You know that feeling when you fire up a kart racer and realize the "balanced" mascot is actually the most boring choice on the roster? Yeah, we’re talking about Sonic. Don't get me wrong, the Blue Blur is iconic, but if you've spent more than five minutes in Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing or its sequel, Transformed, you know that picking the hedgehog is basically the "vanilla ice cream" of gaming decisions.
Honestly, the real magic of these games isn't just the drift mechanics or the way the tracks literally fall apart beneath your wheels. It’s the roster. SEGA didn’t just throw in a few Sonic clones and call it a day; they dug deep into the "weird" bin. We’re talking about characters that haven't seen a standalone game since the Dreamcast was relevant.
But here’s the thing: not all sonic all stars racing characters are created equal. Some are absolute speed demons that require the reflexes of a caffeinated squirrel, while others are essentially "heavyweights" that feel like driving a literal brick.
The Heavy Hitters and Why Stats Actually Matter
In the first game, Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing, the stats were a bit more opaque, but by the time Transformed rolled around, SEGA got serious. They gave us a 1-to-5 scale for Speed, Acceleration, Handling, Boost, and that elusive "All-Star" stat.
If you’re the type of player who hates being bumped around, you probably gravitated toward someone like Dr. Eggman or Big the Cat. They’re slow off the line—sorta like trying to start a lawnmower in the winter—but once they get going, they’re hard to stop. On the flip side, characters like Tails or AiAi from Super Monkey Ball have handling stats that let you take corners like you’re on rails.
Breaking Down the Top Tiers
Most people assume Sonic has the best top speed. He doesn't. In Transformed, that honor actually belongs to B.D. Joe from Crazy Taxi. The guy is a speed freak. His 5/5 Speed stat makes him a monster on long straights, but if you hit a wall? Good luck. His acceleration is so low you’ll have enough time to go make a sandwich before he hits top speed again.
Then you’ve got the technical picks.
- Joe Musashi (Shinobi): A personal favorite. He’s got a massive 5/5 Boost stat. If you can chain your drifts and hit every dash pad, Joe is essentially untouchable.
- Gilius Thunderhead (Golden Axe): Another high-speed, high-boost character. He’s basically the "pro" pick because his handling is so bad it feels like he’s driving on ice.
- Vyse (Skies of Arcadia): A great all-rounder for people who find Sonic too "floaty." He’s got decent speed and better-than-average boost.
The Weird, the Wild, and the Guest Stars
SEGA’s crossover energy is unmatched. Where else can you see a NASCAR driver, a Disney villain, and a literal Dreamcast console racing against a blue hedgehog?
One of the most controversial additions was Danica Patrick. Yes, the actual professional racer. It felt a bit out of place at the time, but she actually has some of the most balanced stats in the game. Then there’s Wreck-It Ralph, who was added as a promotional tie-in but actually fits the "heavyweight" archetype perfectly.
💡 You might also like: Push The Button Game: Why Jackbox Games Might Have Created the Most Stressful Social Experience Ever
PC Exclusives and the Forgotten Ones
If you played on PC, you got the "Golden Era" of weird guest characters. We’re talking about the Team Fortress 2 trio (Pyro, Heavy, and Spy all sharing one vehicle), General Winter from Company of Heroes, and even Football Manager. Yes, a guy from a spreadsheet simulator made it into a kart racer.
The console versions had their own exclusives, too. Xbox players got their Avatars and Banjo-Kazooie (back in the first game), while Wii U users got their Miis. It’s a bit of a mess for completionists because no single version of the game actually contains every single character ever made for the series.
The All-Star Move: More Than Just a Power-Up
In most kart racers, the "ultimate" item is randomized. Not here. The All-Star move is tied specifically to your character. This is where the sonic all stars racing characters truly show their personality.
Sonic goes Super Sonic (obviously). But have you seen AGES? AGES is a character that literally is SEGA’s history. It starts as a VMU (the Dreamcast memory card), turns into a 3D Controller, and its All-Star move involves transforming into a freaking F-14 Tomcat from After Burner.
The "All-Star" stat on the character select screen basically tells you how effective these moves are. A 5/5 All-Star stat, like Shadow’s, means the move is devastating and lasts a while. A 1/5 stat, like B.D. Joe’s, means the move is more of a "get out of jail free" card that doesn't do much actual damage to the competition.
🔗 Read more: Why Link's Awakening Catfish Maw is the Most Confusing Dungeon in the Game
Why Character Choice Can Ruin Your Win Streak
If you're struggling to beat the World Tour on S-Rank, the problem might not be your driving. It might be your main.
Handling is the "hidden" god stat of Sonic All-Stars. On tracks like Dream Valley (the NiGHTS stage) or Adder's Lair (Golden Axe), the turns are so tight that a high-speed character like B.D. Joe will constantly fly off the edge.
For the harder challenges, most experts suggest switching to a character with at least a 4 in Handling. Amy Rose or Amigo are usually the safe bets here. They won't win a drag race, but they’ll stay on the track while everyone else is plummeting into the abyss.
Tips for Mastering Your Favorite Racer
- Don't ignore the Mods: In Transformed, you can unlock "Mods" for each character. These tweak your stats. If you love Gilius but hate his handling, you can equip a Handling Mod to make him more viable.
- Learn the Transformation Points: Each character handles differently in the air and water. For example, some characters that are great on land become absolute boats (pun intended) once the vehicle transforms.
- Watch the Weight: Heavier characters can bully smaller ones off the track. If you're playing as Eggman, don't be afraid to literally ram into a Tails player. You’ll win that trade 100% of the time.
Moving Beyond the Basics
To truly master the roster, you need to stop thinking about them as just "skins" and start looking at them as different gameplay styles. The shift from the first game to Transformed changed the meta significantly, making "Boost" and "Handling" far more important than raw "Speed."
If you’re still playing on the Steam version or digging out your old 360, try picking someone you’ve never used before. Put down Sonic, ignore Shadow for a second, and try to win a race with Alex Kidd. It’s a completely different game when you aren't playing as the poster child.
👉 See also: Monsters in R.E.P.O. Explained: How to Survive Every Entity
Ready to improve your lap times? Go into Time Attack mode and pick AGES. Its unique handling properties and high skill ceiling make it the ultimate test for any serious player. Practice the "drift-hop" on the Ocean View track to see just how much time you can shave off when you aren't limited by a "balanced" character's stats.