You're driving south from Miami, the skyline is fading in the rearview, and you finally see that sign: "Welcome to the Florida Keys." Your windows are down. You can almost smell the salt air and the key lime pie. Then, everything stops. Red brake lights as far as the eye can see. Welcome to Key Largo traffic. It is the rite of passage nobody wants but almost everyone gets.
Honestly, it sucks.
But here is the thing about the gateway to the Keys—it is a literal bottleneck. You have thousands of people trying to squeeze through a single entry point. There isn't a secret backroad. There is no magic tunnel under the mangroves. You’ve basically got two choices: the 18-Mile Stretch or Card Sound Road. If you pick the wrong one at the wrong time, you’re looking at an extra hour of staring at the bumper of a rented Mustang.
The Reality of the 18-Mile Stretch
Most people take the Stretch (U.S. 1). It’s the direct shot from Florida City into Key Largo. Historically, this road was a nightmare of head-on collisions, which is why the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) spent years installing those concrete barriers. It’s safer now. Much safer. But safety didn't solve the volume problem.
On a Friday afternoon, especially during high season from January through April, the Stretch becomes a parking lot. It’s a physical limitation. The road funnels from a multi-lane highway down into a more constrained flow. If there is a fender bender at the Jewfish Creek Bridge, you are stuck. There is nowhere to turn around. You are essentially on a concrete ribbon surrounded by water and wetlands.
According to data from the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, weekends are predictably the worst. Specifically, southbound traffic peaks between 2:00 PM and 8:00 PM on Fridays. If you are hitting that road at 5:30 PM on a Friday during spring break? Good luck. You’ll need a long podcast. Maybe three.
💡 You might also like: Why Tequila Sunset South Padre Island TX is the Only Spot That Actually Matters After 5 PM
Why Card Sound Road Isn't Always the Answer
Local "hackers" will tell you to take Card Sound Road (CR 905). You take it off flicking away from U.S. 1 in Florida City, pay a small toll at the bridge, and wind through the mangroves. It’s beautiful. It’s old Florida. It also takes you way out of the way.
Unless the Stretch is totally backed up due to a major accident, Card Sound Road usually adds about 15 to 20 minutes to your trip. It dumps you out much further north in Key Largo, near the gated community of Ocean Reef. If your hotel is at Mile Marker 100, taking Card Sound might actually be a mistake. Plus, if everyone else has the same "secret" idea, that two-lane road crawls. It’s a gamble. Sometimes you win, sometimes you’re just driving more miles to sit in the same line of cars.
What Most People Get Wrong About Key Largo Traffic
People think the traffic is just about tourists. It’s not. It’s the "Day Trippers" and the workforce.
Key Largo is the hub for people who work in the upper Keys but live on the mainland because housing prices in Monroe County are astronomical. You have a massive ebb and flow of service workers, construction crews, and delivery trucks every single morning and evening.
Morning rush hour? It’s northbound.
Evening rush hour? It’s southbound.
If you are a tourist trying to leave the Keys on a Sunday afternoon, you are fighting the exodus. Everyone who spent the weekend in Islamorada or Marathon is heading home to Miami or Fort Lauderdale at the exact same time. The backup at the light on Transylvania Avenue or near the Gilbert’s Resort turn-off can be legendary.
The Mile Marker System is Your Best Friend
You have to learn to speak "Keys." We don’t use addresses much here. We use Mile Markers (MM). Key Largo starts around MM 107 and ends roughly at the Tavernier Creek Bridge near MM 90.
Traffic density changes depending on where the "center of town" is. The stretch between MM 100 and MM 104 is the gauntlet. That is where the grocery stores are. That’s where the K-Mart (now closed but still a landmark) and the big shopping centers sit. You have people turning left across traffic, people pulling out of dive shops, and tourists looking for the African Queen boat without watching the road.
The Toll of Environment and Infrastructure
You can't just "build more lanes" in Key Largo. This isn't Orlando.
The environment dictates the road. We are talking about a narrow island chain flanked by the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary and the Everglades. Environmental regulations are incredibly strict. Expanding U.S. 1 any further would mean dredging or destroying vital seagrasses and mangroves. FDOT has to balance human frustration with ecological preservation.
There’s also the drawbridge factor. While the Jewfish Creek Bridge is high-span now (thank god), other bridges further down can still cause ripples of delays. If one boat takes a long time to clear, the line of cars grows exponentially. It’s a butterfly effect. A three-minute bridge opening at Snake Creek (down in Islamorada) can cause a backup that reaches all the way into southern Key Largo.
Real Tips for Dodging the Worst of It
- The Mid-Week Rule: If you can travel on a Tuesday or Wednesday, do it. The road is virtually empty compared to the weekend chaos.
- The "Early Bird" Myth: Getting there at 10:00 AM on a Saturday is not "early." The rush has already started. If you want to beat the traffic, you need to be crossing the Monroe County line by 7:30 AM.
- Monitor the Monroe County Sheriff's App: They are pretty good about posting real-time accident alerts. If the Stretch is closed, you must take Card Sound. If you don't check, you might sit behind a police blockade for three hours.
- Gas Up in Florida City: Don’t wait until you get onto the islands. Prices jump the second you cross that bridge, and if you’re idling in traffic for an hour, you don't want to be watching your fuel light flicker.
Let’s Talk About the "Bumper-to-Bumper" Psychology
Driving in the Keys requires a different mindset. If you drive like you’re on I-95 in Miami, you’re going to get frustrated and probably get a ticket. The speed limits drop fast. It goes from 55 to 45 to 35 in some spots. And the Monroe County deputies? They don't play. They know exactly where people speed up out of frustration, and they’ll be waiting.
👉 See also: Exactly How Far is Nice from Paris and the Best Ways to Get There
There is a certain "island time" that people joke about, but when it comes to Key Largo traffic, it’s a forced reality. You have to accept that you will move slowly.
I once saw a guy try to pass on the shoulder near the median. Not only is that illegal, but it’s incredibly dangerous because of the cyclists. The Florida Keys Overseas Heritage Trail runs parallel to the highway. People are walking, biking, and fishing right next to the road.
Seasonality is Everything
If you visit in October, you’ll wonder what all the fuss is about. The roads are clear. You can get a table at Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen without a wait.
If you visit during "Mini-Season"—the two-day spiny lobster sport season in late July—you are entering a circle of hell. It is arguably the busiest traffic event of the year. Thousands of boat trailers clog the roads. Boat ramps overflow onto the highway. It is pure, unadulterated chaos. Unless you are there to dive for bugs, stay far, far away from Key Largo during those 48 hours.
Navigating the Local "Choke Points"
There are specific spots where everything just grinds to a halt.
- The "S" Curve at MM 106: This is where the road bends as you enter the island. People slow down because the view of the water hits them for the first time.
- The Shopping Centers (MM 101-99): This is the commercial heart. Constant turning traffic creates a "stop-and-go" rhythm that can drive you crazy.
- Tavernier Creek Bridge: As you leave Key Largo and head toward Islamorada, the road narrows slightly and the speed limit changes. It’s a natural braking point.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Trip
Stop treating the drive to Key Largo as something to "get through" and start planning around the reality of the infrastructure.
First, check the Florida 511 app before you leave Florida City. It gives you a live look at traffic cameras on the Stretch. If you see a sea of red, divert to Card Sound Road immediately.
Second, adjust your arrival and departure times. If you are staying for the weekend, try to check out and leave by 10:00 AM on Sunday, or wait until after 7:00 PM. Most people try to squeeze out every last drop of sun and leave at 2:00 PM, which is exactly why the traffic is backed up for ten miles.
Third, embrace the pit stop. If the traffic is grueling, pull over. Grab a coffee at a local spot or walk around a marina for an hour. The traffic will likely be the same or better an hour later, and your blood pressure will be significantly lower.
Finally, keep your eyes on the road. A huge percentage of the "random" backups in Key Largo are caused by rubbernecking at minor accidents or even just people looking at iguanas on the side of the road. Don't be that person. Focus on the drive, get to your destination, and then you can stare at the water all you want.