You're staring at a map of the Caribbean, and honestly, it’s a mess of beautiful options. Picking between Puerto Rico vs. San Vicente y Granadinas isn't just about comparing two islands; it’s about choosing between two completely different universes. One is a high-energy, thumping heartbeat of a place where you can find a 24-hour Walgreens and a world-class rainforest within twenty minutes of each other. The other? It’s a string of thirty-two islands where people still measure time by the tide and the arrival of the mail boat.
Most people get this comparison wrong because they think "Caribbean" is a monolithic vibe. It isn't.
Puerto Rico is the "Big City" of the islands. It’s got the infrastructure. It’s got the massive airports. If you’re coming from the States, you don’t even need a passport, which is a massive logistical win. But San Vicente y Granadinas—or SVG as the locals and yachties call it—is for the person who wants to disappear. You go there to be unreachable.
The Logistics of Getting There (And Staying Sane)
Let’s talk about the flight, because this is where the reality check happens.
Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport (SJU) in San Juan is a beast. It handles millions of people. You can find direct flights from London, Madrid, New York, and Bogota. You land, you grab a Cape Air flight to Culebra, or you just rent a car and drive. It’s easy. It’s almost too easy.
SVG is a different story. For decades, getting to St. Vincent was a nightmare involving prop planes from Barbados or St. Lucia. The opening of the Argyle International Airport changed things, but it’s still not "easy." You’re likely looking at a connection. And if you want to get to the "good stuff"—the Granadinas like Bequia, Mustique, or Mayreau—you’re getting on a ferry or a tiny charter plane that feels like a flying lawnmower.
Money and Connectivity
In Puerto Rico, you’re using the US Dollar. Your phone plan from the US probably works without roaming fees. You can find high-speed fiber internet in San Juan and even in some remote Airbnb rentals in Utuado. It’s a digital nomad’s dream.
In St. Vincent and the Grenadines, the Eastern Caribbean Dollar (XCD) is the local currency, though US dollars are widely accepted in tourist areas. The exchange rate is usually pegged around 2.70 XCD to 1 USD. Internet exists, sure, but it’s "island internet." If a storm rolls through or the lizard on the wire has a bad day, you’re offline. It forces you to actually look at the ocean.
Vibe Check: San Juan Sparkle vs. Grenadines Grit
San Juan is loud. It’s reggaeton blasting from a customized Jeep in Santurce. It’s the smell of alcapurrias frying at a roadside kiosk in Piñones. You have the history of Old San Juan, with its 500-year-old blue cobblestones and the massive forts like El Morro, but right next to it, you have the Condado district which feels like a mini-Miami.
👉 See also: Johnny's Reef on City Island: What People Get Wrong About the Bronx’s Iconic Seafood Spot
Puerto Rico offers a scale of diversity that SVG can’t match. You have the central mountain range (La Cordillera Central) where it actually gets chilly enough for a sweater. You have the dry forest of Guánica. You have the bioluminescent bays in Vieques. It’s a lot.
SVG is more... fragmented. St. Vincent itself is a rugged, volcanic island. It’s green. It’s dramatic. It’s home to La Soufrière, an active volcano that last erupted in 2021, covering the island in ash and reminding everyone who’s really in charge.
But the Granadinas? That’s where the postcard images live.
Bequia (pronounced beck-way) has a quirky, old-school sailing culture.
Mustique is where rock stars and royals go to hide in multi-million dollar "cottages."
The Tobago Cays are basically a set from a movie—five uninhabited cays surrounded by a horseshoe reef where you can swim with green sea turtles in water so clear it looks like gin.
The Food Scene: Mofongo vs. Roasted Breadfruit
Food is a serious business in this comparison.
If you go to Puerto Rico and don't eat mofongo, you’ve failed. It’s mashed green plantains with garlic, olive oil, and pork cracklings, usually stuffed with shrimp or chicken. The culinary scene in San Juan is sophisticated. Chefs like José Santaella are doing things with local ingredients that would win Michelin stars if the guide covered the island. You have the "Pork Highway" in Guavate, where you can eat lechon (roast suckling pig) until you need a nap.
St. Vincent is the "Breadfruit Capital." They love it so much it’s on their national coat of arms. Their national dish is roasted breadfruit and fried jackfish. It’s hearty, salty, and perfect.
The dining experience in SVG is generally more casual. You’re eating at a picnic table on the beach. You’re getting fresh lobster caught that morning. In the Grenadines, the food is often dictated by what the supply boat brought in that week, supplemented by incredible local fruit like mangoes and soursop. It’s less "fine dining" and more "fine ingredients."
Nature and Adventure
Puerto Rico has El Yunque. It’s the only tropical rainforest in the US National Forest System. You can hike to waterfalls like La Mina or Britton Tower. If you’re into surfing, Rincón on the west coast is legendary. The waves at Domes or Maria’s Beach are world-class during the winter swell.
✨ Don't miss: Is Barceló Whale Lagoon Maldives Actually Worth the Trip to Ari Atoll?
St. Vincent has the Vermont Nature Trail and the hike up La Soufrière. It’s grueling. It’s a physical challenge that requires a guide and some decent boots. But the real "nature" in SVG is underwater.
The diving in the Grenadines is vastly superior to the main island of Puerto Rico. While PR has some great spots (especially off the coast of Fajardo or the "Wall" in La Parguera), SVG is part of the Grenadines bank. The coral health is generally better, and the sheer volume of marine life in the Tobago Cays Marine Park is staggering.
Cost Comparison: Why Your Wallet Might Cry
Let’s be real. Neither of these is a "budget" destination in the way Southeast Asia is.
Puerto Rico can be done on a budget if you stay in hostels or guesthouses outside of San Juan and eat at mesones gastronómicos. But once you start adding up car rentals (which are expensive and necessary), high-end dinners, and tours, it adds up.
San Vicente y Granadinas is expensive by design. Because so much has to be imported to the smaller islands, a burger in Bequia might cost you more than a steak in NYC. Logistics are the killer here. Taking water taxis between islands or hopping on small flights eats your budget fast. However, you aren't spending money on shopping or big-city distractions because there aren't many.
Nightlife and Social Energy
If you want to party until 4 AM, go to Puerto Rico. La Placita de Santurce is a marketplace by day and a massive outdoor street party by night. It’s sweaty, it’s loud, and it’s incredible.
If you want to sit at a bar called "Basil's" on Mustique and hope to see Mick Jagger while sipping a rum punch, go to SVG. The nightlife in the Grenadines is centered around "Jump Ups" or quiet drinks at a yacht club. It’s refined or rugged, but rarely "clubby."
The Elephant in the Room: Safety and Stability
Puerto Rico is a US Territory. It has US laws, US courts, and US federal oversight. It’s generally safe, though like any big city, San Juan has neighborhoods you should avoid at night.
🔗 Read more: How to Actually Book the Hangover Suite Caesars Las Vegas Without Getting Fooled
St. Vincent and the Grenadines is an independent nation within the Commonwealth. It’s stable, but it’s a developing nation. Petty theft can happen, especially from yachts. The main island of St. Vincent has some rougher areas in Kingstown, but the Grenadines are generally very safe and communal.
Making the Choice: The "Who Are You?" Test
Choosing between these two comes down to what you want your vacation to look like when you close your eyes.
Choose Puerto Rico if:
- You want convenience. No passport (for US citizens), easy flights, and great roads.
- You love a mix of beach and "real" city culture.
- You are a foodie who wants high-end gastronomy and street food variety.
- You need to stay connected for work.
- You want to see a rainforest, a desert, and a bioluminescent bay in one week.
Choose San Vicente y Granadinas if:
- You want to feel like an explorer.
- You love sailing or being on the water more than being on land.
- You want to escape the "Americanized" version of the Caribbean.
- You don't mind a little logistical friction for the sake of privacy.
- You want to see what the islands looked like fifty years ago.
Actionable Insights for Your Trip
If you go to Puerto Rico, rent a car. Do not rely on Ubers outside of San Juan. Book your ferry tickets to Vieques or Culebra weeks in advance via the Por Ferry website, or better yet, just bite the bullet and pay for the small plane from Isla Grande airport. It saves you four hours of headaches.
If you go to San Vicente y Granadinas, pack light. You’ll be jumping on and off ferries and small planes with weight limits. Buy a "cruising guide" even if you aren't sailing; it has the best info on local moorings and beach bars. Most importantly, bring a high-quality, reef-safe sunscreen. The sun in the Grenadines doesn't play around, and you’ll spend 90% of your time on the water where the reflection doubles the burn.
Ultimately, Puerto Rico is a place you visit to "do" things. San Vicente y Granadinas is a place you go to "be." Both are spectacular, but they serve different parts of the soul. Decide if you want the rhythm of the drums or the rhythm of the waves.
Check the local weather patterns before booking; June to November is hurricane season for both, though SVG is technically further south and occasionally stays just out of the main track—but as 2024's Hurricane Beryl proved, nowhere is truly exempt. Always get the travel insurance. It’s the smartest $100 you’ll spend.