Honestly, if you haven't hummed "Rosa, Rosa, Ro-saaa" to yourself while doing the dishes, have you even lived? Doug Judy is basically the mascot of "Brooklyn Nine-Nine" fans everywhere. He’s the anti-villain we can’t help but root for, even when he’s literally stealing a car right in front of us.
Doug Judy first rolled into the 99th Precinct back in Season 1, Episode 12. He wasn't even the main target at first. He was just a witness who supposedly knew how to find the "Pontiac Bandit," a thief Jake Peralta had been chasing for years. It was the ultimate long con.
Jake, being Jake, fell for the charm. He fell hard.
The Mystery of the Pontiac Bandit
Most people forget that Doug Judy was only in nine episodes. That’s it. Just nine out of 153. It feels like he was there every week, doesn't it? That’s the "Craig Robinson effect." He has this gravity that makes every scene feel like a main event.
The guy is a legend in the Brooklyn underworld. We're talking over 200 stolen Pontiacs. He’s got 600 felonies on his rap sheet, including "dog fraud"—which basically means he sold a cat and told the guy it was a Pekingese.
Why Jake and Doug Just Work
It’s the bromance. Pure and simple. Jake Peralta is a cop obsessed with Die Hard. Doug Judy is a criminal who acts like he’s in Ocean’s Eleven. They both love pop culture, singing at inappropriate times, and making everything a bit more dramatic than it needs to be.
📖 Related: Despicable Me 2 Edith: Why the Middle Child is Secretly the Best Part of the Movie
They are essentially the same person on opposite sides of the law.
- Shared Vibe: They both have that "I don't really want to grow up" energy.
- The Musical Connection: From "The Fieval Song" to original R&B jams about Rosa Diaz.
- Mutual Respect: Judy actually respects Jake’s detective skills, even while he’s outsmarting him.
Every Season Needs a Doug Judy Episode
It became a tradition. Every year, fans waited for the "Judy Episode." It was like the Halloween Heists, but with more silk shirts and betrayals.
In Season 2, we got the "Pontiac Bandit Returns," where Doug helps Jake catch the Giggle Pig kingpin. Well, sort of. He mostly just used the police to clear his own path and then vanished again. Classic Judy.
By Season 3, they’re on a cruise ship. "The Cruise" is probably the peak of their friendship. Doug gets Jake and Amy free tickets because someone is trying to kill him. It turns into this weirdly domestic vacation where Jake tries to be professional but ends up doing karaoke.
The Evolution of a Criminal
As the show went on, Doug Judy started to change. He went from a guy who would leave Jake stranded in a basement to a guy who invited Jake to his wedding.
👉 See also: Death Wish II: Why This Sleazy Sequel Still Triggers People Today
Wait, remember that? Jake was genuinely hurt when he found out he wasn't invited to the wedding. He thought they were past the "cop and robber" phase. It turns out Doug was just trying to protect him from the other criminals at the party. It’s kinda sweet, in a totally illegal way.
What Happened in the Series Finale?
The end of the road for Doug Judy was in Season 8, Episode 5, titled "PB&J." It stands for Pontiac Bandit and Jake. It’s a road trip episode, but the stakes are higher.
Doug is being sent to prison in New Jersey for crimes outside of Jake’s jurisdiction. Jake decides to personally escort him. It’s their last hurrah. There are matching rings. There’s a trivia contest. There’s even a moment where they have to fight off henchmen hired from Craigslist.
The Great Escape
A lot of fans debate the ending of this episode. Judy escapes. Again.
But this time, it’s different. Two weeks later, Jake gets a call from Amsterdam. Doug is living his best life with legalized marijuana and stroopwafels. He tells Jake that he found a pen in his pocket after their final hug.
✨ Don't miss: Dark Reign Fantastic Four: Why This Weirdly Political Comic Still Holds Up
He used that pen to pick his handcuffs and vanish.
The twist? Jake knew the pen was there. He basically let his best friend go. It was the ultimate act of friendship from a cop who finally realized that some people are just too charismatic for a cage.
Things Most People Miss About Doug Judy
Did you know his name is a pun? "The Judge" was a nickname for the 1969 Pontiac GTO. So, Judge... Judy. It’s a layers-deep car joke that fits his character perfectly.
Also, his mother, Diane, is a recurring character who never actually appears on screen for long, but she’s the only person Doug is truly scared of. She thinks he works for "Black NASA." Honestly, that’s a spin-off I’d watch.
How to Relive the Pontiac Bandit Saga
If you’re looking to binge just the Judy episodes, here is the chronological list to follow:
- Season 1, Episode 12: "Pontiac Bandit"
- Season 2, Episode 10: "The Pontiac Bandit Returns"
- Season 3, Episode 13: "The Cruise"
- Season 4, Episode 11 & 12: "The Fugitive" (The two-parter)
- Season 5, Episode 22: "The Negotiation"
- Season 6, Episode 5: "A Tale of Two Bandits"
- Season 7, Episode 8: "The Takeback"
- Season 8, Episode 5: "PB&J"
Watch them in order. You’ll see the slow transition from Jake wanting to put him behind bars to Jake literally helping him flee the country. It’s one of the most consistent and rewarding character arcs in modern sitcom history.
Grab some snacks, find a streaming service, and get ready for the best bromance in Brooklyn. Just maybe keep an eye on your car keys.