Ever seen a sketch that looked kinda like Roronoa Zoro but felt... off? That's because it wasn't Zoro. At least, not yet. If you've been deep in the Reddit threads or the SBS columns lately, you’ve probably seen people obsessing over the one piece test character—those weird, rough drafts Eiichiro Oda doodled before Romance Dawn ever hit the pages of Weekly Shonen Jump. These aren't just doodles. They’re the DNA of the biggest manga on the planet.
Most fans think One Piece just appeared out of thin air, fully formed. Nope. It was a messy process. Honestly, looking at the original designs for the Straw Hat crew is like looking at a parallel universe where everything went slightly wrong.
🔗 Read more: Doug Judy: Why the Pontiac Bandit is the Friend We All Wish We Had (Sorta)
The One Piece Test Character That Almost Changed History
Take a look at the "test" version of Tony Tony Chopper. He wasn't always a cute, marketable reindeer with a blue nose. In the early concept art, Chopper was a smoke-shuffling, realistic-looking reindeer that looked like he belonged in a gritty survival manga rather than a whimsical pirate adventure. He even carried a sword. Can you imagine Chopper trying to "KUNG FU POINT" while hacking people to bits? It changes the whole vibe.
Oda’s process for a one piece test character is basically a masterclass in trial and error. He doesn't just draw a guy and call it a day. He iterates. He scraps. He pivots. This is why the series feels so lived-in. Every character we love is the survivor of a brutal casting process that happened on Oda’s desk in the mid-90s.
Why the Prototypes Look So Weird
You’ve got to understand the context of 1996. Shonen manga was dominated by the hyper-muscular aesthetics of Dragon Ball and the edgy vibes of YuYu Hakusho. When Oda was developing his one piece test character lineup, he was fighting against the grain.
Initially, Nami wasn't a navigator with weather powers. She was a battle-hardened cyborg wielding a massive mechanical axe. Her design was heavy, metallic, and honestly, a bit generic for the time. Oda realized that a "battle girl" wasn't as interesting as a thief with a complex moral compass. So, he stripped away the cyborg limbs and gave her a map. That one decision saved the emotional core of the Arlong Park arc.
Variation is the spice of life, right? Oda thinks so too. He often keeps these "failed" test characters in his back pocket. Ever notice how some background characters in Wano look suspiciously like early 90s sketches? That’s not laziness. That’s a creator who never throws away a good idea, even if it didn't fit the main protagonist slot.
The Mystery of the "Sixth" Member
In one of the most famous pieces of early concept art, there’s a one piece test character standing where Franky or Brook eventually would. He’s a tiny, plant-loving dwarf-like man. For years, fans speculated he was the original Jinbe. Others thought he was a precursor to Usopp.
✨ Don't miss: Why Deftones Bored is Actually One of the Most Important Songs in Alt-Metal History
Actually, it turns out Oda just really wanted a botanist on the ship.
He eventually split that "test" DNA across several characters. Usopp got the plant-based Pop Greens. Chopper got the medical knowledge. Robin got the "quiet intellectual" vibe. This is how a single one piece test character can influence three different protagonists decades later.
The Evolution of Luffy’s Design
Luffy is the ultimate one piece test character. In the Romance Dawn one-shots (there were two different versions before the main series), Luffy’s personality shifted wildly. In one, he was basically a younger version of Shanks. In another, his Gomu Gomu powers were treated more like a curse than a fun quirk.
Oda was testing the limits of "rubbery-ness."
If you look at the 1996 sketches, Luffy’s face was much sharper. He looked meaner. More like a traditional "tough guy." Oda eventually softened the eyes and rounded the face because he wanted a hero who looked like he was always having fun. That’s the secret sauce. A character’s silhouette tells you their destiny before they even speak a word of dialogue.
How to Spot "Test" Designs in Modern One Piece
Oda hasn't stopped using this method. Even now, in the final saga, he creates "test" versions of villains like the Seraphim or the Five Elders.
- Check the SBS (Shonen Magazine’s Q&A section). Oda frequently shares "What if" designs there.
- Look at the One Piece Green and Red data books. They are gold mines for the one piece test character enthusiast.
- Compare the early manga chapters to the pilot one-shots. The differences in Garp and Shanks are jarring.
The "test" phase is where the soul of the character is found. It's the difference between a character that's just "cool" and a character that feels like a real person. When Oda draws a one piece test character, he’s asking himself: "Can I draw this person 10,000 times without getting bored?" If the answer is no, they get relegated to a background shot in Loguetown or a cover story.
Practical Steps for Fans and Artists
If you’re trying to understand character design through the lens of One Piece, don't just look at the finished product. That’s like looking at a finished cake and trying to guess the temperature of the oven.
- Hunt down the "Romance Dawn" V.1 and V.2. These are the literal test grounds for the entire franchise. You can find them in the Wanted! short story collection.
- Analyze the "Missing" Straw Hats. Look at the concept art featuring the "Skeleton Swordsman" (Brook) and the "Shipwright" (Franky) from 1997. Brook’s design barely changed, but Franky used to look like a generic pirate grunt.
- Study the Silhouettes. Oda’s biggest rule is that you should recognize a character just by their shadow. Most one piece test character drafts were rejected because their silhouettes were too similar to characters from other popular manga of the era.
The takeaway here is simple: nothing is ever perfect on the first try. The one piece test character archive proves that even the most successful creator in history had to fumble through some pretty weird, axe-wielding-cyborg-girl ideas before he hit gold.
If you want to truly appreciate the genius of the Egghead Island or Wano character designs, go back to the basics. Look at those shaky, hand-drawn prototypes from thirty years ago. It makes the current journey feel a lot more personal. You're not just watching a story; you're watching the evolution of an idea that started with a few "test" doodles in a cramped Tokyo apartment.
To get the most out of this piece of history, start by comparing the original 1997 Straw Hat lineup sketch (the one with the weird bird-human and the tiny botanist) with the current crew. Notice who stayed, who changed, and who was "recycled" into the world-building we see today. That is how you truly read between the lines of One Piece.