It was the end of an era that many in the North Shore didn't see coming, or at least didn't want to admit was happening. For a decade, the Mariano's Northfield Northfield IL location at 1822 Willow Road served as the caffeine-fueled, gelato-topped heartbeat of the village. Then, in June 2024, the doors locked for good.
Honestly, the closure left a massive hole in the local routine. You've probably driven past that empty parking lot recently and wondered why a store that always seemed bustling just vanished. It wasn't just a grocery store; it was where you'd grab a Vero coffee before a commute or linger over a "36 feet of meat" display that felt more like a museum of protein than a deli counter.
The Rise and Sudden Exit of 1822 Willow Road
When Mariano’s first took over the old Dominick’s shell back in 2014, the excitement was palpable. Northfield Village President Fred Gougler was famously thrilled about how quickly they opened. Bob Mariano, the man himself, had basically come home to the North Shore, having learned the ropes at Dominick's years prior.
The store was a pivot point. It turned grocery shopping from a chore into a "foodie experience." You didn't just buy milk; you watched pastry chefs ice cupcakes or sampled cheese from a "cave" that felt suspiciously like a high-end wine cellar.
But things changed.
By June 2024, the lease was winding down. Kroger, the parent company, began a nationwide tightening of its belt, closing dozens of underperforming or strategically redundant stores. The Mariano's Northfield Northfield IL location was caught in that sweep. Village officials confirmed the exit was ahead of the actual lease expiration, leaving many residents scrambling to find a new "third place."
Why it wasn't just another Kroger store
Most people assume all Mariano’s are created equal. They aren't. The Northfield spot was unique because it was a conversion, not a ground-up build. It had a specific layout—some called it "bizarre," others "charming"—that felt tighter and more intimate than the massive flagship stores in Glenview or Northbrook.
It also had a distinct community tie. Before the first loaf of bread was even baked in 2014, the store cut a $2,500 check for the Northfield Township Food Pantry. That kind of local buy-in is hard to replicate with a generic big-box brand.
What’s Actually Happening With the Space Now?
If you’ve been following the local planning commission meetings, things are finally getting interesting. As of late 2025 and heading into early 2026, a new player has entered the chat. An unnamed grocery tenant—rumored to focus on "organic, natural, and better-for-you" products—has applied for a special-use permit at the old Mariano's site.
Swanson Development Group, who bought the property in 2023, is looking to subdivide the land to create an "outlot." Basically, they want to add more retail or a smaller shop near the road to make the whole property more viable.
🔗 Read more: The Sran Family Orchards Chapter 11 Filing: What Went Wrong and What Happens Now
- The Projected Timeline: Don't expect to be buying kale there next week. The current application points to a "late 2026 or spring 2027" opening.
- The Vibe: The new tenant claims they will focus on personalized service that "large chain stores simply can't match."
- The Impact: Village Manager Stacy Canning has been vocal about how losing a grocer at this location is a "devastating blow" to the Village Center. They are fast-tracking the process to get the lights back on.
The Real Reason the Northfield Store Felt Different
Shopping at Mariano's Northfield Northfield IL was a weirdly social event. You’d run into your neighbor at the sushi bar or see the same barista every morning at the Vero counter.
The store survived the initial Kroger acquisition in 2015, but long-time patrons noticed a slow shift. Some reviewers on platforms like Yelp and Google started complaining about staffing shortages and long checkout lines toward the end. It’s a common story in the post-pandemic retail world. One day the gelato machine is broken, the next day the handheld baskets disappear, and suddenly the "magic" starts to fade.
Yet, even with the "downward spiral" some critics mentioned, the loss was felt deeply. Why? Because the alternatives—Jewel-Osco or the more expensive Whole Foods—don't quite hit that middle ground of "luxury for the masses" that Bob Mariano originally envisioned.
Community Stats and Tidbits
- Size: The building is roughly 47,732 square feet.
- Land: It sits on over three acres of prime Northfield real estate.
- History: Dominick's occupied the spot for 38 years before Mariano's had its 10-year run.
Actionable Insights for Northfield Residents
Since the Mariano's Northfield Northfield IL location is no longer an option for your weekly haul, you've got to pivot. Here is the move:
- For the Mariano’s Die-Hards: The Northbrook location at 784 Skokie Blvd is your closest bet. It’s a bit larger and still maintains the wine bar and live music on Fridays.
- For the "Fresh & Local" Crowd: Keep an eye on the Northfield Village Board agendas. The new tenant's identity is the worst-kept secret in town, and public hearings are the best way to voice what you want in the new store (like, maybe, more than five small carts?).
- Support the Pantry: Since Mariano's was a big donor to the Northfield Township Food Pantry, consider making a direct donation. The "grocery gap" in the village center often means local food banks feel the squeeze too.
The era of grabbing a smoothie and a rotisserie chicken at 1822 Willow Road is over for now, but the site isn't going to stay a ghost town. The village needs that anchor. Whether the new "organic" store can capture the same cult following that Mariano's had in its prime remains to be seen.
If you're missing the specific rewards or fuel points you earned there, make sure your Kroger account is linked to the Northbrook or Glenview locations so you don't lose those balances. Change is annoying, but in the North Shore, it usually leads to something even more upscale.