It’s the Saturday after Thanksgiving in 2025. You’re standing in a snowy Ann Arbor, and the air feels like it’s vibrating. The score is 27-9. Ohio State finally did it. They broke the curse. After four years of misery, Ryan Day walked off the field with a win, and for a moment, the world made sense again in Columbus.
But then you look at the trophy case.
Michigan won the national title in 2023. Ohio State won it in 2024. Think about that for a second. We are living in a reality where the "The Game" is no longer an elimination match, yet the hatred has somehow gotten worse. People think the 12-team playoff killed the stakes of Ohio State vs Michigan football. They’re wrong. Dead wrong. If anything, the new era has turned a regional border war into a year-round psychological thriller.
The Ryan Day Problem (And How He Solved It)
For the longest time, Ryan Day was the guy who inherited a Ferrari and didn't know how to change the oil. That’s what Michigan fans said, anyway. Going 1-4 against your rival is a death sentence in Ohio. Honestly, it doesn't matter if you have an .890 winning percentage. If you can't beat the team up north, you're basically just a very successful placeholder.
The 2024 loss was the rock bottom. Michigan was a 23-point underdog. They were unranked. They had a first-year coach in Sherrone Moore. And they still walked into the Shoe and won 13-10. It was embarrassing. There’s no other word for it. Cops had to use pepper spray to break up a brawl because Michigan players tried to plant a flag on the Block O. Again.
🔗 Read more: North Korea Soccer Team: What Most People Get Wrong
But 2025 changed the vibe. Julian Sayin, the Buckeyes’ young quarterback, played like a seasoned pro. He didn't blink. That 35-yard dime to Jeremiah Smith on fourth down? That was the moment the "soft" narrative died. Ohio State didn't just win; they bullied Michigan. They held them to 163 total yards. No touchdowns. Just pure, unadulterated defensive dominance.
The Connor Stalions Shadow
We have to talk about the "KGB." No, not the Russian spies. The network of signal-stealers that Connor Stalions allegedly ran. This is where the rivalry gets really toxic. Michigan fans see it as a "burger-gate" overreaction. Ohio State fans see it as the greatest cheating scandal in the history of the sport.
The NCAA didn't hold back in August 2025. They hit Michigan with four years of probation. They gave Stalions an eight-year show-cause and Jim Harbaugh a ten-year one. Sherrone Moore got suspended. The program had to cough up 10% of its football budget. That’s roughly $20 million.
But here’s the kicker: the wins stayed.
That drives Buckeye fans insane. You’ve got a segment of the population that believes 2021, 2022, and 2023 should have an asterisk the size of Lake Erie. Michigan fans just point at their 2023 ring and laugh. It’s a level of pettiness that you just don't find in the NFL. It’s personal. It’s about more than signals; it’s about the soul of the Big Ten.
Does the 12-Team Playoff Actually Matter?
Cardale Jones said it recently—the rivalry feels "watered down." He’s a legend, so people listen, but I sort of disagree. He thinks because both teams can make the playoffs, the game loses its "life or death" quality.
Pragmatically? Sure. In 2024, Ohio State lost to Michigan and still won the National Championship. They went on a "revenge tour" and took the trophy home. John Cooper would have killed for that opportunity in the 90s. Back then, losing to Michigan meant you were going to the Outback Bowl and watching the title game from your couch.
But try telling a fan in Columbus that the 2024 loss didn't matter because they won a trophy later. They’ll look at you like you have three heads. The "Gold Pants" tradition—where players get a tiny gold charm for beating Michigan—is still the highest honor in that locker room. You can't buy those. You have to earn them.
The Tactical Shift: Speed vs. Muscle
For a decade, Ohio State tried to out-athlete Michigan. They wanted to play basketball on grass. It worked when Urban Meyer was there because he had the horses. But when Harbaugh pivoted to "Smash," Ohio State didn't have an answer. They got ran over. Literally.
The 2025 game showed a different Ohio State. They used a 20-play drive that ate up 12 minutes of the clock. They became the hammer instead of the nail. This is the new reality of Ohio State vs Michigan football. It’s not about who has the five-star receivers anymore—though Jeremiah Smith is definitely a cheat code. It’s about who can survive a 15-round heavyweight fight in 20-degree weather.
Why the All-Time Record is Deceptive
- Michigan leads 62–53–6. * Most of those wins came before your grandparents were born.
- Since 2000, Ohio State has won 18 of the 25 matchups.
- The "Ten Year War" (Bo vs. Woody) ended 5-4-1 in favor of Michigan.
What’s Next for the Rivalry?
If you’re looking for a way to stay ahead of the curve, stop looking at the recruiting rankings for a second. Look at the coaching staff stability. Sherrone Moore is under a massive microscope now. The NCAA penalties are real, and the "us against the world" energy that fueled their 2023 run is hard to sustain when you're paying $20 million in fines.
Ohio State, meanwhile, has found its identity. They’ve embraced the pressure. They realized that they can't just be "talented." They have to be mean.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Season:
- Watch the Transfer Portal Trenches: The winner of this game is now decided by which team lands the best 300-pounders from smaller schools. Skill positions are flashy, but the line of scrimmage is where the 2025 game was won.
- Monitor the "Rematch" Potential: With the Big Ten eliminating divisions, we are highly likely to see these teams play in late November and then again seven days later in Indianapolis. Prepare your heart rate for back-to-back weekends of stress.
- Follow the NCAA Appeals: Michigan is still fighting some of the financial penalties. If those stick, it could affect their ability to retain top-tier assistant coaches, which is where the real gap usually opens up.
The rivalry has moved past the "who is better" phase and into the "who can endure" phase. Whether it's in the Big House or the Shoe, the 60 minutes on the field are just the tip of the iceberg. The real war is fought in the 364 days in between.