Peter Parker has a "type." Usually, it’s the girl next door or the brilliant scientist. But then there is Felicia Hardy. Spider-Man and Black Cat have spent decades dancing on the edge of a rooftop, and honestly, it is easily the most complicated relationship in comic book history. It isn't just about a hero falling for a thief. It is deeper than that. It is about the mask.
Felicia Hardy didn't fall for the guy who worries about his rent or his Aunt May’s health. She fell for the guy who swings through skyscrapers and cracks jokes while fighting a six-armed madman. She loves the Spider, but for a long time, she couldn't stand the man. That is a heavy dynamic to carry for forty-plus years of publication.
How it all started in the 70s
Marv Wolfman and Keith Pollard brought Black Cat into the mix back in The Amazing Spider-Man #194 (1979). She wasn't an instant love interest. She was a villain, or at least, villain-adjacent. Felicia was a world-class cat burglar with a gimmick: she "jinxed" people. If you tried to grab her, you’d trip. If you shot at her, the gun would jam.
The attraction was instant. Peter was used to being the outcast, the "menace" that J. Jonah Jameson screamed about in the papers. With Felicia, he found someone who actually saw the costume as a badge of freedom rather than a burden. She flirted. He blushed. It worked.
The mask is the problem
Here is the thing about Spider-Man and Black Cat that most casual fans miss. Most of Peter's love interests—Gwen Stacy, Mary Jane Watson—loved Peter Parker first. The Spider-Man stuff was the "secret" they had to deal with. Felicia reversed the script. When Peter finally unmasked for her in The Amazing Spider-Man #257, it was a disaster.
She was horrified.
She didn't want a dorky photographer with a tiny apartment and a pile of laundry. She wanted the myth. She wanted the legend. It’s a stinging rejection that Peter never really forgot. Imagine showing someone your true self and having them tell you to put the mask back on. Ouch.
Eventually, she grew past that. She learned to love Peter, but that initial friction defines why they can never quite stay together. They represent two different worlds. Peter is grounded in responsibility. Felicia is grounded in... well, whatever she wants at that moment.
Real talk about the "Bad Luck" powers
For a long time, people thought Felicia was just lucky. Later writers, like Al Milgrom, leaned into the idea that she actually had subconscious probability-altering powers. Basically, she’s a localized disaster zone for anyone she considers an enemy.
But there’s a catch.
In the 80s, she got these powers enhanced by the Kingpin. Because of course she did. Dealing with Wilson Fisk is always a mistake. It turned out that her "bad luck" was contagious and started affecting Peter even when they were just hanging out. It was a literal toxic relationship. She had to break it off to keep him safe, which is one of the few times Felicia acted out of pure, unselfish love.
Why they keep coming back to each other
You’ve probably noticed they never stay apart for long. Why? Because MJ is "home," but Felicia is "the escape."
When Peter is with Mary Jane, he’s a husband (well, depending on which editorial era you're reading) and a provider. When he’s with Black Cat, he’s just Spider-Man. No bills. No guilt. Just the wind in his face. It’s addictive. Even in recent runs like Jed MacKay’s Black Cat series, we see that she’s one of the few people who can keep up with him physically and mentally.
Key moments that changed everything:
- The 90s Drama: Felicia tried to make Peter jealous by dating Flash Thompson. It was messy. It was petty. It was very human.
- The Superior Spider-Man Incident: This was the low point. Doctor Octopus (in Peter’s body) punched Felicia in the face and turned her over to the police. She didn't know it wasn't Peter. She came out of prison hating him, eventually becoming a literal Queenpin of crime.
- The Reconciliation: Thankfully, they fixed that. In the Beyond era and the subsequent Amazing Spider-Man issues, they’ve found a middle ground again. They’re friends. Sometimes more. Usually complicated.
Is Black Cat a villain or a hero?
She’s an anti-hero. Labeling her a villain is a stretch. She has saved the world. She’s helped Peter through his darkest moments, like during the Kraven’s Last Hunt aftermath. But she’s also a thief. She likes shiny things. She likes the thrill of taking what isn't hers.
Tom DeFalco once noted that Felicia is the "dark reflection" of Peter’s freedom. If Peter didn't have Uncle Ben's voice in his head, he’d probably be a lot more like her. That’s the magnetism.
💡 You might also like: Why Hunt for the Wilderpeople is Still the Best Movie You Haven't Seen Enough
The impact on the Marvel Cinematic Universe and Games
We haven't seen a proper live-action Felicia yet, unless you count Felicity Jones’ brief cameo in The Amazing Spider-Man 2. That was a wasted opportunity.
However, the Insomniac Spider-Man games nailed it. In the The City That Never Sleeps DLC, the chemistry between the two is palpable. They use the "does he have a son?" trope to mess with Peter's head, which is such a classic Black Cat move. It shows that even in other media, the core of Spider-Man and Black Cat is manipulation mixed with genuine affection.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you're looking to actually dive into this history without reading 900 issues, there are specific places to start.
- Read the Early Stuff: Track down The Amazing Spider-Man #194 and the "Owl/Octopus War" arc. It shows the rawest version of their partnership.
- Check Out "The Evil that Men Do": Written by Kevin Smith, this miniseries is controversial and deals with very mature themes, but it adds a lot of depth to Felicia’s backstory and why she acts the way she does.
- The Jed MacKay Run: If you want the modern version where Felicia is a badass heist leader who still cares for Peter, this is the gold standard.
- Understand the "One More Day" Fallout: For a while, Felicia forgot Peter's identity just like everyone else. Their relationship had to be rebuilt from scratch, which led to some interesting "will-they-won't-they" moments in the mid-2010s.
Ultimately, Black Cat is the only person who truly understands why Peter Parker puts on the suit, even if she doesn't always agree with why he takes it off. She represents the part of him that wants to stop worrying and just live. That is why, no matter how many times they say goodbye, she’ll always be waiting on the next rooftop.
✨ Don't miss: Halloween Movie Trivia Questions and Answers: What Most People Get Wrong
Keep an eye on current Amazing Spider-Man issues. The writers are constantly shifting the status quo between these two. One month they're a power couple, the next they're barely speaking. That’s just the nature of the cat and the spider.
To get the most out of this lore, focus on the trade paperbacks that collect the "Black Cat" solo series from 2019-2021. It provides the best context for her modern power level and her current standing with the Avengers and the Fantastic Four, proving she's way more than just a Spider-Man supporting character.