Gaming used to be simpler. You bought a disc, you popped it into the console, and you played until the credits rolled. Those days are long gone. Now, if you want to do basically anything online with your PS5, you’re looking at a monthly bill. Sony’s subscription service has morphed into this three-headed beast that’s honestly kind of confusing if you haven't looked at the store page in a few months. Deciding to subscribe to PlayStation Plus isn't just about getting "free" games anymore—it's about calculating how much of your free time you’re willing to trade for a massive digital library.
Sony overhauled the whole system back in 2022, ditching the old "Plus and Now" separation for a tiered structure. It was a clear response to Xbox Game Pass, but it feels different. It’s less about day-one releases and more about a massive backlog of nostalgia and polished AAA titles.
What You’re Actually Buying: The Tier Breakdown
If you're sitting there with your controller wondering which button to press, you’ve got three choices: Essential, Extra, and Premium. Most people just grab Essential because it’s the cheapest. It’s the "I just want to play Call of Duty or FC 26 online" tax. You get the monthly games, cloud saves, and the ability to get yelled at by teenagers in a lobby. That’s it.
Then things get spicy.
The Extra tier is where most gamers find the "sweet spot," though that phrase is a bit overused. It includes the Game Catalog. Think of it like Netflix but for games like Ghost of Tsushima or Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart. You’re getting hundreds of PS4 and PS5 games. If you just bought a PS5 and have no library, this is the one. It’s a no-brainer. Seriously. You’d spend way more buying those games individually on sale than you would on a yearly sub.
The Premium Problem
Then there’s Premium. Honestly? It’s a bit of a mixed bag. You get "Classics," which means PS1, PS2, and PSP games. Some are great. Some look like a pixelated mess on a 4K TV. The real draw here is game trials and cloud streaming. If you have bad internet, do not—I repeat, do not—buy Premium for the streaming. It will stutter. You will get frustrated. You will regret the extra twenty bucks. But if you're a trophy hunter who wants to try a game for two hours before committing, it has its niche.
📖 Related: The Streamer of the Year 2025 Vote: Why Most People Got It Wrong
Why People Get Frustrated With the Service
There's a lot of noise online about the price hikes. Sony bumped the prices up significantly in late 2023, and the community hasn't exactly forgotten. A yearly sub to Essential used to be $59.99; now it's $79.99. Extra and Premium followed suit.
- Essential: $79.99 / year
- Extra: $134.99 / year
- Premium: $159.99 / year
It’s a lot of money to drop at once. Some gamers argue that the "monthly games" have dropped in quality lately. One month you get a banger like Sifu, the next you get a simulator about power washing or a niche sports title nobody asked for. It's a gamble. You’re paying for the potential of a good game, not a guarantee.
Cloud saves are the other sticking point. It feels a little predatory that you can’t back up your PS5 save files to a USB stick like you could on the PS4. Sony locked that feature behind the Plus wall. If you want to ensure your 100-hour Elden Ring save doesn't vanish if your console dies, you basically have to subscribe to PlayStation Plus. It’s a bit of a "gotcha" move that leaves a sour taste for some.
The Catalog vs. Game Pass
We have to talk about the elephant in the room. Microsoft’s Game Pass puts their biggest games on the service the day they launch. Sony doesn't. You won't see Spider-Man 3 or the next God of War on PS Plus the day they hit shelves. Sony’s leadership, specifically folks like Hiroki Totoki, have been pretty vocal about why: they think it devalues their big-budget "prestige" titles.
They want you to pay $70 for the new stuff.
However, the PS Plus Extra catalog is arguably "higher quality" if you prefer single-player, cinematic experiences. While Game Pass has more variety and day-one indies, Plus Extra is packed with those heavy-hitting Sony exclusives. If you missed out on the PS4 era, subscribing to Extra is like walking into a gold mine. You have Bloodborne, The Last of Us Remastered, and Horizon Forbidden West just sitting there waiting for you.
Don't Forget the "Collection" Controversy
Remember the PS Plus Collection? It was a group of 20 era-defining games given to PS5 owners. Sony killed that off in May 2023. It was a huge bummer for late adopters. Now, if you want those games, you're either buying them or hoping they're in the Extra catalog. It’s a reminder that these digital services are fluid. Things disappear. Licenses expire. You don't "own" these games; you're just renting the license.
If you stop paying, the games lock.
That’s the scary part for some. You build this massive library over five years, but the second you stop that recurring payment, your library becomes a graveyard of locked icons. It’s the ultimate "tether" to the ecosystem.
Technical Stuff Most People Ignore
Let’s get into the weeds for a second. Remote Play and Share Play. If you subscribe to PlayStation Plus, you can use Share Play to let a friend "take over" your controller virtually. They don't even need to own the game. You can be sitting in New York, and they can play your copy of Street Fighter from London. It’s surprisingly low-latency if you both have fiber.
Then there’s the Game Help feature. If you’re stuck on a puzzle in Astro Bot, you can pull up a little video hint window that shows you exactly what to do. It’s better than Googling and getting spoiled by a thumbnail. It’s a small, "premium" feeling touch that actually adds value to the daily experience of using the console.
The Streaming Reality
Sony bought Gaikai and OnLive years ago to build their streaming tech. It’s gotten better. On the Premium tier, you can stream PS5 games directly to your console without downloading them. This is great for those 100GB behemoths that you just want to try out. But again—and I cannot stress this enough—your home network needs to be solid. Hardwired ethernet is basically mandatory for a good time here. Wi-Fi 6 helps, but it’s still risky.
How to Get the Best Deal (The "Pro" Strategy)
Don't just pay full price. That's the first rule of the PS Plus club.
Sony almost always runs a massive sale during "Days of Play" in June and again around Black Friday in November. Usually, you can snag 25% to 30% off the annual price. If your sub expires in March, just buy a one-month sub to bridge the gap until the big sales hit.
Also, watch out for the "New Subscriber Only" deals. Sony loves to bait new people with 50% off while making loyal long-term fans pay the full "loyalty tax." If you have a second account or a family member, sometimes it's cheaper to start a "new" sub on their profile and set that console as the "Primary" PS5. This shares the online play and the downloaded games across all accounts on that machine.
Is It Right For You?
If you play Warzone, Fortnite, or Apex Legends, you actually don't need to subscribe to PlayStation Plus. Free-to-play games are exempt from the requirement. You can jump into those right now for zero dollars.
But for everything else?
If you're a "one game a year" person who only plays Madden, Essential is a necessary evil. If you're a "I want to see what all the hype is about" person, Extra is the best value in gaming right now, arguably better than Game Pass for pure cinematic quality. Premium is mostly for people with nostalgia for the 90s or those who have more money than time.
Immediate Next Steps to Take
Instead of just hitting "Accept" on your console, do these three things first to make sure you aren't wasting money:
- Check your internet speed. If you’re pulling less than 50Mbps down, forget the Premium tier's streaming features. It won't work well.
- Audit the "Game Catalog" list online. Go to the official PlayStation website and scroll through the Extra catalog. If you already own 70% of those games, the Extra tier is a waste of your money.
- Wait for a holiday. If it’s anywhere near June or November, do not buy a full year. Buy one month and wait for the "Days of Play" or Black Friday discounts to stack your membership.
- Download your "Monthly Games" even if you don't play them. Just "Add to Library." As long as you have a sub, they stay there. If you don't add them during their specific month, they’re gone forever.
The reality of modern gaming is that the console is just the entry fee. The subscription is the ongoing cost of the hobby. Choose the tier that matches your actual playtime, not the one that sounds most "impressive" on paper. Most of us really just need the Extra tier to stay busy for a lifetime.