Ever stood in front of a massive chalkboard or a sticky laminated book, staring at a list of smoked meats that all sound identical? It happens. You’re at a place with a name like One More Grill, and the pressure is on. You don't want to be the person who orders the "safe" chicken breast while everyone else is tearing into bark-heavy brisket that looks like it was kissed by a Texas angel. It's frustrating. You want the good stuff. But "the good stuff" changes depending on where you are and how that specific pitmaster handles their wood splits.
If you’re looking at the One More Grill menu, you’re likely hunting for that specific balance of char, smoke, and salt. Most people just glance at the prices and pick the middle-of-the-road option. Huge mistake. BBQ isn't about the price point; it's about the labor. You are paying for the 14 hours someone spent staring at a thermometer at 3:00 AM.
The Meat of the One More Grill Menu
Let's talk brisket. Honestly, it’s the king. If a grill menu doesn't have a solid brisket, why are we even here? At a high-quality spot like One More Grill, the brisket should be sliced to order. If you see them pulling pre-sliced meat out of a warming tray, run. Seriously. The oxidation hits the fat and turns it into something resembling wet cardboard within minutes. You want that "jiggle." If the slice of beef doesn't do a little dance when you poke it, it’s over-cooked.
The One More Grill menu usually features a "Fatty" or "Lean" option. Lean sounds healthy. Forget healthy. You're at a BBQ joint. The fatty cut (the point) is where the collagen has melted into a buttery silk. It’s the soul of the cow. If you're worried about your heart, eat a salad tomorrow. Today, you order the point.
Beyond the Brisket: Pork and Poultry
Pulled pork is the safety net. It’s hard to mess up, but it’s also easy to make boring. Look for "hand-pulled" on the menu. Machine-shredded pork has a mushy, baby-food texture that ruins the experience. You want chunks. You want those "burnt ends" of the pork shoulder mixed in—those little nuggets of concentrated spice and smoke.
Then there are the ribs. Most menus offer St. Louis style or Baby Back. St. Louis are meatier and flatter, which means more surface area for the rub. Baby backs are leaner and more curved. If the menu says "fall-off-the-bone," that’s actually a warning sign for BBQ purists. Real ribs should have a "tug." You should be able to bite it and see your tooth marks in the meat, not have the whole thing slide off like a wet noodle.
Sides Are Not Afterthoughts
Most people ignore the sides. Big mistake. Huge. A One More Grill menu is often defined by its mac and cheese. Is it baked with a crust? Is it a stovetop style with a liquid gold sauce? If there are breadcrumbs on top, they care about texture. That matters.
- Collard Greens: Look for smoked turkey or pork belly in the pot. The "pot likker" (the juice at the bottom) should be salty, acidic, and dark.
- Cornbread: Is it sweet like cake or savory with jalapeños? Ask the server. If it’s dry, it’s a waste of calories.
- Potato Salad: Mustard-based vs. Mayo-based is a religious war in the South.
The secret weapon on any grill menu is often the "daily special." This is where the chef experiments. Maybe it's smoked pork belly burnt ends tossed in a gochujang glaze. Maybe it’s a smoked prime rib that they only do on Fridays. If you see a whiteboard with a handwritten item, that’s usually what the staff is eating. Eat what they eat.
Why the One More Grill Menu Focuses on Wood Types
You might see "Hickory Smoked" or "Mesquite Grilled" written in small print. This isn't just marketing fluff. It changes the molecular structure of the flavor.
- Hickory: The classic. It’s pungent and "bacony."
- Oak: The clean burner. It gives a solid smoke ring without being overpowering.
- Fruitwoods (Apple/Cherry): These are sweet. Great for ribs and poultry.
- Mesquite: Be careful. It’s intense. If they use too much, your steak will taste like a campfire's gym socks.
A well-constructed menu balances these. You don't want a mesquite-smoked turkey; it’ll be too bitter. You want a light fruitwood for the bird and maybe some heavy hickory for the beef.
The Sauce Situation
Depending on where you are, the sauce is either a holy relic or an insult to the cook. In Central Texas, asking for sauce is basically telling the pitmaster his meat is dry. In Kansas City, the sauce is the whole point—thick, sweet, and sticky.
If the One More Grill menu offers a "Carolina Gold," expect mustard and vinegar. It’s tangy. It cuts through the fat of a pulled pork sandwich like a hot knife. If it’s an "Alabama White Sauce," it’s mayo-based with black pepper and vinegar, specifically designed for smoked chicken. Don't knock it until you try it. It sounds weird, but it’s a revelation.
Navigating the Prices and Portions
BBQ is expensive. There’s no way around it. When you see the prices on a One More Grill menu, remember that a raw brisket loses about 40% to 50% of its weight during the smoking process. You are paying for the finished weight and the 12 hours of wood.
The "Platter" is almost always the better value. Getting a quarter-pound of three different meats usually costs more than a "3-Meat Combo" that comes with sides. If you’re with a group, look for the "Family Meal" or "The Whole Pit" option. It’s messy, it’s excessive, and it’s the only way to truly sample the breadth of what the grill can do.
📖 Related: Alpha Kappa Alpha Alpha Chapter: Why the Howard University Legacy Still Matters
What Most People Get Wrong
People think "char" is "burnt." It’s not. In the BBQ world, we call that "bark." It’s a chemical reaction called the Maillard reaction, combined with the smoke particles sticking to the rub. It should be dark, almost black, but it shouldn't taste like an ash tray. It should be a crust of salt, pepper, and meat juices.
Another common error? Ordering the salmon at a BBQ joint. I mean, sure, sometimes it’s great. But if you’re at a place famous for its smoker, why are you ordering something that takes six minutes to cook on a flat top? Stick to the specialties.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Visit
If you want to master the One More Grill menu like a pro, follow these steps next time you walk through the door:
- Ask about the wood: "What are you burning today?" If they say "pellets," keep your expectations modest. If they say "Post Oak" or "Hickory," get excited.
- Check the bark: Look at other people's plates. Is the brisket dark and crusty or grey and wet? You want the former.
- Go early: The best items on a grill menu—especially burnt ends and ribs—sell out. If you show up at 7:00 PM, you’re getting the leftovers of the lunch rush.
- Order the "Fatty" cut: Don't be afraid of the rendered fat. It’s where the flavor lives.
- Sample the sauce first: Dip a corner of a fry or a piece of white bread into the sauce before dousing your meat. You might find the meat doesn't need it at all.
- Look for the smoke ring: A pinkish band just under the surface of the meat is a sign of a slow, low-temperature cook. It doesn't affect flavor much, but it proves the cook knows their craft.
The next time you sit down and open that One More Grill menu, don't just settle. Look for the labor. Look for the smoke. Order the things that take the most time to prepare, because in the world of grilling, time is the most important ingredient on the plate. Skip the chicken tenders. Get the brisket. Get the ribs. And for heaven's sake, get the extra napkins.