Critique Needed - My First Major Pixel Art Project

[TMT]

So I've dabbled in pixel art for about a year now making some platformer tilesets for fun and just generally goofing around. I guess I was just in a pixel art kind of mood today so I started on a landscape. Its still a WIP, but I could use some feedback, and to know if its worth continuing. Thanks!

[Pusty]

I like it!
I really like the dithering ^^
But the water reflexion(?) looks kinda odd to me.
I would like to see this as a finished piece ^^

[Julito98]

  its seems pretty cool to me, nice use of AA and Dithering, i only think that you can use an more shiny color to illuminate those towers, good luck!

[TMT]

Thanks for the feedback guys! I've been working on it a bit more. I worked on the lighting on the tower a bit like you suggested Julito. As far as the reflection goes, I think I'm going to just redo it once I have the scene its reflecting finished since I think thats where I went wrong to begin with.


Also, do you guys think the color palette is okay? I'm used to working in grayscale.

[Julito98]

Thanks for the feedback guys! I've been working on it a bit more. I worked on the lighting on the tower a bit like you suggested Julito. As far as the reflection goes, I think I'm going to just redo it once I have the scene its reflecting finished since I think thats where I went wrong to begin with.


Also, do you guys think the color palette is okay? I'm used to working in grayscale.

i feel pretty happy that my advice help you on your piece 

[Decroded]

hi and welcome 

no time to help much but I wanna say I love this and definitely worth developing.
look forward to see more from u 

[TMT]

Thanks decroded!, that means a lot having seen the quality of your work.   

I've been working on detailing the left rock-face, and the clouds. Its starting to come together. 

[TMT]

I think its almost done. Hopefully this reflection is a bit better than the last one.

[Pusty]

wow, awesome! (I'm shocked how much highlighting things helps improving them)
Nice development !

[Shackhal]

Since the first to the last there's a huge change. Looks great, but still doesn't satisfy me the mountain. I fell those rocks on the left side are very big ass rocks and that they are not part of the mountain.