You’re standing in the personal care aisle, staring at that bright gold bar. It’s iconic. It’s cheap. It smells like "clean." But if your skin feels like it’s currently being attacked by a thousand tiny fire ants, you’re probably wondering: is Dial soap good for eczema, or am I about to make a massive mistake?
Skin is weird. Eczema is weirder.
Most people with atopic dermatitis (the medical name for the most common type of eczema) spend their lives hunting for a "holy grail" cleanser. They want something that kills bacteria but doesn't strip their skin into a desert landscape. Dial, specifically the classic Gold bar, has a reputation that’s basically split down the middle. Some people swear it cured their weeping eczema. Others say it’s like washing with sandpaper and battery acid.
The Science of the "Squeaky Clean" Feeling
Here’s the thing about Dial. It’s a true soap. In the world of dermatology, there’s a massive difference between a "soap" and a "syndet" (synthetic detergent) bar like Dove or Cetaphil.
Traditional soaps are alkaline. Your skin’s natural barrier—the acid mantle—is slightly acidic, sitting around a pH of 4.5 to 5.5. Dial Gold has a pH that usually sits much higher, often around 9 or 10. When you put something that alkaline on eczema-prone skin, you’re essentially disrupting the lipid barrier. You know that "squeaky" feeling you get after rinsing? That’s not actually cleanliness. It’s the sound of your skin’s natural oils being dragged away into the drain.
For a lot of people, this is why the answer to is Dial soap good for eczema is a hard no. If your barrier is already broken, adding a high-pH soap can trigger a flare-up that lasts for weeks.
What’s actually inside the bar?
Dial’s active ingredient used to be Triclosan, but the FDA banned that in consumer soaps a few years back because of safety concerns and lack of evidence that it was better than plain soap and water. Now, they mostly use Benzalkonium Chloride.
- It’s an antimicrobial.
- It kills staph.
- It’s potent.
But it’s also a known irritant for some. If you have a fragrance sensitivity—which is common for eczema patients—the heavy scent in Dial Gold is basically a chemical red flag.
Why Do Some Dermatologists Actually Recommend It?
This is where it gets confusing. You’ll find people online saying their doctor told them to use Dial. Why would a medical professional recommend a harsh, alkaline soap for someone with a compromised skin barrier?
It comes down to Staphylococcus aureus.
People with eczema have a higher-than-normal colonization of staph bacteria on their skin. When you scratch, you create micro-tears. The staph gets in. You get an infection. This creates a vicious cycle of inflammation.
In some specific cases, doctors suggest an antimicrobial soap like Dial to "decolonize" the skin. It’s a poor man’s bleach bath. By knocking down the bacterial load, the skin can sometimes stop overreacting. So, in this very specific context, is Dial soap good for eczema? It might be, but only as a short-term tool to manage bacteria, not as a long-term hydration strategy.
The Dial "Power" Bar vs. The Alternatives
Honestly, if you have "angry" eczema—red, weeping, or cracked—Dial is probably going to sting like crazy.
✨ Don't miss: Sore Dog Paws Between Toes: What Your Vet Wishes You Knew About Interdigital Cysts and Beyond
Think about the ingredients. Sodium Tallowate. Sodium Cocoate. These are surfactants that are great at removing grease from a mechanic's hands. They aren't necessarily what you want on the delicate, thin skin of an infant or someone with chronic dermatitis.
If you’re dead set on using the brand, they do make a "Spring Water" version or a "Power Berries" version, but the Gold bar is the one people usually talk about for "medicinal" uses. It’s aggressive. It’s old school. It doesn't care about your feelings or your moisture levels.
Compare that to something like the Vanicream Cleansing Bar. Vanicream is formulated specifically to stay near the skin’s natural pH. It doesn’t have the antimicrobial "kick" that Dial has, but it also won't make you want to peel your skin off after a shower.
The Staph Factor
Let's talk about Dr. Richard Gallo's research at UC San Diego. His team has done a ton of work on the skin microbiome. They found that people with eczema lack the "good" bacteria that naturally fight off the "bad" staph. When you use a heavy-duty antimicrobial soap like Dial, you aren't just killing the bad guys. You’re carpet-bombing the entire ecosystem.
You kill the staph, sure. But you also kill the Staphylococcus hominis and Staphylococcus epidermidis—the "hero" bacteria that actually produce natural antimicrobial peptides.
Once you stop using the Dial, the staph often grows back faster than the good stuff. It’s like clearing a forest and wondering why the weeds are the first things to sprout.
Real World Feedback: The Good, The Bad, and The Itchy
I’ve spent a lot of time lurking in eczema forums. The anecdotes are wild.
One user on a popular skincare subreddit claimed that Dial Gold was the only thing that stopped their "weeping" eczema on their legs. They used it once a day, followed immediately by a thick layer of petrolatum (Vaseline).
🔗 Read more: How Much Protein in an Ounce of Chicken: The Real Math for Your Muscles
On the flip side, another user reported that one single wash with Dial resulted in a "full-body flare" that required a round of prednisone to calm down.
The difference? Probably the state of their skin barrier at the time. If your eczema is "dry and scaly," Dial is likely a disaster. If your eczema is "wet and infected," the antimicrobial properties might actually provide temporary relief.
Fragrance: The Silent Trigger
We have to talk about the smell. That medicinal, floral, "clean" scent is a cocktail of synthetic fragrances.
For about 15% of the population, fragrance is a contact allergen. For eczema patients, that number is way higher. Even if the antimicrobial part of the soap helps with bacteria, the fragrance could be causing a secondary allergic contact dermatitis. Now you have two problems instead of one.
If you’re asking is Dial soap good for eczema, you have to ask yourself if you’ve ever reacted to perfumes or scented candles. If the answer is yes, keep Dial far away from your shower.
How to Test It Without Ruining Your Life
If you’re determined to try it—maybe because it’s $3 for a pack of three and you’re tired of spending $15 on "medical" washes—don't just hop in the shower and lather up your whole body.
- The Spot Test: Pick a small, non-flared area. Maybe your inner forearm.
- Wash and Wait: Wash that one spot. Rinse thoroughly. Wait 24 hours.
- Check for Tightness: Does the skin feel "tight" or look shiny? That’s a sign of dehydration.
- The "Crisis" Use: Only use it on the areas that feel "infected" or extra itchy, rather than using it as a full-body wash.
Better Ways to Kill Bacteria
If you’re using Dial because you’re worried about infection, there are "eczema-safe" ways to handle that.
- Diluted Bleach Baths: Sounds scary, but it’s actually highly recommended by the American Academy of Dermatology. It’s like a swimming pool. Half a cup of regular bleach in a full tub of water. It kills the staph without the harsh surfactants found in bar soap.
- Hypochlorous Acid Sprays: This is a game-changer. It’s a substance your white blood cells naturally produce. You can buy it in a spray bottle (brands like Tower 28 or various medical-grade ones). It kills bacteria but has a neutral pH and doesn’t strip oils.
- CLn Wash: This is basically a "designer" version of a bleach bath in a body wash form. It’s expensive, but it’s formulated specifically for eczema.
The Verdict on Dial
Is it "good"? Not really.
Is it "useful"? Sometimes.
Dial is a blunt instrument. It’s a sledgehammer when you might only need a small mallet. If you have extremely oily skin and secondary infections, you might get away with it. But for the vast majority of people with the "itch that rashes," Dial is simply too aggressive.
The goal of eczema management is to keep the moisture in and the irritants out. Dial does the opposite—it pulls the moisture out and introduces fragrance and high-alkalinity irritants.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Shower
If you're currently dealing with a flare-up, stop looking at the Dial. Instead, try this routine:
- Lukewarm only: Hot water triggers histamine release. It feels good for a second, then it's hell.
- Soap-free cleansers: Look for the National Eczema Association (NEA) Seal of Acceptance. Brands like CeraVe, Cetaphil, or La Roche-Posay (their Lipikar line is incredible) are much safer bets.
- The Three-Minute Rule: You have a three-minute window after getting out of the shower to lock in moisture. Pat dry—don't rub—and slather on a thick cream (not a lotion) while your skin is still damp.
- Ointment over Cream: If you're really dry, creams might sting because they contain water and preservatives. Ointments (like Aquaphor or plain Vaseline) are safer for broken skin.
If you absolutely must use an antimicrobial, look for the Dial Basics (which is harder to find now) or the Dial Sensitive liquid wash. They are slightly milder than the Gold bar. But honestly? Just stick to something that doesn't smell like a 1970s locker room. Your skin barrier will thank you.
Summary Checklist for Eczema Sufferers
- Check the pH: If it's over 7, be careful.
- Smell it: If it's strong, it's probably wrong.
- Feel it: If your skin feels "tight" after, stop using it immediately.
- Consult: If you see yellow crusting or red streaks, stop the DIY soap experiments and see a doctor—you might need actual antibiotics.
The "clean" feeling is a lie. True health for eczema skin feels soft, a bit boring, and definitely not "squeaky."