Let's be real for a second. If you grew up in Northeast Ohio, the list of browns qbs isn't just a list of names. It’s a psychological profile. It is a record of every Sunday afternoon spent yelling at a screen while a guy in a jersey you just bought two weeks ago throws a ball directly into the hands of a waiting linebacker.
Basically, it’s been a ride.
Most people think the "Quarterback Jersey" with the long duct-tape tail of names is the whole story. But there’s a lot more nuance to the history than just the "Factory of Sadness" era. We have a weird history that splits almost perfectly between legendary, Hall of Fame dominance and a twenty-year stretch that felt like a social experiment in frustration.
The Golden Age: Before the Chaos
Believe it or not, there was a time when Cleveland didn't just have a quarterback; they had the quarterback.
Otto Graham is the gold standard. Between 1946 and 1955, the guy led the Browns to ten straight championship games. Ten. He won seven of them. He has a winning percentage of .810, which is honestly just absurd. If you’re looking at the all-time list of browns qbs, Graham sits at the top not just for the stats, but for the sheer inevitability of winning.
Then came Frank Ryan. He’s the guy who delivered the 1964 NFL Championship. He was a math professor, literally. He had a PhD and could probably calculate the trajectory of a deep ball better than anyone in league history. After him, Brian Sipe and the "Kardiac Kids" took over the late 70s. Sipe won the NFL MVP in 1980, throwing for over 4,000 yards when that was a massive, rare feat.
👉 See also: Yesterday’s NFL Game Scores: Why the Texans’ Defensive Masterpiece Just Changed Everything
And then there’s Bernie Kosar.
If you ask any Browns fan over the age of 40, Bernie is the king. He wasn't the most athletic guy—he had a sidearm delivery that looked like he was skipping stones—but he was brilliant. He led the team to three AFC Championship games in the late 80s. We don't talk about "The Drive" or "The Fumble" because they still hurt, but Kosar was the reason we were even in those games.
The Expansion Era: A Revolving Door
When the team came back in 1999, things got weird.
Tim Couch was the first pick of the new era. Honestly, he got a raw deal. He was sacked 56 times in his rookie season. Imagine being 22 years old and getting hit by a 300-pound defensive tackle once every ten minutes for three hours every Sunday. He still managed to get the team to the playoffs in 2002, even if he couldn't play in the game because of a broken leg.
The years following Couch are a bit of a blur of "wait, who was that again?" names:
✨ Don't miss: Kobe Bryant Graphic Tee: Why That Old Shirt Still Matters
- Kelly Holcomb (The guy who threw for 429 yards in a playoff loss)
- Jeff Garcia (A Pro Bowler who just couldn't find the rhythm in Cleveland)
- Charlie Frye (The local kid everyone wanted to succeed)
- Derek Anderson (The 2007 Pro Bowl season felt like magic, until it wasn't)
- Brady Quinn (The hometown hero who couldn't quite transition to the pro game)
The list of browns qbs in the 2010s feels like a fever dream. Remember Brandon Weeden? He was a 28-year-old rookie. Then there was Johnny Manziel. The hype was deafening, the "money man" hand sign was everywhere, and the actual football... well, it was short-lived. Between 2014 and 2017, the team went through starters like most people go through socks. Josh McCown, Robert Griffin III, and the winless season of DeShone Kizer.
The Baker Mayfield Era and the Current Landscape
In 2018, Baker Mayfield changed the energy.
He woke up feeling dangerous. He gave the city its first playoff win in 26 years against the Steelers in their own house. It felt like the cycle was finally broken. He finished his Cleveland career with 29 wins, which, for a modern Browns quarterback, is actually quite high on the list.
But as we know, things changed. The trade for Deshaun Watson in 2022 was supposed to be the "final piece." It has been complicated, to say the least. Injuries and suspensions have made his tenure inconsistent.
Unexpectedly, the 2023 and 2024 seasons brought some of the most "Cleveland" moments imaginable. Joe Flacco, at 38 years old, came off his couch to lead the team to the playoffs. It was surreal. Seeing an ex-Raven wearing orange and brown and throwing bombs to Amari Cooper was not on anyone's bingo card.
💡 You might also like: FC Seoul contra Fútbol Club Barcelona: Lo que realmente pasó en aquel amistoso de 2004
As of early 2026, the room has shifted again. After a series of injuries to Watson, the team has leaned on youth. Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel are the names currently etched into the modern list of browns qbs. Sanders, specifically, has shown that "it" factor—a certain swagger that the city hasn't seen since the early Baker years. He recently set a record for the most passing yards by a Browns rookie in a single game (364 yards against the Titans in late 2025).
Why the List Still Matters
People joke about the names, but the list is actually a map of the team's philosophy. For years, they tried to find a savior in the first round. Then they tried "bridge" veterans. Now, they seem to be building around high-ceiling athletes with modern skill sets.
If you’re tracking the list of browns qbs for fantasy or just out of morbid curiosity, here are the cold, hard facts:
- Most Wins: Brian Sipe (57) and Otto Graham (57)
- Most Starts: Brian Sipe (112)
- Longest Tenure (Modern): Tim Couch and Baker Mayfield (tied at 59 starts)
- The "Iron Man" Award: In the 2023 season alone, the Browns used 5 different starting QBs.
Honestly, being a Browns fan requires a certain level of toughness. You've seen Pro Bowlers fail and backups become legends for exactly three weeks.
The next step for anyone following this team is to look past the "curse" narrative. Pay attention to how the front office is drafting now. The transition from the "pocket passer" archetype (like Kosar) to mobile, dual-threat guys (like Sanders) is the biggest shift in the franchise's history. Watch the 2026 preseason closely; the competition between the veteran room and the young guns is going to define whether this list finally stops growing at such a frantic pace.
Keep an eye on the injury reports—if history tells us anything, the next name on the list is usually only one sack away.
Actionable Insights for Fans
- Track the "First Start" Stat: Historically, Browns QBs making their first NFL start are 1-17 since 1999. If a rookie is debuting, manage your expectations for that specific game.
- Value the Win-Loss Record: In the expansion era, only Brian Hoyer (10-6) and Joe Flacco (5-4) have significant winning percentages. Wins are the only stat that truly changes the "culture" in Cleveland.
- Watch the Roster Depth: The Browns currently carry three potential starters. In this system, the "backup" is often the most important player on the roster by Week 10.
- Historical Perspective: Don't let the 2000s era overshadow guys like Milt Plum or Bill Nelsen. The Browns have a rich history of elite quarterbacking; the recent struggle is the anomaly, not the rule.