Forest guardian

[TheForgottenOne]

Hello!
i need feedback for this pixel art.
I got a version with line and one without it, I want to know which of the two is better. and what is wrong in it


With Line:


Without line:

[ChillTaco]

I like without lines a lot better. Just a personal liking for that kind of pixel. I suppose with line might contrast bettter if the greens of the forest are to simular. buuuutttt, blending in with the forest may suit the character.

[astrofra]

Without line is 10times better

[Double7]

I really think the not outlined one is better. All i would suggest for this is to make the face a bit darker so that it contrasts a bit and gives a hooded feel with some cool glowing eyes.

All preference. What you have is great

[TheForgottenOne]

Thanks for the feedback!
I do this edit:

[lachrymose]

To many straight lines, organic forms are generally more curvey. Especially leaves.

[Friend]

I find the straight lines charming in this case. I love the design. Things that for certain could be better is removing the banding and better AA.  Subjective fixes I'd suggest is perhaps rethinking color and light. I imagine you can really make this character stand out with more glowey and atmospheric light and color. I envision it particularly with more luminescent eyes