Manchester United is a weird place. Honestly, there’s no other way to put it. You’ve got this massive, global institution that basically lives in the shadow of two men—Sir Matt Busby and Sir Alex Ferguson—and every other human being who has ever tried to sit in that dugout has eventually looked like they’ve aged a decade in six months. It's a revolving door.
As of January 2026, the list of Manchester United managers has just grown again. Michael Carrick is back in the hot seat, this time as an interim until the end of the season, after the club decided the Ruben Amorim experiment wasn't working. It’s a cycle. We’ve seen it with Mourinho, we saw it with Ten Hag, and we even saw it with club legends like Solskjaer.
The Early Days and the First Success
Before the glitz and the billion-dollar valuations, United was Newton Heath. The first "managers" weren't even called that; they were club secretaries. A.H. Albut and James West did the heavy lifting early on, but the first guy to actually win something significant was Ernest Mangnall.
He took over in 1903.
Mangnall was a bit of a character. He led the club to its first-ever league title in 1908 and followed it up with an FA Cup in 1909. But here’s the kicker: he left United in 1912 to join Manchester City. Yeah, the local rivals. Imagine that happening today. Social media would literally melt.
The Busby Era: Rebuilding from Tragedy
After a bunch of forgettable names like John Bentley and Jack Robson, we get to 1945. Enter Sir Matt Busby.
Busby didn't just manage a team; he built a philosophy. He was the one who insisted on the "Busby Babes," a group of homegrown kids who played with a flair that the post-war world hadn't really seen. Then 1958 happened. The Munich Air Disaster. It’s the darkest chapter in the club’s history, losing eight players and almost losing Busby himself.
Most people would have quit.
👉 See also: Steelers News: Justin Fields and the 2026 Quarterback Reality
Busby stayed. He rebuilt. A decade later, in 1968, he stood at Wembley and watched Bobby Charlton and George Best lift the European Cup. It was the first time an English club had ever won it. When people talk about "The United Way," they’re talking about Matt Busby. He retired in 1969, came back for a bit in 1970 to steady things, and then finally stepped away.
The Dark Ages of the 70s and 80s
Replacing a legend is impossible. Wilf McGuinness tried it. Frank O'Farrell tried it. Both failed. Tommy Docherty—"The Doc"—actually got them relegated in 1974 but brought them straight back up and won the FA Cup in 1977. He was sacked shortly after because of an affair with the physio’s wife. Classic 70s drama.
Dave Sexton and Ron Atkinson followed. "Big Ron" won two FA Cups and brought in some serious talent like Bryan Robson, but he could never quite clinch the league title. By 1986, the board had seen enough.
Sir Alex Ferguson: 26 Years of Dominance
When Ferguson arrived from Aberdeen in November 1986, he wasn't an instant success. In fact, by 1990, fans were holding up banners asking him to leave. Then a Mark Robins goal in the FA Cup (allegedly) saved his job, and the rest is history.
26 years.
38 trophies.
13 Premier League titles.
Ferguson was a machine. He won the Treble in 1999, dominated the 2000s, and retired in 2013 after winning one last league title. His win percentage was 59.67%, which is impressive given he took charge of 1,500 games. Every manager on the list of Manchester United managers since then has been compared to him, and none have come close to that kind of longevity.
The Post-Ferguson Chaos (2013–2026)
Since 2013, the club has been through more managers than a Kardashian has had outfits.
✨ Don't miss: South Dakota State Football vs NDSU Football Matches: Why the Border Battle Just Changed Forever
David Moyes was "The Chosen One," but he didn't even last a full season. He won the Community Shield, but that was about it. Then came Louis van Gaal, the "Iron Tulip." He won the FA Cup in 2016 and was sacked literally hours later.
Jose Mourinho is technically the most successful manager of the modern era in terms of win percentage ($58.33%$). He won the League Cup and the Europa League in 2017. He famously said finishing second with that squad was one of his greatest achievements. At the time, we laughed. Now? He kind of had a point.
Then we had the emotional era of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. He brought the good vibes back, had some "miralce" nights in Paris, but never won a trophy. He was sacked in 2021 after a horror run of results.
Recent Turmoil: Ten Hag and Amorim
Erik ten Hag came in with a massive reputation from Ajax. He won two trophies—the Carabao Cup and the FA Cup—but the league form was a disaster. He spent over £600 million and still couldn't find a settled midfield. He was finally sacked in late 2024.
Then came the "tactical genius" Ruben Amorim. People were hyped. He brought his 3-4-3 system from Sporting CP, but it just didn't click in the Premier League. He lasted just over a year, getting the sack in early January 2026.
The Current Standing (January 2026)
As it stands right now, Michael Carrick is the interim head coach. He’s the 25th full-time or interim appointment in the club's history. United is sitting 7th in the league, 17 points behind the leaders, and out of both domestic cups.
Man Utd Manager Performance at a Glance
| Manager | Win % | Major Trophies |
|---|---|---|
| Sir Alex Ferguson | 59.67 | 38 |
| Jose Mourinho | 58.33 | 3 |
| Erik ten Hag | 56.25 | 2 |
| Ole Gunnar Solskjaer | 54.17 | 0 |
| Sir Matt Busby | 49.43 | 11 |
| Ruben Amorim | 38.10 | 0 |
Wait, why is Busby’s win percentage lower than Ten Hag’s? It’s because he managed for decades, through the 50s, 60s, and the rebuilding years after Munich. Win percentage doesn't always tell the whole story, but it does show how high the "floor" has become for modern managers.
🔗 Read more: Shedeur Sanders Draft Room: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Why Does This Job Break Everyone?
The pressure at Old Trafford is just different. You’ve got a massive stadium, a global fanbase that expects a trophy every year, and a hierarchy that—until the recent INEOS takeover—seemed more interested in selling noodles than winning games.
Managers often struggle with:
- The Shadow of the Past: You're always being compared to Fergie.
- Player Power: Huge salaries make it hard to shift underperforming stars.
- Tactical Identity: United fans demand "attacking football," but most modern managers are pragmatic.
What's Next for the Red Devils?
The club is currently looking for a permanent solution for the 2026/27 season. Names like Oliver Glasner are being thrown around, but whoever takes the job needs more than just a good CV. They need a thick skin.
If you're tracking the history of the club, keep an eye on how INEOS restructures the recruitment side. The manager can only do so much if the players being bought don't fit the system. For now, Carrick is the man tasked with saving what's left of this season.
To truly understand the trajectory of the club, you have to look at the gaps between the successful eras. It took 26 years to find a replacement for Busby. We are now 13 years into the post-Ferguson era. History suggests it might take a while longer before the right name is added to the list of Manchester United managers who actually stay for the long haul.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts:
- Watch the Youth Integration: Historically, successful United managers (Busby, Ferguson) rely on the academy. Watch if Carrick or the next hire actually plays the kids.
- Check the Win Percentage over 100 Games: Most post-Fergie managers start strong and then collapse. A win rate above $55%$ after two full seasons is usually the benchmark for "safety."
- Follow the Sporting Director: The hire of Dan Ashworth and the INEOS changes mean the manager has less power than Ferguson had. The "Head Coach" model is the new reality.