You know that feeling when you're sitting around a fire or a crowded living room, and someone starts acting like a horror movie savant? They’ll swear up and down that they know exactly how the Michael Myers mask was made or which film was the first to show a toilet flushing.
Most of the time, they’re half-right. Or totally wrong.
Honestly, the world of horror cinema is packed with myths that have been repeated so many times they’ve basically become "fact." But if you’re looking for halloween movie trivia questions and answers that will actually stump your friends—and maybe even yourself—you have to look at what happened behind the scenes. We’re talking about the low-budget miracles, the cursed sets, and the weird accidents that changed movie history.
The Slasher Origins Nobody Remembers
Let's start with the big one. John Carpenter's Halloween (1978).
People love to talk about the mask. You probably know the basics: they were broke, they went to a costume shop, and they bought a Captain Kirk mask. But it wasn’t just "put on the mask and go." They had to spray-paint it a ghostly bluish-white, rip off the sideburns, and hack the eye holes wider.
The result? A face that looked human but felt empty.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Trivia Question: Which future horror icon was actually on the set of the original Halloween throwing dead leaves to make California look like Illinois?
Answer: Robert Englund. Yep, the man who would become Freddy Krueger was basically a production assistant for a day, helping scatter bags of dried leaves because the movie was filmed in the middle of a green California summer.
Speaking of Michael Myers, here’s a weird one for your next trivia night. In Halloween II, the paramedic Jimmy actually survives in the TV edit. In the theatrical version, he just passes out on a car horn and we never see him again. It’s a tiny detail, but for fans who care about "canon," it changes everything.
The "Cursed" Productions
If you want to get a little darker, look at The Exorcist (1973). This wasn't just a movie; it was a logistical nightmare.
- The set for the MacNeil house caught fire and burned down, except for Regan’s bedroom.
- Linda Blair actually fractured her back when the mechanical bed rig malfunctioned.
- The screams you hear from Ellen Burstyn when she’s thrown to the ground? Those aren't "acting." She seriously injured her coccyx because a stuntman pulled her too hard.
It’s easy to see why people thought the movie was cursed. When it premiered in Rome, a lightning strike actually knocked a 400-year-old cross off a nearby church.
Trivia Question: What was the first American film to ever show a toilet flushing on screen?
Answer: Psycho (1960). It sounds silly now, but in the 60s, that was considered "indecent." Alfred Hitchcock had to fight to keep it in.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Scream and the Meta Revolution
When Wes Craven directed Scream in 1996, he changed the game. But did you know the voice of Ghostface, Roger Jackson, was never allowed to meet the actors?
Craven kept him hidden in a tent outside the houses they were filming in. When the actors picked up the phone, they were actually talking to him in real-time. The fear in their voices? Much of it was genuine because they couldn't put a face to the "intelligent evil" they were hearing.
Another fun one: Rose McGowan’s character, Tatum, gets stuck in the dog flap. In reality, McGowan was so tiny she kept falling out of the door. The crew had to literally nail her clothes to the garage door to keep her in place for the shot.
Quick-Fire Trivia Round
- Question: What was the original title of Scream?
Answer: Scary Movie. The Weinsteins changed it after hearing Michael Jackson’s song "Scream" on the radio. - Question: Who was the first choice to play Max in Hocus Pocus?
Answer: Leonardo DiCaprio. He turned it down to do What's Eating Gilbert Grape, which earned him his first Oscar nod. - Question: In Hereditary, how did they make the chalkboard write by itself?
Answer: Magnets. A simple trick—one in the chalk and one behind the board. - Question: Which horror movie villain has the highest body count?
Answer: Jason Voorhees. He’s racked up over 150 kills across the Friday the 13th franchise.
Modern Nightmares: Hereditary and Beyond
Ari Aster is a perfectionist. For Hereditary, he didn't just find a house; he built the entire interior on a soundstage in Utah. Why? Because he wanted to be able to pull the walls away. He wanted the camera to move in a way that made the family look like they were inside a dollhouse.
Alex Wolff, who played Peter, was so committed he actually wanted to break his own nose during the classroom scene. Aster told him no and gave him a "cushioned" desk. It wasn't cushioned enough, though—Wolff ended up dislocating his jaw anyway.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Trivia Question: Which actor in Hereditary was a Broadway star and Tony winner before making their film debut as Charlie?
Answer: Milly Shapiro. She was one of the original Matildas on Broadway.
Putting Your Trivia to Use
Knowing halloween movie trivia questions and answers isn't just about winning a plastic trophy at a bar. It’s about seeing the "seams" of the movies we love. It’s knowing that the vomit in The Exorcist was just Andersen’s Pea Soup mixed with a bit of oatmeal. Or that the Sanderson Sisters in Hocus Pocus were originally meant to be way scarier before Disney decided to lean into the camp.
If you’re hosting a night soon, don't just ask "Who played Jason?" Everyone knows that.
Ask about the $250 Tony Moran got paid just to show his face for three seconds as the unmasked Michael Myers. Ask about the real moths Doug Jones had to keep in his mouth for the Billy Butcherson scene in Hocus Pocus.
To really level up your trivia game, start looking for the "mistakes" that stayed in. The best horror often comes from things going wrong. When a light burst on the set of Hereditary right after someone said the name of "The Scottish Play" out loud, that wasn't a script—it was just the universe being creepy.
Check out the original scripts of your favorite films on sites like IMSDb. Often, the endings were totally different. For example, Get Out originally had a much darker ending where Chris actually goes to jail. Knowing these "what if" scenarios adds a whole new layer to your expertise.