If you walked past 505 Park Avenue a few years ago, you would’ve seen the literal throne of the American wine world. Sherry Lehmann New York wasn't just a liquor store. It was the place where Greta Garbo bought her champagne and where Andy Warhol probably popped in for a bottle of something expensive. It was an institution that survived the end of Prohibition only to find its modern-day ending in a mess of FBI raids, missing Petrus, and millions in unpaid taxes.
Honestly, it’s a tragedy. Or a heist movie. Depends on who you ask.
The shop that basically invented the "wine future" in the U.S. is now a shell. By mid-2023, the New York State Liquor Authority had effectively pulled the plug because the owners failed to renew their license. But that was just the tip of the iceberg. Behind the shuttered doors was a $2.7 million tax debt and a growing list of furious collectors who realized their "stored" wine collections might have actually been sold to someone else.
The Slow Burn of a Manhattan Icon
For 89 years, Sherry-Lehmann was the gold standard. Founded in 1934 by Jack Aaron, it moved from Madison Avenue to Park Avenue and became the "Tiffany’s of wine." You didn't just buy a bottle there; you bought the expertise of the Aaron family.
Things started to get weird after the family sold the business. The new management, led by Shyda Gilmer and Kris Green, inherited a legacy that was increasingly hard to maintain. Rents on Park Avenue aren't exactly cheap—we’re talking nearly $2 million a year. Then the pandemic hit. Midtown Manhattan turned into a ghost town. The corporate clients who used to order five-figure cases of Bordeaux for holiday gifts just... vanished.
🔗 Read more: Are There Tariffs on China: What Most People Get Wrong Right Now
But you can't blame everything on COVID-19.
Evidence suggests the rot started years earlier. By 2017, long-time customers were already complaining about "wine futures." For those not in the know, a future is basically a pre-order. You pay now for a wine that’s still in the barrel in France, and they deliver it to you two years later. Except at Sherry Lehmann New York, the two years turned into five. Then seven. Then never.
The Wine Caves Mystery
One of the biggest draws for the elite was "Wine Caves," the company's off-site storage facility. If you live in a Manhattan apartment, you don't have room for 500 bottles of 1982 Bordeaux. You pay Sherry-Lehmann to keep it in a temperature-controlled vault.
It sounds safe. It wasn't.
💡 You might also like: Adani Ports SEZ Share Price: Why the Market is kida Obsessed Right Now
By 2023, reports surfaced that wine belonging to certain collectors—including socialite Mercedes Bass—had been moved or sold without permission. Imagine paying storage fees for years only to find out your $5,000 bottle of Petrus was actually on someone else's dinner table in the Hamptons.
What went wrong?
- The Tax Bill: The shop ended up on the New York State "Top 250" delinquent taxpayer list. They owed over $3 million at one point.
- The FBI Raid: In July 2023, the feds showed up. They weren't there for a tasting. Agents were seen hauling out boxes of records and files, signaling a full-blown criminal investigation into whether the shop was operating a Ponzi-like scheme with customers' wine.
- The T.G.I. Fridays Basement: In one of the most bizarre twists, it was discovered that some of this world-class wine was being stored in a basement under a shuttered T.G.I. Fridays in Times Square. Hardly the "caves" people thought they were paying for.
Why Sherry Lehmann New York Still Matters
You might wonder why anyone still cares about a closed shop. It's because the fallout is still happening. As of early 2026, many customers are finally getting glimpses of their wine back, but it's a legal nightmare.
The story of Sherry-Lehmann is a warning. It shows how even the most "un-killable" brands can be destroyed by poor management and a lack of transparency. When a business stops answering the phone and starts bouncing checks to wholesalers, the prestige of the name on the door doesn't mean anything.
Wholesalers eventually stopped delivering. They went "C.O.D."—Cash on Delivery. If Sherry-Lehmann didn't have the literal cash on the counter when the truck arrived, the wine went back to the warehouse. This created a death spiral. No stock means no sales; no sales means no money to pay the $4.8 million in back rent they eventually owed their landlord, Glorious Sun.
📖 Related: 40 Quid to Dollars: Why You Always Get Less Than the Google Rate
The Aftermath and Your Wine
If you still have "futures" or stored wine with the remnants of this business, you're basically in a long line of creditors. The company was hit with an "order of ejectment" in March 2024, meaning they were legally kicked out of the Park Avenue space.
Recent court filings from 2025 show that some wine stashes—including $80,000 worth of Bordeaux—were finally being released to their rightful owners. But for many, the bottles are just gone.
Actionable Steps for Affected Collectors
- Check the Dockets: Follow the Southern District of New York (SDNY) court records. Cases like Wine, Liquor & Distillery Workers Union v. Sherry-Lehmann or individual customer lawsuits are where the status of assets is revealed.
- Verify Your Inventory: If you have wine in storage anywhere in NYC, get a physical inventory check. Don't rely on a digital portal.
- Future Proofing: If you're buying wine futures today, only use retailers with a massive, proven balance sheet. The "oldest name in the business" isn't a guarantee of solvency anymore.
- Tax Records: If you believe you were charged sales tax that was never remitted to the state (a common allegation in this case), keep your receipts. They are vital for any future class-action participation.
The downfall of Sherry-Lehmann marks the end of an era for New York retail. It wasn't just a store; it was a landmark. Now, it’s a cautionary tale about what happens when a legacy is traded for short-term survival. The lesson is simple: in the world of fine wine, trust is even more expensive than the bottle.