bengoshia, I don't think your edit helped at all besides in color choice. The chestplate looks flat, the legs lack depth, and stance is very strange which makes the character look surprised. I personally feel that the original is much better.

Glide, your edit helps a lot, it makes the colors pop a lot more then the current tiles and helps with the depth issue. The only problem I see with the old tiles, though more original they lack in giving the tiles a cave-like feel. Also because of the multiple platforms it looks like the character could easily walk up it at any height and they act more as stairs than anything.

I didn't attempt to post the newest sprites or mock-ups. As Glide said the sprite has changed and the shadow of the palm tree has changed. As I stated, the other artists appreciate the critiques on all the mock-ups made by them, and I do also, but that is not what this topic is dedicated too. I updated the first post to make it easier to comprehend what I am asking for. It is most likely my fault for not making it clear enough in the first place.

I am looking for critiques on the furniture, floor, and wall tiles because I feel that the style isn't cohesive with the current tiles in the mock-ups made by the other two artists. Also, I feel that some proportions are off and any other help or ideas on how to make the furniture, floor, and wall tiles better is welcome.

Edit:

I put an hour or so into trying out some cave tiles, here is what I came up with.


I thought I should post them here for critiques before I go any further. Obviously they are very mucky so far, but other then that I feel that they look more like a mountain cliff then a cave platform.

I'm sorry if I did not make this clear. I am looking for advice on the tilesets to make it match the current style of the mock-ups below. Nonetheless, I think the advice can be appriciated by the other Sylph artists. Another thing I forgot to mention or edit out of the tileset is the bed is not finished. I am having a hard time finishing it.

Yes, some screens are outdated.