Edit: sorry, doesnt matter, this is just meant to be a bit of fun. Dont take anything personally Kal, I'm just in a mood 

I really liked the greeny blues on the lighthouse, I'm also not keen on the banded shading on the second roof, but yeah the colours could be reduced a bit, and light cast by the fire is good - however the shadows shouldnt be so harsh, they're still in areas hit by the main lightsource.

I guess I'll take 99.

I hope no-one minds me reworking my tiles a little, I thought the top was looking a bit bland now the rest of its looking so good.

finished my last tile, and found the missing yellow. excellent work everyone!

Sohashu, I think it would be a shame to have your tiles edited because, as someone already mentioned, the nice thing about this is that everyones tile is unique to them.

I will do some c&c though if I may.

As it stands your tiles do stand out a bit, not because of technical ability, but there are a few things that stops them fitting into the overall style.

Now I know there were only a few tiles to work from when you did yours, but looking over the rest of the peice now I can see:
-edge tiles have a black outline
-characters have a black/dark outline
-characters have very distinctive proportions
-characters are flat shaded

I see one thing you did pick up on was TakaMs short grass style (although you might want to check some of the angles of the darker lines) so that helps.

I think following the points above would make the world of difference. Probably the hardest would be if you wanted to adapt your character to the proportions of the others. I had a rough go myself:


The only other point I would make is that some of the parts seem a little obscure, I'm not sure what the things either side of the character are, but youve done a good job putting some motion into the scene.

________

if no-one thinks it greedy of me I'd like to reserve 100.