Honestly, if you’d told me in 2011 that we’d still be obsessing over a dual-screen handheld with a glasses-free 3D gimmick in 2026, I might’ve laughed. But here we are. The 3DS isn't just a piece of "vintage" plastic sitting in a drawer; it's currently at the center of a massive price bubble. People are dropping $300 on used consoles just to play the most popular 3DS games in their native format.
Why? Because the 3DS was the last time Nintendo felt truly weird.
It wasn't trying to be a home console like the Switch. It was a pockets-only ecosystem that birthed games you literally cannot play anywhere else without it feeling "wrong." When the eShop went dark and then the online servers finally blinked out, everyone thought the library would just fade into the background. Instead, the demand for physical cartridges has skyrocketed.
The Sales Titans vs. The Actual Favorites
When people talk about the "best" or "most popular" titles, they usually just look at the sales charts. And sure, the numbers are wild. Mario Kart 7 sits at the top with nearly 19 million copies sold. That’s a staggering amount of people throwing blue shells on the bus. But sales don't always tell the whole story of what people are actually playing right now.
Take the Pokémon situation. Pokémon X and Y sold over 16 million units, but if you go into any enthusiast forum today, the conversation is almost entirely about Pokémon Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon or the Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire remakes. The sales numbers show a snapshot of 2013, but the "popularity" in 2026 is driven by which games have the most content and the best 3D effects.
- Mario Kart 7: The undisputed king of sales (18.99 million).
- Pokémon X/Y: The jump to 3D that everyone bought but many now find "hollow."
- Animal Crossing: New Leaf: 13 million copies of pure, unadulterated mayor-sim bliss.
- New Super Mario Bros. 2: The one with all the gold coins that people bought, played once, and then forgot.
There is a weird gap between what sold well and what people actually cherish. Tomodachi Life, for example, sold 6.7 million copies. It’s a bizarre Mii-sim that makes no sense on paper but is currently one of the most sought-after physical games because there is nothing else like it on modern platforms.
🔗 Read more: Battlefield 1 PC Minimum Requirements: Can Your Old Rig Actually Handle the Great War?
Why Fire Emblem: Awakening Changed Everything
You can't talk about the most popular 3ds games without mentioning the game that literally saved a franchise. Before 2012, Fire Emblem was on life support. Nintendo told Intelligent Systems that if Fire Emblem: Awakening didn’t sell 250,000 units, the series was done.
It didn't just meet the goal; it smashed it.
It sold over 2.3 million copies and turned a niche tactical RPG into a global powerhouse. It introduced the "Casual Mode" (no permadeath) and the support system that allowed characters to marry and have kids. Purists might complain that it "waifu-ized" the series, but it’s the reason we have Fire Emblem Engage and Three Houses today. In 2026, it remains the gold standard for handheld strategy.
The Zelda Remasters: Better Than the Originals?
This is a hot take, but for a lot of us, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D is the definitive version of the game. Grezzo (the developer) didn't just slap a 3D coat of paint on it. They fixed the iron boots, stabilized the framerate to a smooth 30fps (up from the N64's chugging 20fps), and made the Water Temple actually playable without a guide.
Then you have A Link Between Worlds. This wasn't a remake; it was a spiritual successor to the SNES classic. It sold over 4 million copies because it finally let players tackle dungeons in any order. It felt like the first time Nintendo trusted the player to just... explore.
The Monster Hunter Boom
Before Monster Hunter World made the series a household name on PS4 and Xbox, the "true" hunters lived on the 3DS.
Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate is often cited by veterans as the peak of the series. It introduced verticality—climbing walls and jumping onto monsters—without the "clutter" of modern open-world mechanics. It’s a 100-hour game that fits in your pocket. Even now, players are using fan-run servers to keep the hunts alive because the loop of "kill, carve, craft" is so perfectly tuned for the 3DS hardware.
The Price Bubble: Why it’s Hard to Get These Games Now
If you’re looking to pick up a physical copy of Yo-kai Watch 3 or the Fire Emblem Fates Special Edition, I have bad news for your wallet. These are currently fetching $400 to $600 on the secondary market.
Part of the popularity surge in 2026 is actually artificial. Scalpers and "investors" have realized that the 3DS eShop closure created a supply vacuum. If you didn't buy it digitally by March 2023, you're stuck with physical copies that are getting rarer by the day. It’s a shame, really. Some of the best experiences, like Kid Icarus: Uprising, are becoming inaccessible to the average kid who just wants to play a cool shooter.
Replayability: What Stays Fresh?
When you're looking for value, some games just never get old. Animal Crossing: New Leaf is still arguably better than the Switch's New Horizons in terms of personality. The villagers feel more like real people (and are occasionally mean to you, which we love).
Super Mario 3D Land is another one. It’s the perfect "five-minute" game. The levels are short, the 3D effect actually helps with platforming, and the post-game content doubles the length of the experience. It’s pure Nintendo magic.
What to Do if You Want to Start a 3DS Collection
Look, the market is a mess right now. If you're chasing the most popular 3ds games, don't just go for the $500 rarities.
- Check Local Shops: Stop looking at eBay. Thrift stores and small-town game shops often still have Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon or Super Smash Bros. for $20.
- Focus on the "Selects": Nintendo released a line of "Nintendo Selects" (with the red border). These sold millions and are still relatively cheap. Games like The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds can still be found for under $40 if you're patient.
- Consider the 2DS: If you don't care about the 3D effect, the "wedge" 2DS is the most comfortable way to play long RPGs like Bravely Default. It's cheaper and indestructible.
The 3DS era was a weird, experimental time for gaming. It wasn't perfect, but the library has a "soul" that is increasingly hard to find in the era of $70 live-service titles. Whether you're a returning vet or a new collector, these games are worth the effort of tracking down. Just... maybe wait for the current price bubble to pop before buying that copy of Barbie: Groom and Glam Pups for two grand. Yes, that is a real thing. No, it is not worth it.