution plan rather than trying to "time" the inevitable dip.
The SPY 1 year return is a snapshot in time. It's a highlight reel. While it’s fun to celebrate, the real wealth isn't made in the single years where everything goes right; it's made by staying invested through the years where everything goes wrong. Keep your eyes on the horizon, not just the last twelve months of the chart.