@Ultimaodin, hehe yeah, I happened across the thought to use something like
Xena's circlet throwing weapon. Or even if I used the boomerang, where do you go from there? And doesn't the boomerang or aiselne weapon seem more powerful than a crossbow, yet the crossbow is more accurate and would reach farther; it's unclear which is superior. I'm trying to make it obvious each weapon is greater than the one before it. This is the trouble with not keeping each weapon in the series all in the same "type". The other sets have a clear hierarchy because they're just the same basic weapon, it just gets a little bigger between levels.
@politopo, thanks for the interesting ideas. Long-reaching polearms are a nice idea but I wouldn't be able to get much detail in since I'd have to render them small in order to fit them into the image's dimensions, plus the Sound Dept. weapons already cover "chopping" weapons, and the Coder Dept is covering "slicing/slashing".
@Photo, yeah I really wanted to stay with hand/gauntlet weapons, but I can't seem to come up 4 good ones, which all get better per level up. Thought about using an
NES Powerglove for the 4th and final weapon. If I did something like brass knuckles for the 1st weapon, it wouldn't stack up well against a hammer, axe or sword now would it?
_______
In order to just get the show on the road, why don't I just do projectile weapons. . . Those are easily superior to other departments' melee weapon sets, which is the point of the PL weapons - they have to be able to trump all others.
So here's my official starting point:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/11a9d/11a9d1a066049a43907ac698e92c30e9a9b3e053" alt=""
-The crossbow doesn't fit in well, though it is sufficiently primitive, making a good lvl 1 weapon.
-Would be better if #2 (top right) was a better bridge between 1 and 3, there's too much of a jump in technology. I might make #1 an ancient crappy
flint-lock pistol.
-#4 is an all-out modern warfare rifle, includes an RPG launcher, and complete with evil Rambo bayonet. It's kinda ridiculous.