We need to talk about the Spencer Reid-shaped hole in our lives. Honestly, if you’ve spent any time on Paramount+ lately watching the Criminal Minds: Evolution reboot, you know exactly what I’m getting at. The show is gritty, the stakes are high, but something feels fundamentally "off." It’s like a family dinner where your favorite cousin just... didn't show up. That cousin is, of course, Dr. Spencer Reid.
Matthew Gray Gubler spent 15 years playing the socially awkward, boy-genius profiler. He wasn’t just a character; he was the soul of the BAU. When the original series ended in 2020, fans assumed he’d be back for the revival. But then the seasons started rolling by. No Reid. Just a mention of him being on a "special assignment" and a very empty desk.
The Truth About the Scheduling Nightmare
You’ve probably heard the PR line about "scheduling conflicts" a million times. It’s the standard Hollywood excuse for "we couldn't make it work." But in the case of Matthew Gray Gubler Criminal Minds fans are basically forensic investigators themselves, and they’ve been digging for the real story.
Basically, the jump from network TV to streaming changed the game. When the show was on CBS, they filmed for ten months out of the year. Now, for the reboot, they squeeze everything into about four months. If you’re a busy guy like Gubler—who is a published author, a painter, and a director—hitting that tiny four-month window is a logistical nightmare.
And let's be real: Gubler has been busy. Between his hit children’s book Rumple Buttercup and his new upcoming series Einstein, his plate isn't just full; it’s overflowing. He’s currently set to lead that new CBS procedural Einstein, where he plays the great-grandson of Albert Einstein. It’s another genius role, which feels very "on brand," but it also means he’s tied to a whole different production schedule.
That Weird Season 3 Cameo
Finally, in early 2025, we got what we wanted. Sorta.
The internet nearly broke when it was leaked that Gubler would finally appear in Evolution Season 3. We all waited. We watched. And then... it was over in a blink. He showed up for a funeral scene (RIP Will LaMontagne Jr., we're still processing that too) and had almost no dialogue. It was a "blink and you'll miss it" moment.
A.J. Cook, who plays JJ and is actually best friends with Gubler in real life, later explained that the lack of dialogue was a specific choice. They wanted the moment to feel heavy and emotional without needing a massive monologue. While that sounds nice and "artistic," for a fandom that hadn't seen Reid in years, it felt like getting a single fry when you ordered a whole meal.
The Horror Master Behind the Camera
One thing a lot of casual viewers forget is that Matthew Gray Gubler wasn't just an actor on the show. He was one of their most prolific and, frankly, most twisted directors. He directed 12 episodes in total, and they are easily the most "out there" installments of the series.
If an episode involved creepy dolls, human marionettes, or Victorian-style ghost stories, there was a 90% chance Gubler was the one calling the shots.
- "The Lesson" (Season 8, Episode 10): This is the one where the UnSub turns people into living puppets. It’s pure nightmare fuel.
- "Mr. Scratch" (Season 10, Episode 21): This episode introduced one of the show's most iconic villains and used shadow-monster imagery that felt more like a horror movie than a police procedural.
- "Mosley Lane" (Season 5, Episode 16): This was his directorial debut, and it’s still considered one of the saddest, most haunting episodes in the show's history.
He has this specific "Gubler-esque" style that mixes whimsical charm with deep, psychological dread. Without him directing in the reboot, the show feels a bit more "standard" and a bit less "weird."
Why We Still Can’t Let Go
Reid was the person we grew up with. We saw him go from a 24-year-old kid with a bad haircut to a seasoned agent who survived being kidnapped, framed for murder, and losing the love of his life (RIP Maeve, we're still not over that either).
The chemistry between the cast is real. Gubler is a registered minister and actually officiated Paget Brewster’s wedding. That kind of bond translates to the screen. When you see the team on Evolution now, they look like they’re missing a limb.
🔗 Read more: Why My Boo by Ghost Town DJs Still Rules Every Cookout and Viral Challenge
There’s also the "Einstein" factor. His new show was originally supposed to drop in the 2025-2026 season, but CBS pushed it back to 2026-2027. This delay actually gives fans a tiny sliver of hope. If he isn't filming Einstein right this second, could he finally have time for a multi-episode arc in the BAU?
The Realistic Future for Dr. Reid
Honestly, don't expect him to come back as a series regular. Those days are probably over. Gubler has always been an "artist first" kind of guy, and he’s clearly enjoying his freedom to paint and write.
But the door isn't closed. Showrunner Erica Messer has been vocal about the fact that Reid’s desk is still there, waiting for him. The most likely scenario is that we get "meaningful" guest appearances. Think along the lines of how the show handled Felicity Huffman’s character—someone who comes in for a specific case, has a real impact, and then leaves.
If you're looking for your Gubler fix while waiting for more news, the best move is to dive back into the "Gubler-directed" episodes on streaming. They hold up incredibly well and remind you why the show became such a juggernaut in the first place.
Keep an eye on the CBS 2026 fall schedule for Einstein updates, as that will be the ultimate indicator of his availability. For now, we just have to be okay with the "special assignment" excuse and keep our fingers crossed that the stars—and the schedules—finally align for a real homecoming.
To stay updated on his specific projects, your best bet is to follow his personal site (which looks like something out of a 1990s fever dream) or check the official Paramount+ production logs for Season 4 of Evolution.