Honestly, if you looked at the standings in May, you probably thought the Phillies were just going to steamroll everyone. They were playing some of the most dominant baseball we’ve seen in South Philly for decades. But then the Milwaukee Brewers showed up. The Phillies vs Brewers 2024 season series ended up being one of those weird, gritty chess matches that defined the power structure of the National League. It wasn't just about home runs or flashy catches. It was about which team could survive the pressure of clinching scenarios and elite pitching.
Most people forget that the Brewers actually won the season series 4-2. Yeah, you read 그 right. Despite the Phillies finishing with 95 wins and the top seed in many people's minds, Milwaukee had their number when it mattered. The Phillies took the first three games at home in June, looking like world-beaters. Then they went to Milwaukee in September and everything changed.
The June Sweep That Fooled Us All
In early June, the Brewers walked into Citizens Bank Park and got absolutely stifled. It was a pitching masterclass from the Phillies' rotation. Zack Wheeler, Aaron Nola, and Cristopher Sánchez were basically untouchable.
The series opener on June 3 set the tone. The Phillies won 3-1. Then came June 4, which was a classic "Philly special." Nick Castellanos, who has a knack for the dramatic, ripped a walk-off double in the 10th inning to win it 2-1. Alec Bohm had tied it up in the 8th with a solo shot. It felt like the Phillies could just pull a win out of thin air whenever they wanted.
By the time the Phillies won 2-0 on June 5 to complete the sweep, Milwaukee looked lost. They didn't score a single run in that finale. Aaron Nola was dominant, and the Brewers' bats were colder than a Lake Michigan breeze in January. At that point, the Phillies vs Brewers 2024 narrative was "Philadelphia is the team to beat."
Why September Flipped the Script
Fast forward to mid-September. The vibe was totally different. The Brewers were on the verge of clinching the NL Central, and the Phillies were trying to lock down a first-round bye. This is where things got interesting.
💡 You might also like: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
Milwaukee didn't just win; they won with grit. On September 16, they took the opener 6-2. They followed it up with a heartbreaking (for Philly fans) 2-1 win on September 18. Jake Bauers hit a walk-off single in the 9th inning. That single didn't just win the game—it sparked a champagne celebration. The Brewers clinched the NL Central title that night. Seeing the Brewers celebrate on the same field where the Phillies were trying to assert dominance was a reality check for Rob Thomson's squad.
- June 3-5 (Philadelphia): Phillies sweep (Scores: 3-1, 2-1, 2-0)
- September 16-18 (Milwaukee): Brewers sweep (Scores: 6-2, 1-5, 2-1)
- Season Series Winner: Milwaukee Brewers (4-2)
Wait, I should probably correct myself there. The Phillies actually won the game on September 17. Zack Wheeler went 7 innings and allowed only one run. Bryce Harper and Nick Castellanos both homered. So, while the Brewers won the series 4-2, the Phillies did manage to "keep the champagne on ice" for at least 24 hours.
The Rhys Hoskins Factor
You can't talk about Phillies vs Brewers 2024 without mentioning Rhys Hoskins. It was weird, right? Seeing him in that Milwaukee cream-and-navy jersey. After years of being the heartbeat of the Phillies' clubhouse, he was suddenly the enemy.
His return to Philly in June was emotional. Standing ovations. Tears. The whole deal. But on the field, Hoskins was his usual professional self. He didn't blow the roof off with home runs against his old team, but his presence in that Brewers lineup added a layer of psychological drama. He knew the Phillies' pitchers better than anyone. He knew the tendencies.
The Brewers’ success in 2024 was largely built on this "scrappy" identity. They didn't have the $300 million superstars like Bryce Harper or Trea Turner (mostly). They had William Contreras, who has quietly become one of the best catchers in baseball, and a bullpen that seemed to have an endless supply of guys throwing 99 mph with movement.
📖 Related: NL Rookie of the Year 2025: Why Drake Baldwin Actually Deserved the Hardware
Pitching Matchups That Defined the Season
The Phillies vs Brewers 2024 matchups were a dream for stat nerds. You had the traditional "workhorse" rotation of the Phillies against the "pitching lab" approach of the Brewers.
Zack Wheeler was, well, Zack Wheeler. He finished the season as a Cy Young runner-up for a reason. In his September start against Milwaukee, he showed exactly why he’s the most feared starter in the NL. He neutralized a Brewers lineup that was top-5 in stolen bases and high-pressure situations.
On the other side, the Brewers used guys like Tobias Myers and Freddy Peralta to keep the Phillies' high-priced hitters off-balance. The Phillies' lineup is built to punish mistakes. If you leave a hanging slider to Kyle Schwarber, it’s going into the second deck. The Brewers' staff didn't make those mistakes often. They focused on "tunneling" and high-spin rates, which sort of neutralized the Phillies' aggression.
Key Performance Stats:
- Zack Wheeler: 1.29 ERA against Milwaukee in 2024.
- William Contreras: Led the Brewers with a .365 OBP, a thorn in the side of Philly's starters.
- Nick Castellanos: The most consistent Phillies hitter in the season series, providing two of their most pivotal RBIs.
What Most People Get Wrong About the 2024 Series
There's this common misconception that the Phillies were the "better" team and just had a bad week in September. Honestly? That's not quite right. Milwaukee's 2024 squad was built specifically to beat teams like Philadelphia.
The Brewers led the league in several defensive categories and were elite at "small ball." While the Phillies relied on the long ball, the Brewers were perfectly happy winning 2-1 or 3-2 by moving runners over and playing lockdown defense. This clash of styles made the Phillies vs Brewers 2024 games feel like playoff previews.
👉 See also: New Zealand Breakers vs Illawarra Hawks: What Most People Get Wrong
Milwaukee’s manager, Pat Murphy, basically out-maneuvered everyone. He used his bullpen like a weapon, often pulling starters early to ensure the Phillies' hitters never saw a pitcher for a third time in a game. It worked.
Actionable Insights for Baseball Fans
If you're looking back at the 2024 season to understand how these two teams will interact in the future, there are a few things to keep in mind.
First, the season series tiebreaker matters. Because the Brewers won the series 4-2, they held the edge in playoff seeding. If you're a bettor or a fantasy manager, pay attention to the venue. The Phillies are a different animal at Citizens Bank Park, but they struggled with the unique sightlines and roof conditions at American Family Field.
Second, watch the catcher battle. William Contreras vs. J.T. Realmuto is arguably the best positional rivalry in the National League right now. In 2024, Contreras proved he belongs in the MVP conversation, while Realmuto showed he’s still the "BCIB" (Best Catcher in Baseball) when healthy.
Lastly, don't overlook the "revenge" narrative. Every time these teams meet, the Rhys Hoskins storyline will be there, but so will the budding rivalry between two fanbases that are starting to realize they are the two biggest hurdles in the NL that aren't named the Dodgers.
The 2024 chapter of this rivalry showed us that star power doesn't always trump system-wide execution. The Phillies have the icons, but the Brewers have the blueprint. Seeing how those two philosophies clash is exactly why we watch the game. Keep an eye on the schedule for next season; the pitching matchups are likely to be just as tight, and the stakes will probably be even higher.