If you haven’t checked the box scores in a week, you might not even recognize the team wearing the blue and white. Seriously. Between a sudden rash of injuries and some mid-season tinkering by Brad Treliving, the maple leafs hockey roster is currently a fascinating, slightly chaotic mix of $13 million superstars and guys who were probably just happy to have a locker in September.
It’s January 2026. The snow is piling up outside Scotiabank Arena, and inside, the lineup is shifting daily.
We all know the heavy hitters like Auston Matthews and William Nylander. They’re the engine. But right now, the engine is missing a few spark plugs. Nylander actually missed the last game against Winnipeg with a lower-body issue he picked up in Vegas. It’s not supposed to be long-term, but in Toronto, every time a star player limps, the entire city holds its breath.
The Core: Still Matthews, but different
Auston Matthews is still the captain. He’s sitting at 24 goals through 48 games, which is "off-pace" for him but elite for literally anyone else. He is still the guy. He’s playing over 20 minutes a night, winning nearly 59% of his draws, and basically carrying the defensive burden of the top line while the wingers rotate like a revolving door.
Speaking of wingers, Matthew Knies has truly arrived. He’s at 40 points. Watching him hunt pucks in the corner is one of the few things that hasn't changed this season. He’s huge, he’s fast, and he’s finally learned how to use that 230-pound frame to create space for #34.
Then there’s the John Tavares situation. Honestly, people were ready to write him off when his $11 million contract ended, but he’s back on a much more manageable $4.38 million deal. He has 42 points. He’s not as fast as he used to be, but his hockey IQ is still off the charts. He’s basically the ultimate "dad" of this roster.
🔗 Read more: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The New Faces and the "Invisibles"
The real story of the current maple leafs hockey roster is the depth. Have you been watching Matias Maccelli? He was brought in to provide some secondary scoring, and while he’s not a burner, his vision is incredible. He’s slotted in on that second line with Tavares, and they’ve developed this weirdly effective chemistry.
And don't look now, but Easton Cowan is actually sticking. There was so much debate about whether he was ready for the NHL. Well, 15 points later, the kid from Mount Brydges is proving the scouts right. He’s tenacious. He plays like his hair is on fire.
The bottom six is a bit more of a "lunch pail" crew:
- Nicolas Roy: The big center they snagged to stabilize the third line.
- Scott Laughton: Pure sandpaper. He’s the guy you hate to play against but love to have on your bench.
- Bobby McMann: He’s leading the team in penalty minutes (40), which tells you exactly what kind of game he's playing.
The Defensive Blueprint (and the M.I.A. List)
The blue line is where things get really dicey. Chris Tanev is currently on IR with a groin injury. That’s a massive hole. Tanev is the guy who blocks 90-mph shots with his face and doesn’t even blink. Without him, the minutes have shifted heavily to Morgan Rielly and Brandon Carlo.
Jake McCabe has been the unsung hero of the season. He’s a +20. In a league where plus-minus is often mocked, that number actually means something for a guy who starts most of his shifts in the defensive zone. He’s paired with Oliver Ekman-Larsson, who has somehow found a fountain of youth in Toronto. OEL has 31 points and is still quarterbacking the power play when Rielly needs a breather.
💡 You might also like: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
But look at the third pair. Simon Benoit and Troy Stecher. It’s… fine. It’s gritty. It’s not going to win any beauty contests, but they keep the puck out of the high-danger areas. Usually.
The Crease: Woll’s World
Joseph Woll is the undisputed #1. Finally. He has 11 wins and has looked steady even when the defense in front of him collapses. Anthony Stolarz is currently out with an upper-body injury, which means we’re seeing a lot of Dennis Hildeby.
"The Woll" is a great nickname, but the team needs him to stay healthy. If he goes down, the playoff aspirations for this specific maple leafs hockey roster start to look a lot shakier.
The Salary Cap Tetris
Brad Treliving is basically playing a high-stakes game of Tetris with the cap. The NHL cap limit for this 2025-26 season is $95.5 million. Toronto is right up against it.
They’ve got about $25 million in "dead" space or IR relief at any given time, but the fact that they managed to keep Marner (who is currently the subject of about a billion trade rumors) and Matthews while filling out the bottom of the roster is a feat of engineering. Or magic. Maybe both.
📖 Related: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
What to watch for next
If you're tracking this team, the next two weeks are huge. They’ve been hovering around the 6th spot in the Atlantic Division. They aren't dominant, but they are "grind-it-out" tough.
Keep an eye on the injury reports for Nylander and Tanev. If those two don't get back into the lineup by the end of January, the Leafs might be forced into the trade market earlier than they’d like. They need another right-shot defenseman. Everyone knows it. The fans know it, the media knows it, and you can bet the opposing scouts know it too.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Check the 11:30 AM skate reports: With the current injury wave, the lines are changing almost every morning. Twitter (or X) is your friend here.
- Watch the waiver wire: The Leafs are tight on the cap, so any move for a backup goalie or 7th defenseman will likely involve someone being put on waivers.
- Monitor the Olympic Break: Remember, the 2026 Winter Olympics in Milano Cortina are coming up. Matthews and Knies are locks for Team USA; Nylander (if healthy) for Sweden. This roster is going to be exhausted by March.
The maple leafs hockey roster isn't perfect, but it's built for a Craig Berube style of hockey: heavy, hard to play against, and reliant on elite finishing. It’s going to be a wild ride to the trade deadline.