You’ve downloaded them all. Notion, Todoist, Obsidian, maybe that weird one with the forest that grows trees while you work. You spend three hours "building a system" and then exactly twenty minutes actually working. Honestly, productivity apps have become the digital equivalent of buying new running shoes and thinking that makes you a marathon runner.
It's a trap.
Most people use these tools to feel busy rather than to be effective. We live in an era where "workflow optimization" is a hobby. But if you're spending more time tagging tasks than doing them, you're just procrastinating with better aesthetics.
The Productivity Apps Paradox
Here is the thing. Software companies want you to stay inside their app. That is their business model. But the point of a productivity tool should be to get you out of the app and into your actual work. When an app adds "social features" or "infinite customization," it is often just adding friction.
👉 See also: Google Authenticator for Mac: The Fix for People Tired of Grabbing Their Phones
You’ve probably heard of Parkinson’s Law. It basically says work expands to fill the time available. Digital tools do something similar. Your list of tasks expands to fill the capabilities of the app. If the app allows for 50 sub-tasks and 10 priority levels, you will find a way to use them, even if the job is just "write a blog post."
Why your brain hates digital lists
Science is pretty clear on this. Dr. Bluma Zeigarnik identified what we now call the Zeigarnik Effect. It’s that nagging feeling you get when a task is unfinished. Productivity apps are essentially Zeigarnik Effect engines. They remind you of everything you aren't doing.
When you look at a digital list of 45 items, your brain doesn't see "organization." It sees a threat. This triggers a micro-stress response. Instead of focusing on the one thing that matters, you’re paralyzed by the 44 things that don't. This is why so many people go back to paper. A piece of paper doesn't have notifications. It doesn't have a "backlog" that haunts you from 2022.
The "Everything is a Priority" Lie
Most productivity apps treat every entry with the same weight unless you manually intervene. A notification for "Buy milk" looks exactly like a notification for "Finish quarterly budget."
This is what experts call "flat hierarchy."
Without a clear sense of what actually moves the needle, we tend to do the easy things first. We check off the low-hanging fruit. It feels good. We get a hit of dopamine. But at the end of the day, the big, scary, important project is still sitting there.
Real-world friction vs. digital ease
In the 1990s, David Allen’s Getting Things Done (GTD) changed everything. It was meant for paper and filing cabinets. The friction of physically moving a piece of paper meant you only kept what was vital. Digital tools removed that friction. Now, we keep everything.
We’ve become digital hoards. We save articles we’ll never read into "Read Later" apps that are really "Read Never" graveyards. We create "Second Brains" in Obsidian or Roam Research that are more cluttered than our first brains.
How to actually use these tools without losing your mind
If you’re going to use productivity apps, you need a strategy that isn't just "input everything." You need to be ruthless.
🔗 Read more: James A. Van Allen: What Most People Get Wrong About the Man Who Found the Belts
- The Rule of Three. Open your app. Pick three things. Close the app. If you do more, great. But three is the limit for what you can realistically focus on with high quality.
- Batching. Stop checking your task manager every twenty minutes. It’s just another form of social media at that point. Check it in the morning, check it after lunch, check it before you sign off.
- The "Delete" Key. It is your best friend. If a task has been on your list for three weeks and you haven't touched it, you're probably not going to do it. Delete it. If it’s important, it’ll come back.
The trap of "Optimization Porn"
You see it on YouTube all the time. "My Aesthetic Notion Setup." It looks beautiful. It has widgets and weather reports and motivational quotes. It’s also a massive waste of time for 99% of people.
Unless your job is literally "Notion Architect," you don't need a complex system. You need a list and a calendar. That’s it. Most people who are actually getting massive amounts of work done—think top-tier CEOs or prolific authors—often use the simplest tools imaginable.
When to quit your app
Is the app making you faster? Or are you just spending more time "organizing" your work than "doing" your work?
If you find yourself spending more than 10 minutes a day managing the tool itself, the tool is broken. Or you are using it wrong. Productivity apps should be a peripheral, not the main event.
🔗 Read more: How to Make ChatGPT Less Agreeable and Actually Get Useful Feedback
Think about the most productive day you had in the last month. Was it productive because of an app? Or was it productive because you put your phone in another room, turned off your internet, and sat in a chair until the work was done?
Usually, it's the latter.
The bias toward "New"
We have a cognitive bias toward newness. We think a new app will be the magic bullet that finally makes us disciplined. It won't. Discipline is a muscle, not a software subscription. Switching from Todoist to TickTick won't make you a hard worker. It just gives you a new interface to ignore your responsibilities in.
Reclaiming your focus
To actually win at this, you have to stop treating productivity apps like a savior. They are just buckets. Buckets don't move water; you do.
The most effective people I know use a "low-tech, high-intent" approach. They might use Google Calendar for meetings because they have to, but their daily priorities are written on a Post-it note. Why? Because you can't hide a Post-it note behind another tab. It sits there, staring at you, until the job is finished.
Actionable steps for tomorrow morning
Stop looking for a new app. It's not there. Instead, try this:
- Audit your current tool. Look at your main task list. If there are more than 20 items on it, you aren't organized; you're overwhelmed. Move 15 of them to a "Someday" list and hide that list.
- Identify the "Big Frog." Mark the one task you are dreading the most. Do that before you even open your email.
- Turn off all notifications. Your productivity app should never, ever be allowed to send you a push notification. You go to the app when you are ready to work; it should not bark at you while you are trying to think.
- Physical backup. Keep a notebook on your desk. When a random thought pops up during deep work, write it in the notebook, not the app. Don't break your digital flow.
The goal isn't to have a perfect system. The goal is to get the work done and go home. Productivity apps are a means to an end, and for most of us, that end is having more time away from our screens. Stop fiddling with the settings and start doing the thing you're avoiding.